DFIP-2202-A: Deposit of a Masternode as security for a loan

DFIP Overview

Requester(s): derstrecker [Github] aka Abuna Semai [Telegram] Proposal fee (50 DFI) txid: https://defiscan.live/transactions/c896085910eafa33762b6ab073f2019145fa58c96ad7427999a2bd52b28c4eeb Inspired by Agent Switters :)

When the Freezer-Masternodes (MN) were introduced, there was the idea of enabling a change of owner of a Freezer-MN at some point, i.e. the sale. Based on this, the following idea:

The owner of a house can generate rental income as well as take out a mortgage on the house in order to be liquid. The same financial principle can also apply to masternodes: The rental income corresponds to the rewards, the mortgage to the following:

Possible deposit of a MN as security for a loan. This loan can amount to a maximum of 10K in dUSD, in order to remain at the maximum of an auction tranche (anything else is likely to be too complicated to implement for the time being). If the value of the MN falls below 10K (unlikely, but not impossible), the collateral (here the MN) can be auctioned off, as usual. I.e. after a successful auction, a change of owner takes place. According the Defichain-Masternode Telegram-channel, the function for transferring a masternode is already programmed, just not yet implemented. Since the masternodes run on the desktop wallet, the Vault/Loan function must be added there.

The Dfip includes:

Desktop Wallet is upgraded to include the Vaults/Loans function (UI)
Implementation of the possibility to transfer a masternode to a new owner
Possible deposit of a MN as collateral for a loan, 10K dUSD lending only
Masternodes in debt can not be transferred

In this update optional, not mandatory:

Different fee rates for the freezer nodes
Loan scheme 200% per default as additional security, can be changed by the user within the usual limits

In order to take into account the higher value of a freezer MN, the lending rates can be adjusted accordingly. According to the current value, a normal MN would have a collateralisation ratio of 670% and would be subject to a selected min. coll. ratio of e.g. 200%, which would cost 2% in fees. A 5Y freezer node could have a 25% discount on these fees, and a 10Y freezer node could have a 50% discount. The min. coll. ratio can be determined by the borrower as before within the scope of possibilities.

Network Security The network would not be subject to instability since an auction and a change of owner would be quick. Freezer MNs can still not be resigned after an owner change and keeps on its original freeze-duration (current share of freezer MN in the network: 31%, as of 26.1.2022, according to statistics from mydefichain). Also, the liquidation of a MN is unlikely, as with 20,000 Dfi of the MN and minimum collateralisation of 150%, the Dfi price would have to fall to 0.667 cents. In addition, if the existing vaults or a separate type of vault with otherwise similar functionality are equipped with this option, there is the security that the MN owner can add additional tokens for protection, such as dUSDC or dBTC, until the Dfi share reaches the usual minimum 50%, thus doubling the protection.

Since all masternode owners benefit from this, everyone was invited to help setting it up by helping to raise the Dfip fees, which are 50 Dfi in total. These are already collected on this address: https://defiscan.live/address/dbDmgzKrBA86QiZtceUbEkUJrREQQGLxqj

How does this DFIP benefit the DeFiChain community?

Will add another feature as to decentralize finance: leveraging Masternodes.
It would encourage more people to set up (and keep) Masternodes if they can also utilize those assets by leveraging them and putting into other uses or mining [Dcshel].
For many, this is interesting for tax reasons, as despite the holding period of 1 year for tax exemption, one still remains somewhat liquid.
Since this is interesting for all MN owners, this can mint 107,380,000 dUSD into the Defichain ecosystem, since at the moment of writing there are currently 10,738 Masternodes (https://mydeficha.in/en/index.php?site=calculator).
This honours the current 3,331 and future freezer-masterode operators for their commitment and reduces their risk.
For decentralising Defichain, many more private MN are needed, since 7866 of 10812 MN are run by Cake (https://mydeficha.in/en/index.php?site=masternodes), means almost 73%. So an incentive to set up a new node should be welcomed.

GERMAN

DFIP Übersicht

Antragsteller: derstrecker [Github] aka Abuna Semai [Telegram] Vorschlagsgebühr (50 DFI) txid: https://defiscan.live/transactions/c896085910eafa33762b6ab073f2019145fa58c96ad7427999a2bd52b28c4eeb Inspiriert von Agent Switters :)

Bei Eröffnung der Freezer-Masternodes (MN) gab es die Idee irgendwann einmal einen Ownerwechsel einer Freezer-MN zu ermöglichen, also den Verkauf. Darauf aufbauend folgende Idee:

Der Besitzer eines Hauses kann sowohl Mieteinnahmen generieren, als auch sich eine Hypothek auf das Haus aufnehmen, um liquide zu sein. Dasselbe Finanzprinzip kann auch für Masternodes gelten: Die Mieteeinnahmen entsprechen dabei den Rewards, die Hypothek dem folgenden:

Mögliche Hinterlegung einer MN als Sicherheit für einen Loan. Dieser Loan kann maximal 10K in dUSD betragen, um beim Maximum einer Auktionstranche zu bleiben (alles Andere dürfte vorerst von der Umsetzung zu kompliziert werden). Fällt der Wert der MN unter die 10K (unwahrscheinlich, aber nicht unmöglich), kann das Collateral (hier die MN) ersteigert werden, so wie gehabt. Dh nach einer erfolgreichen Versteigerung findet ein Ownerwechsel statt. Laut dem Defichain-Masternode Telegram-Kanal ist die Funktion zum Übertragen eines Masternodes bereits programmiert, nur noch nicht implementiert. Da die Masternodes auf der Desktop-Wallet laufen, muss die Vault/Loan-Funktion dort hinzugefügt werden.

Das Dfip beinhaltet:

Desktop Wallet wird um die Funktion der Vaults/Loans ergänzt (UI)
Implementierung der Möglichkeit eine Masternode auf einen neuen Eigentümer zu übertragen
Mögliche Hinterlegung einer MN als Sicherheit für einen Loan, nur 10K dUSD Beleihung
Beliehene Masternodes können nicht übertragen werden

In diesem Update optional, nicht obligatorisch:

Unterschiedliche Gebührensätze für die Freezer Nodes
Darlehensregelung 200% als Standard für zusätzliche Sicherheit, kann vom Nutzer in den üblichen Rahmen verändert werden

Um den höheren Wert einer gefreezten MN zu berücksichtigen, können die Beleihungszinsen entsprechend angepasst sein. Nach aktuellem Wert hätte eine normale MN 670% Collateralization Ratio und würde bei einer gewählten Min. Coll. Ratio von z.B. 200% 2% Gebühren kosten. Bei einer 5Y gefreezten Node könnte ein Rabatt auf diese Gebühren von 25% erfolgen, bei einer 10Y gefreezten von 50%. Die Min. Coll. Ratio kann dabei wie bisher auch vom Loan-Nehmer im Rahmen der Möglichkeiten selbst bestimmt werden.

Netzwerksicherheit Das Netz wäre nicht instabil, da eine Versteigerung und ein Wechsel des Eigentümers schnell erfolgen würden. Freezer-MN können nach einem Ownerwechsel weiterhin nicht aufgelöst werden und behalten ihre ursprüngliche Freeze-Dauer bei (aktueller Anteil der Freezer-MN im Netzwerk: 31%, Stand 26.1.2022, laut Statistik von mydefichain). Auch ist die Liquidierung einer MN unwahrscheinlich, da bei 20.000 Dfi der MN und Mindestbesicherung von 150% der Dfi-Preis auf 0,667 Cent fallen müsste. Zusätzlich besteht die Sicherheit, wenn die bisherigen Vaults oder eine gesonderte Art von Vaults mit sonst gleicher Funktionsweise mit dieser Möglichkeit bestückt werden, dass der MN-Owner zusätzlich weitere Token zur Absicherung, wie dUSDC oder dBTC hinzufügen kann, bis der Dfi-Anteil die üblichen Mindest-50% beträgt, somit die Absicherung verdoppelt werden kann.

Da alle Masternode-Besitzer davon profitieren, wurde jeder eingeladen, bei der Einrichtung zu helfen, indem sie die Dfip-Gebühren, die insgesamt 50 Dfi betragen, gemeinsam aufbringen. Diese werden bereits unter dieser Adresse gesammelt: https://defiscan.live/address/dbDmgzKrBA86QiZtceUbEkUJrREQQGLxqj

Wie profitiert die DeFiChain-Gemeinschaft von diesem DFIP?

Fügt eine weitere Funktion zur Dezentralisierung der Finanzen hinzu: die Hebelwirkung von Masternodes.
Es würde mehr Leute dazu ermutigen, Masternodes einzurichten (und zu behalten), wenn sie dieses Vermögen auch nutzen können, indem sie es hebeln und in andere Zwecke oder Mining stecken [Dcshel].
Für viele ist dies aus steuerlichen Gründen interessant, da man trotz der Haltedauer von 1 Jahr für die Steuerbefreiung noch etwas liquide bleibt.
Da dies für alle MN-Besitzer interessant ist, können dadurch 107.380.000 dUSD in das Defichain-Ökosystem fließen, denn zum Zeitpunkt der Erstellung dieses Artikels gibt es derzeit 10.738 Masternodes (https://mydeficha.in/en/index.php?site=calculator).
Dies ehrt die aktuellen 3.331 und künftige Freezer-Masternode Betreiber für ihr Engagement und verkleinert ihr Risiko.
Um Defichain zu dezentralisieren, werden viel mehr private MN benötigt, da 7866 von 10812 MN von Cake (https://mydeficha.in/en/index.php?site=masternodes) betrieben werden, also fast 73%. Ein Anreiz zur Einrichtung einer neuen Masternode sollte daher begrüßt werden.

Non-obligation

I understand that vote of confidence for DFIP carries no obligations by any developers to implement the proposals. DeFiChain is a community projects. Pull requests can be submitted by community and reserved to be evaluated for safety and general community acceptance.

defi-cli signmessage 8Lb2YBdFHTbioN1e3RGf1Vvprrj7da8Srs DFIP-2202-A-yes H0GaOqR2JXE/ktAHbfB8crIiy5P/xAlHZhKwBJfPDtqINCxYO2b6RucSV4y0esoPqQJYW5INo3slXwnpfMaKQxQ=

$ defi-cli signmessage 8cWRypxsZgTKjSMCZm7UQTV9C4X7tStZGM "dfip-2202-a-no" H2dEzzCTI/6NVv4IxpMOdejTz6C5C8tcMp2uAR7ORQOmOyuNwqR41O5XPD+Uc38D1OdODrTOH3F1xUJ9200tbOM=

$ defi-cli signmessage 8QHLgmQVqMFQyN3cjPU2EDoKv7enHKstyn "dfip-2202-a-no" INFf1FpQV5QNkamk3eOm4fAP4byzGV92o37MS68H5Xj6YQXzL88y3f9WD5fP+j2mxTpFyDaSLA9H7wGyiWkIKPc=

$ defi-cli signmessage 8ZoH6xB8kmA7EqvRu8yd7e1ARXLVf36LtZ "cfp-2202-04-no" H6qTqCt4CsjpEOuY65hqbsJPRjmfj+/GNglJgzPEQl72dLd0OLNrOgDqGpZlta6Chuhu7IsdLJhUItlNvqEzEMg= $ defi-cli signmessage 8cdaZANhAHEA3LcNrqJe5fT4ZGZcF5F2Ry "cfp-2202-04-no" IEQQynktmO8f/nbQgMUlQ3pmguch7vtU/ItDs4Jz8EPyAAxyYMp3E3AW9WJ3/8ij5PXs4nvW9Xkeu8qZuyexJ4A= $ defi-cli signmessage 8GbaBfHunRm6yrCtFSinyfLdQpZhuy1vPY "cfp-2202-04-no" Hxo9i/bB4ofeCYG2lZtiZNjYSWPXO/RPOMXsrujXZ0M7cBCMFNjtS7gfDO01zqC1o/ZVGbnp4YAOremar5Y/SXA= $ defi-cli signmessage 8YYUahjNZhhQmB3HjgMY5xqQTFNhJaZN5z "cfp-2202-04-no" IOBZTpKVKx6E3SLn7sc0jv8hL8X1yLl2y/dDhGL4jU7WFQQa908Si9PBjD9FjiEvvbdF2JkVxQOYA9YeUjvYH44= $ defi-cli signmessage 8Lp6bZHmhPoSpjxTG68BMbUEZkSH67LjCG "cfp-2202-04-no" Hy1I6xLRNkpkqg1S4QhPRhRHpmC4pgH2+b/y4kZZUP+CUpHkuzL/iUonMN/bMnPXG7Ku1W0aJQWecq2WrXBOAsY=

$ defi-cli signmessage 8GETy1tTzTde2AS9U6FC8a1LHBs9GLN2Gm "dfip-2202-a-no" H3oRdOlih2LVq7zGbq1ZwTcFjcLXt357eH6YkFARrlNkbz+idJhWKROCuud9OcqOBDx2MWKKbl3z2f3J1em4UUA=

signmessage 8GQuQhRTKTcGgw8nSMnQmqLJWmZ2zoaorq "dfip-2202-a-yes" H1y+ddASPENwywFFwdat73NMOU+CV24v5yk5K6LP8G8SLg/n0kIhgraQHQXS6jrlX98nxsFnraDwnV7zDV93rDU=

$ defi-cli signmessage 8SUn3fKmL6i2bTuh7DLnLPEpoFgcqNCUgE "dfip-2202-a-yes" H8R3dSnLARt9JbpeoK2PjmFNwK2xFeGPF+1oX3daNKmGEnqpibysfnGUU2nTcD/wImHkDgmpYaLAvZX8GY01Hu4=

signmessage 8XfjUN9asrYD25ftg5uLmcMHRve8QN5pD4 DFIP-2202-a-no IJ34zhh0U8AINttK5bnwodgilKWuwiMGenDMdFisSik4VKE/MJ6dRu5RlpE5QWLtaYA6JkPQjvjZNsd/Rr8OX7g=

$ defi-cli signmessage 8ZZnTWjtDxryxXtxt5ZpVsw4x4wGu1xhTH dfip-2202-a-yes IO1Vad6te01u3cmBzkVUW9p/e5x1uIqLtPLfYrxTPjj6eF9EcrnvoYr6JgzrCk0oDrMwn3APo+NB3b3apxEzVog= $ defi-cli signmessage 8bChxeusSifHLb8ycLwW56dfM5ihuTucdH dfip-2202-a-yes IA7qDtBy41AxqBlr3c6Yl5AkEjTxHPS0dtFz9Rj9uhkwFHn2PFy7AVuwOSGFgK/cGr3sAs0i/M922pM4x6GL1xE= $ defi-cli signmessage 8YPNGNK8KTf4K7DRy1f754yjcmZMFGydEP dfip-2202-a-yes H9gDOgwtcNQADh4TP6moGl96k8jvi+aFF75x+1YIfF6ccrFUITXxGMipff+wpLcK8eZgqO0DFPSnohLbRQp1TjE=

signmessage 8S4J5K9ohSkxgbYFc2Cbfmf3rf6WjfYH8T dfip-2202-a-yes HzN2XpH7vhMy47o5WqQQ1NTYWtgUlWwW9KCs6Ioj35DHdWqVvnJ4xNVDUoITJORVkQzxabb3cUi7/CjpbbYm0JA= signmessage 8dkH97UwAEcEM5bEZ56UjBNpE7MoTvpHc9 dfip-2202-a-yes IAqNgP+AlJeXq6Hy3/1V+f1fPCS/9pMLy/lVUu/wyNW5MoChcVgWu1tc3AbtCZFZaHPjdfLF7yN0LC3ekz0J234= signmessage 8PQfqMwffNWou7JkPDb9c5QsTeu4RxvKrs dfip-2202-a-yes H6fbP1xYUyNiosEfxws09zTqnC4+q5UQmiVxsUSrbyk4CF1f4kDR/X0Z1vmlBgSOiguPyvWuduMzPXwEInWlQMs= signmessage 8MdCzvjK8Z8xM5zpmZUaxFNq1DKz86gQbw dfip-2202-a-yes IKQbx25z8FaeparVMGvqfbTPaa1LIwZAr+521F/fY6AzcqBM9tBaJsL1T820ap+GZYrcIkH8sHB8xUJxGxmnQWg= signmessage 8S7mi7YYXu4AxCqsjSPTYZjTBcbZS5mwga dfip-2202-a-yes H4WPqPHnIfjnIjS4n3xdw+qrTkEjL4deK7/1RYV6pHj8RO9r60hcaNZvqAicBZg1FYXaYtWN3qQMGjywgFcrzco= signmessage 8QvQ6UQqYT3CMmLTEsnJZxsX1zZHFuMbx9 dfip-2202-a-yes IO+OAzs9+pkS5Ktwte6Mf4HMhJsskyFJICzVe3bsJ9NdJf6ue9WwmtAtKlT5+wXMfNMccZpdO9owzIO96SMpQFE= $ defi-cli signmessage 8JahBhn8hjaYjy4bwiW5mK8f6gaJkPCjLG "dfip-2202-a-yes" IEvPZNlH7UcFBafJiDJTfj8TjNGrSjx70ME5pgHXJZnSa6Y2wYLAv45+ZQ9vpGoA7VPvDG76YQE/vSQWZwbTXvY= $ defi-cli signmessage 8Y7VxAPi4JHprNLG3f1ooWYnCfJThsCRK8 "dfip-2202-a-yes" IDypxWorrc6Z3ml2ZdOiVEXh2LmwGSk3bkeN4goq6YLHa+nNAe7eF8hhJNekoNkFaM2vhA+y80NNdSMBpeG8bjM= $ defi-cli signmessage 8UuvfXfPHECLf4ZAswjA1GBqvjdXwtzPVq "dfip-2202-a-yes" H83Rg2XSjSfPYeRenPF8m4zmVE6x8dO3sRThFs1JA5+cB+8eH2SYcPnRLd4bE142fjluPNgAkMQ4I7ioDNLEYKI= $ defi-cli signmessage 8d9HLziLRfNMHd55ZXcpHSwGX4WD1wRedd "dfip-2202-a-yes" IDV1oA30TTukzHVIXIhhRImiI9BjncoiF+oI4QK/WCt3WMTMFHmI+WEoUZUNkasxGZ9Ksu/mHcNsSgSOOM2L0iY= $ defi-cli signmessage 8UZNDPgSeRK9xJSdJVZzyCpTAYGi2xd8ss "dfip-2202-a-yes" IHK7elBGJtHZl7bdJmFuaIlaSWpm/ay6wXoLHCLJvbQ3NtGtY8SQXrmNXd5qKR4MpFO24n/1cY4ABd0nxvE+F40= $ defi-cli signmessage 8U1dV8LDm5rX2YNUDyihqb3tX55P5L8eDF "dfip-2202-a-yes" IKFjh9v8uoOq2S5JrqblUdqHGcmKNsmJDWHQVMQcu5pBARakojDsQxr1bluTOe9nk/H5TJ+fjj3P/fu3iR7sMt0= $ defi-cli signmessage 8T4qaNNqWByMscZBgNeoUnn32efit5LaQS "dfip-2202-a-yes" IJ3bxxqMO6tyqsZx638PygbgXO0Ott4YgPJe0bV/kBRXIBK7OG2C9cSaPpwM3Pdw7hoOV+Z/tePgGQmqiNp/7cs= $ defi-cli signmessage 8b8ApttANbsnrAoeEBbmAjg861Xme9u2D2 "dfip-2202-a-yes" IIfEXVouLGLnkNcWiGS+VyMUbiRQ/ZYWvjZoztWsuOY1JWNH6uucjuRSC5hqD5p28LbCNKbwOTr2xtwaUo1NxOE= $ defi-cli signmessage 8WgTXgUEG4evFkicVzs3nJ8SYdeM6SDH9w "dfip-2202-a-yes" H9jGxih6xRe0TfI1y1qyXs7UdTNl2XhXn5H3HRqZ/T6ibdubRXn7nCVgeW7kTwE2D5anqugZkjRGInPNrR2TEXI= $ defi-cli signmessage 8Yfh3cbbQLpGzTd6LFxa9qDNMAm6bqJpuN "dfip-2202-a-yes" H0zDSfI8WGVVfemrWzeuSSURYjDwsemPYqMWwJeyCUGVXpKaTlcNpvYnkmmiPUD+hQQovI/r3K5FFSQN+tzFN1Y= $ defi-cli signmessage 8GdFg9DtLqQTGfAtS1LZE16yXfXkLWfbsD "dfip-2202-a-yes" H1YENCHJGgFAMBiomudeqEHcCn+y1Pe4VNkn5iqpTINkV10lMNiDybAfUR2q+bzMqKOLl2yJ+7+6cLLHGu7QdRI= $ defi-cli signmessage 8KToFU6wKHn7yQtUeD7HY5d1cHQB2Wjb4T "dfip-2202-a-yes" HxZSMbP9ptE5+HlI+dwyaVN9AT31THyD9Wk68Cj4zuWFfxiMfQzpIn646fVdzDASSpPPEpr2nPmUmwvJDDQPFmU= $ defi-cli signmessage 8KNjrrZwvkhEiVJPz9DsubCYBrj7zeDhKJ "dfip-2202-a-yes" IIRfZZ0i8/Ta2Ifw194MJ6v9EBWh2orqYpTJmFGq60zhP4HQZHEuNAG+45uuCXmMCRXa4lw46LUHoyI9VQk5wjQ= $ defi-cli signmessage 8UtzxhiHWnb8Q9G82z7o4USAHSC9yzY2o9 "dfip-2202-a-yes" H/wwjf3zLJm7k/q43NQKJsPIQLhw/0ivTRvBexWdK08OVgIEM4FS2GEQbTEB8wWTdazLDH8KS18anI+4tKfsgkY= $ defi-cli signmessage 8TnPLS9gtZyoN6xdFP3Ryubph6EjysCUnd "dfip-2202-a-yes" IIWc0a7nXw/Afr+wK+CuHb11Vq7eN8J6uLo9/6I4aizyFCrYoaLv/zaWNkTEE+0U7pMHNdXyuOG3S9DVFuPMAjw=

$ defi-cli signmessage 8Lp58RvNtuK7pe2oYKxz5H5XtQANai8guF dfip-2202-a-yes IP0N08TFG0nVbow+ubKFMMya+Vp4cEfKpJ6PO55hyPcDXywL8lqYwSRisPhng8itGYkhus+4qLpZlvs+QPTES+4= $ defi-cli signmessage 8RLxsuGppvr4WuLDR1yEbMdQZ3fY15NrMC dfip-2202-a-yes IP0otU3a4PsvGJkSIeervg81jvUzRYe32M1Rlv07NkpfZ67cspk7caF6hJeCoHPcwSwTo9vglYeLwNgupRmomT8= $ defi-cli signmessage 8bfd2v1ppXAtWsnMHDN3R1WD4VHaRKFXrc dfip-2202-a-yes IO9GLFvr45FimsV/P3T3mpELfaHnn1SjfkZS5BDs9UTjfe1MemXnHv5rop8gAMnIl/WRU4sBRIJBkIDjJGIfpII= $ defi-cli signmessage 8eCcu9KhxSu2fjuFWB2hc8VjGZg9bg1q1G dfip-2202-a-no IMGJOf8qxxBK4siytc8UcuBzhB1ylzrvnICQiciCyowYPvArCAHpk6s3i6O2iq2RM+5+Z1JXW9JPb3EseHHqdV8= $ defi-cli signmessage 8HQ2yJsZehBYXzCs4sZThrDvhy6maJVi1G dfip-2202-a-no IBGu1QkGvA1FPApj+sC+47DW4QXwvfP/yuUOmosnNihwe3j0axC9DWa0lD6n8L4AhYPR60Cc29O5QGtRtVMU1Kw= $ defi-cli signmessage 8RztdwBMqCaVHAf2N7ZF14C3v98nPHC4CK dfip-2202-a-no H/bH08AH2US/U4PvzxZuZC5xNxNPcA9IhAYlh4Q17oHzcK67nRhzfyCe36B7l8EKKQxYMt1cPXHyCmT33xF7ed0= $ defi-cli signmessage 8PYaNr9YB3ko9s9WyJqerhKGVSJmywPczV dfip-2202-a-no IO4f9pXI5ozRR88aXT4pRhaW0xCHATBLZSQzyG+1EakGcHwNPS4Y6iLP+mfX97yb5/3srpWy2msWYXSWURyTZbc= $ defi-cli signmessage 8PTWK8YwrqiLsT9qPb9oYRDg8epve94cgd dfip-2202-a-no HwLJ6V3NIHQcoxcRCXtlCOq6Esg+TcxO9XOBqGoRewtOWTmmc9UsGZQE1GeKuGt7vOShTbGblBGfr8/18ezBg/U= $ defi-cli signmessage 8d6q37gmBtLKH6KUY8FPQkXfPHnCTJbsHb dfip-2202-a-no IGWWuJfjjHNQkt9aX95BVJksjitqpzdBtvwHG0hMA6jOQbpx5WdXaayorMa6vAq1db0t0gFSjV7vAuEkJvj0Qzw= $ defi-cli signmessage 8d8PAcXKW8oySLgCrvewxWUYQhvoA13WLJ dfip-2202-a-no IC2pJTzcMD1SfcFlkj9KHaQ0tuoU8SSsXNVrC8/SJ8shXCw3dEGW1uhTHCSw00QS8wMFCKpReeQx3cBfq4yBK4I= $ defi-cli signmessage 8c8ckkRxtCwVuSzDAFwK5ueMieXJS7Popp dfip-2202-a-no IEzPXoHvQBMys/HcPSeVGA4CBPi9/IRjr8kHiaRq86bec4KLJ2m9RZV/avTEbGaCJb9CzyvQt2m2D5YulPWhn8c= $ defi-cli signmessage 8WD4RW9c5N6VdgrwAJvzH4mq3V1r7m9t6w dfip-2202-a-no IOMV528ch30dgS/tz1rC8QgwvvIDJjP8jfCLte5SRqQoKyzSFRZotFEV99JtSUg6ILMZGXovsTboJVPSK4AG0Ns= $ defi-cli signmessage 8eL3FiupHR1jFpSDVohFdFqtzwCbjNmc3B dfip-2202-a-no H/WgiDDNTj5ukwX2qh/WnokDM2hszL3bMal8TgVeD9WASxTS6ia8TTlcAM9fOgW5G0mWiqeFk/GHYeTiGprgRzE= $ defi-cli signmessage 8USj72RkqTuVuzDC1YQVAF4xp2Ns1wsELZ dfip-2202-a-no INYDN1KnAFdG+gjgtrarkU6b4mKi08jLjlTqZpIGrounO49nHLQ7HoQe+E+GssQfa/uRTnL1EWsVUlLnjJS+iGc= $ defi-cli signmessage 8Rqu842qDGAVd63TMxqqkEvsVCmr16UU6U dfip-2202-a-no H/xMSaeRvJ5/9sy0/RY5SxQMLOn6SPRtIlB3eUXFsYAGDWYZ6GAM4zJERVhYM8vEimIGaDP8HWiVdz/l+1Kfz6s= $ defi-cli signmessage 8bHMRMJBLfpUMpsz7kCtYEswEcURxaEC8B dfip-2202-a-no H6JG5Xc+k7Y5o3A+ahiviGL623zWRMIOK4RcSTLEBHOHUonsjUrjUxAXNQ4qdio3msXA5SxLNnzToTscYKODlwM= $ defi-cli signmessage 8eETFGSUdWmCYCp8SKCiewBUc27Hi5La2b "dfip-2202-a-no" INwBRpUqAtP0MCWs4cCdcQP236wZlsiTF4tT/cPbRS4qVulzYYGPgQ+DIt0MsVn+1PXVbdWw3L0N8DJfY5X1x1I= $ defi-cli signmessage 8c2Bknr6QkpJz4uVGVVEirXrmUnVkQ8BnD "dfip-2202-a-no" IB80awxYzygsODjTcRvsah0Lx34werkGA8rei9ljJZyTfHMW7UyCtZY1yoeECFrINSXl8eecLbSadwygouRZMWQ= $ defi-cli signmessage 8QsJGXwm2QYwtqwWgJeEHyEcRcqcmBktBb "dfip-2202-a-no" Hywuh1zVf2HvPSzlcFz4YySqGFTHhwO08VKu+9x1ZAR3Gbbv7TR4TDPdbVhskbsu2Bndsgz9t+GfLnhQtf9/OmI= signmessage 8TgYxGdQucmFumzv368H2skr1cBEQy7Rcz "dfip-2202-a-yes" H2v2TMAmVbtDvW+2DO1V9ssDX2EdwY0EQ+45QGyiO8+RLROK9o0Ni3ASOsbveD7d0l+Hd/GgdB4S7t+JAUz/gzo= signmessage 8JXJpggS8nTR8eS6y949da7GbmvPhQaUjW "dfip-2202-a-yes" H+ia9h9UCgXoeCfqBsHislActG5RkARYeLbUxYXTYEWpGsHEjokpC5cwCU3zu5EKx2PHBNQ6AMvg+uaNcROoBQQ= signmessage 8com6udmbeAzQ148rFLKWip3TxYcckNzNM "dfip-2202-a-yes" IBMpPeO5dwzLrYmY9oq009+heRQInJyKL5LDXjqpnn34N725LjRQ6FZl7lD8c/EEdxo7G96Y38+vXdEFsRGqIWs= signmessage 8MSmt4Z8MTAYoSFpPiGaeSZAV4y3NTokZk "dfip-2202-a-yes" H1EbEb7gDceonXQ/lRvBgJWaQ/deWeM+cRrU08amdek+OO2C6eumt1OG2+vbEJAEGkRzeNa+b/jEfPOCRMWuf70= signmessage 8b6asVpFQQ5NKWpWfpp5mLfh7ML6qKUear "dfip-2202-a-yes" HwbgW0HJ/0quTdviDe+OtTfbBSiSUv14VPK0gtOU+DqMMOAicq+aebmn3du7F1kg5ZQXS1B5+UzKClEJpCPErCY= signmessage 8aAbh2e5kbKu2FLZfYuXxJJEsNet6jbUmX "dfip-2202-a-yes" IAJzOk+FqZ+sb/sHCwNkRKHUp4SomjTPFNiBJLAy+O8ZF5QneSNkGzwtspT8ZgmrnuZ5V4IzUPk/r8fgoSAYKP0= signmessage 8U4DbZhto6q24iHP3fcDWqouNyHExcy3av "dfip-2202-a-yes" H9VCxgP7VkuY+0Ye3V2o2acuTWqDX+n5j7jCfqvI0sFWX0Tm8k+VoLsw6XB33L7ZIQjZqZikPdY/qKTiof6wakA= signmessage 8JJSzvSY6Krb127JSwoxHZnpEWwfbFTSre "dfip-2202-a-no" IBYOiIvkzKKwUsI/BS6zxMXQ5U0Mbshjb5o1QReV7NkJXgYZwhWqUM0tcq/z4GE/rZetYogq3ecBHsZG0s4uJNI= signmessage 8LXtM3xBk68eEKnfFYTphcpemjabs1mtmz "dfip-2202-a-no" ILhwCxXvdJD2kzfVFlsos8seK2zI6AHNIOFbo9Djg3jbApI5/j27/hzsSSx7TIEUPTTfRqIbyYlFx4v0a1QaF5g= signmessage 8Ynwzb9Z9FBrK8D7LTaDtruBJks4SCkhgf "dfip-2202-a-no" H0uJ04oWVoIivJYYsD9dCI8Q25z1ANP3B9a0RQF5MVSOHqXzUe1iPxEUbbXBPuBeowEYSe6tlTrizde4hVaqu6M=

$ defi-cli signmessage 8Kh1Xd1u5nsVWsgRtr8sVZPk8omeBRvmK1 "dfip-2202-a-no" H9dh+QAResnnMCW/NOCl5oJscojiw2PwLtexOxGsGNQFSLcr76qUoZH9ApgG/zPmPUqG3vmTRIB/F1GrIScHXgM=

$ defi-cli signmessage 8R8tGo9a9J5y6zBLRYvGpPQmbqYWdZEFCx "dfip-2202-a-no" H5/Aw0rtrqjabGtM08epiLD1jWYgvjd0mcu6j5BNlYRTewKDoVSH5I8jOLy7QL8LoB8bj40fcHZUKDycntgQYwg=

$ defi-cli signmessage 8dJLcKddBnwXzzXBLeZLYqzHehfeB8UWa2 "dfip-2202-a-no" H68WtHpzlLFMBxefKTiGtF8mVVlBtUZZiRnNe4BZqccLYgnJ1aesJYCtd+lvR+QflDwjLbaea0YUrg0ywJwvAqw= $ defi-cli signmessage 8JgPSdyFpLTG1wAnxFHpuHjEoSmPBhHccg "dfip-2202-a-no" H5x5QkqS8572P5Glti8kVqXz90LuJjpMY/vIgvhYciJQWmg973rtdNcoRRn5QQrv/KBTUK+pvflVUe1cfhVKF/k=

Votes of the DFX Community

Individual votes can be viewed transparently here: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1tvc1KhLuGGSCfUuZoDnTxqaLDurXcftd8MBA57YfhKQ/edit#gid=1589942302

Votes:

$ defi-cli signmessage 8Liyw8GmbE3yFPwtjADh3gJyFjoKBHcdZ5 dfip-2202-a-yes IIUIB4ZTqanUCtOZ6eG/zv6Ldwc1Rp0namdUlBHqpfK2VJ8+42IfXWmT9CpJgYOTHODHPSRbysrpCkuVC75EldE= $ defi-cli signmessage 8WiN64tvrGYuHAegsdRxWdr5huAxn9HJYp dfip-2202-a-yes HynsC4BZX4pN4o8yFlSH1Nw6SwC2XHa5c9hfNyjsPshmUOWBNSnW0rHvJ265KUi8es/4da60DfWXoiwu6CFnrgU= $ defi-cli signmessage 8Qz2uAif1CknNJ9D49jW9uCrTqFb81Md8b dfip-2202-a-yes H6/A1vW5a5wBHwJ8GAizd40sGE6goyGcltWTJqo11F2RHaBa9e04y8/FoLWgtkXu0T8Ksr/EWwNXO5rJmrGKAJg= $ defi-cli signmessage 8LZH4V5eEkyXevQodEd6UfUrVkUYgTo1fH dfip-2202-a-yes IPPsjhND3xpFfkglRxuJnKkDlQgM+UfVaU7tW6qg261/CHu+6/M07VLLJGNSuJCfaDaD2xSM0eJT62T4IVpw0SE= $ defi-cli signmessage 8a6yyLatxryej8cRV5PDrQgGkTP75Fs7Wp dfip-2202-a-yes IAac1fRSPPw4Ixdq1r5m3s54JdXnvoou64Gl8upIRnd3HHkFALfzCDsZMThoosnQt5KLFYoX2DAUcRQzqNjWFn4= $ defi-cli signmessage 8ZxgwWrSqeEGSqgWQ8K7FdXvUVmNYzrsHQ dfip-2202-a-yes IJeEyBPYbWb2rK2ziPbTV/2AUlfAn7WAUx2VQBjx+RMWB9zfBW6c8nkNzi5bdMJC4LbivLXv4Z3GKdyeapC3wow= $ defi-cli signmessage 8Phw3LWWDKfcbA3tQnpjEDqj5cCV3TX5Fo dfip-2202-a-yes IJgqq4uLgcUrS5jycrArk5Ju1EBJItrnw4+AEeqeSD2OZpLk3KEVHjiv5m2Z77v841UzItX7ScGQzs4YJz0uVd8= $ defi-cli signmessage 8buADVH4egKMsVu9XKT76aaCoC9YqmSKth dfip-2202-a-yes IKNYkDS9Ozph05n6PX8Gpj8gzta/C/aTSz+2tyZFXPpWKnuh5JGXnRFkbu1tEijqp97cjeItPB8p4S+Y1omDRUM= $ defi-cli signmessage 8FbvPr1yBa24Td5cy5XTaASmC7cbrYRYdx dfip-2202-a-yes IOWYggXUZ+B2mNVA35Lz0Ti+DTF8BwCLeTrd6gulKZOYfimsxnKo9A669DoeN4uk4i+v862teKhI6HmNJTpIel8= $ defi-cli signmessage 8TcZLsx4AedC5rT8u6hzvijYAjWTexsQcQ dfip-2202-a-yes IMkohlmChdlqbZCL6DTiN6jZCFqkL9oKMHJSgbgYRVEvLk4mvx6pJIm35NJQwyBVDi3eUje7hkZS6oxUN1ci5jw= $ defi-cli signmessage 8GXCkikfNUX3ACDjZFpMaqReMgLDzUDSfj dfip-2202-a-yes H3eWiYY7NMxZWPnXC7JGtShoIuQ/E7H3rW9OYtFIU60WMwrRBA9CUdc5XD+gtG6njn7o674fYxMBi+rraL4OSys= $ defi-cli signmessage 8Pz13iyh91hpwH8dqQ8kzmenQJ8bXkq1xs dfip-2202-a-yes IPDPHvsvrYDUpSINzhdx+MYIKiLLGI45taVx25U5Ax/iJiwfv/i2onPZsERQFw7h8jDTyCSaeUxQCRIlRok4Fso= $ defi-cli signmessage 8Nje3J5b5i7V6cvWFrSghzFu3zABXYvqAT dfip-2202-a-yes IJdP+Nt8SVQKJqsm3TzBH6US5Avqeioz9okz8sm5uorqOuRgtv4dq2vK1RaXAf6dkpa1bF8wnJs0CbRckzqa/1A= $ defi-cli signmessage 8NfZUCHaht2SojYyFqia4XZsoXvm7Fz2D4 dfip-2202-a-yes HwYQK2//eEBJIc4HtHXJ3T9BXKPlsEq7/jDWnxmNYwoqKKfXJ8TJoUPxgyaNxNl9a7Htj+ig5djk4xxem+xJvTc= $ defi-cli signmessage 8Y7Jjo6iUDTokDgUATYG62fmm1J1knL3p2 dfip-2202-a-yes Hzo19RJt5RfdEtWhpZwwQ+aJNVChIWeT3AuOtQLZrxynajPfJUFyeFjQ/dDWfI2CgeUbMcHgQ5BGxMg70cQnN6Q= $ defi-cli signmessage 8bEjCR6BhWmntrmbw2DdKya9vFDuXZk2su dfip-2202-a-yes H8azrNMj4NiQ9MWkmm1AQy3kGNJ9lhgyuxX2hlqqiIGIVRT4gH7eanIeBYs6K1fIbbRLUmebO+QDwWqGBWzRuAo= $ defi-cli signmessage 8cFvVtTxfrhfnUCokLjmp3v2krYLQubEbQ dfip-2202-a-yes H2EF2psbxm5i+XABobVyp4fcOPVxvi69cxIBXhV7MDYxfQksd74vhYHmYneTclHFT4l9GoIq609Wc2PTuvteXl4= $ defi-cli signmessage 8TAuyksv9oLHZBvisy2nVApr4NHTdV6PCL dfip-2202-a-yes IJjyrYSAgCYzs0YQF7fo8xCZEE+JBx9X9Km8EqshonAWPmAvD6s30J7eAzdokoYAusfQBu5xq0GHS6k39Ktu5Ao= $ defi-cli signmessage 8RpU2WVFCqmMERqGez5pMDrFhf4Eh1ciy2 dfip-2202-a-yes HzdtDxaBeTiJaxxYyhJZn87h36kuhFZx70617dmRoQmzIyKQeNUcVWIen75Prj84yn/p2wgdsi7zvLCgPdnyDuU= $ defi-cli signmessage 8PyBunz9rSSVHrpXWhmNSL6Y1qtWdxU24C dfip-2202-a-yes ILxnFvJJvgZ6tUTbPWihjLKKAV4BqIBiNBb+flPVPfSKZaAmoPu2r+ZKXrng6WbVEADxfosbEIw4hCZHNkbFit8= $ defi-cli signmessage 8VWYae3DsKDo8kv1E3hoUS7a2AnBAdqqsP dfip-2202-a-yes INd3n5sQ8wcEWtKDT8x9UJJacPtQMnMVuq8A1kQB/1DBAkfi+L3dGEAF/IytGIJ4xb0CMo0pTCDyV4QJXD93Tzk= $ defi-cli signmessage 8dCwq815DpwiyKu73LEseHAuXhr7QgfS37 dfip-2202-a-yes IOW25mPhl6Zc8Oir4ILGDbxR+KHH7CgwHHlOmbKqwEQgCaXSJWKrZefsgOrxK9PuKjBWPKeM6HOQtaiSYf+r89o= $ defi-cli signmessage 8P7H6iBQ3i9YWTrvHzNp4fR5JgT6YS56mN dfip-2202-a-yes H4UwkvNXkH8gHbMrMEEn2rbZc5J0iMAZ42XylTZMXqAJJKO/Wd1WT7WRtDNpFyigCjYDs8h0nw62U4jOUeMltTg= $ defi-cli signmessage 8KirKNGVgrsQsmWuy1Ee4ZmsnXVVkAEzh2 dfip-2202-a-yes IFNWQE+NJyQM7dC4mMk2WFXDBOfC5RmfcJh8FfPvQyoDfXvO/Tj1ZUaj+BxgLQ/SrBr6EuUeojXfyXSAo04OhlM= $ defi-cli signmessage 8K2rFXPAbgHmDbS4oJ2rV13anMgqASanjg dfip-2202-a-yes IHpIDeE3adJMqPA3ICEn8c0exUfEK5RPBZDq1X8OMg80WMv5UCk9dGaeaUsF9VY8ff9sqBLvA3I1nNP1y1jZ4Yo= $ defi-cli signmessage 8LCBbjobE1KCdgk2EDX3mQsqS8VFhedNfp dfip-2202-a-yes H4pVzJlkaccEQwVi/+pKRtp7pQV2QHKnntSxJa/URP5FZl5VjVirA37siccwpkqt3Wx6dpXM5z2ooI0KShj2BfI= $ defi-cli signmessage 8T4w25btQL4vL7EfSAHd2evnBrcSoEKDk5 dfip-2202-a-yes HwXBy/AGF24hOvutBoya1ofquZqTZ9Xu/48nR4T0KazXIji8KJ1DhSrtEsElFDwICUYIyLS0sNKHJ2yKvluOBSo= $ defi-cli signmessage 8QdaEJ9Fpxvy7eWdBHTQt37vhkPfqY2Xis dfip-2202-a-yes IC2YqFZ3OJcrIAbhdMZaSeyn86qJnGcBY86L4oFFRbxTb9cqYruOE6NzxDMb+RvOzVeB+TaOdQPh77lmjGXUrac= $ defi-cli signmessage 8G1tj1DMj39GMnVnKyH1j7GLmtAsbhxVnU dfip-2202-a-yes IHh7AKCi8d2uWfA0f4BsXkrJ/NgBLxhJ8v6Thhg35m1ASP0CPaxCstH7/Rylw3LmbXMVpBiGVBw9vVWEh70zU18= $ defi-cli signmessage 8aAfu7SeU3gr9jeCZP3TfLmjr4fpaY3cXb dfip-2202-a-yes H4TkVSBLRhMy0evQFaQKIQkOJanOxfYlLCORuMj/ggVCUJ8ttDe2J+xcxDhIG1Z7YBoMx1eGMGD7Yr0mSzgVF6g= $ defi-cli signmessage 8HQmWowRXtBFWQ9gaex8yRAJgatU9FtMe7 dfip-2202-a-yes IIbM4ty33KBeTkJN5MourX6294bSJkyBkoaLZRWze/TuJ2TOeQzNU9EbxDrsKc0cNY/5Qky2pGmj1PrDpONCar0= $ defi-cli signmessage 8UASnc25BhXYquhejccW2PSe1AYTPvWf3a dfip-2202-a-yes IGoBli8pxItfdbtLy+o2tOnvSBnbMKdKOdm1mX4QIBqsVfHVPOWQcxTg/7YRL7UXq0CMoQCtr+9yoMv0qIrby/s= $ defi-cli signmessage 8PKLYHto5H7rYAe7Yp2s1wWeMDsAp7WoiQ dfip-2202-a-yes H2CU+BCuKT/ZoAjA6agQmuRY3l/mk/PnJwvRrt14t8CcM+xWmRSNTJj1riXvbf+lSNC3gFMcYfa9zy1j3DLYYPo= $ defi-cli signmessage 8QKwpbKQ7dwNWkeeNoB9JJf6mRi6e1zuwH dfip-2202-a-yes IACTwvTIKnQr6Ar63OcaqD75Q10OrfkLNdHnmMnmdKIQYRVakCKctOJ9f8/p0o30A3kFPPd97v1WitAQclouk8w= $ defi-cli signmessage 8XQJtF1ZquixvyZaDtYMoWt29BuWxQD96d dfip-2202-a-yes IHcprfi/XIU/T4Tt2wX1KJQiA4QyX3NYASSr3tK6cgtVJTJrtOWsRenJs36I9xRX5JX+O9ytDo5z1+fqwpt7LRE= $ defi-cli signmessage 8VSi5j9QfWr4s3iyvBSsQVj9ZtjboLJKog dfip-2202-a-yes HxXslIiSfKB+N4nHHg2MFOn8KQAJwdToG9Fd9ZIN5JFsF5kLCw/3UZA2mm6S/N9bVcXFUisFPpjFqKo4DvrITn8= $ defi-cli signmessage 8d7RUWWYY5Z4vd4zDvSj9naeeVTR46kuyb dfip-2202-a-yes H14XJtBQ6tmrpRRNRzyCRrdOOQjegPOggNg6cYVXPD+uFbhsARlf747n48oOao92rjBfKD589EZf1Q1rY4rdyFU= $ defi-cli signmessage 8G1wTn1brVqpAiRU6EFWGB88EcDH44uaLS dfip-2202-a-yes H1a5dXsyMOox9pkXv36bnnbQbIqfh5an0kyrEAYspByAJMC9CxYFrF51lzr1Idur7as/1YEPybefNlILigKfQHQ= $ defi-cli signmessage 8PC6a7bv6eXPpUAZruPyA2YuPT6KPeeEUC dfip-2202-a-yes IL3r7A1YZNiaZgXeZcc2BOPXo+YT2/FzwsMAt2b+XNtyAHCO5i65nlqw7uLD8rCdX2u+taqN9eCycov/vMciNKg= $ defi-cli signmessage 8K1ofTMRHZEyB1YnjFUSqdyuPgRnPyTZ8H dfip-2202-a-yes IM2Lp0iQEboQd07KxX97eIB3O5Avj2y2vuWO6E8kG+IBDu4Q70EuoB8OsV7cjyj4FoRRZeSlBWyZR6UGaXQQe50=

$ defi-cli signmessage 8Hs4sLv66LN49bQ3NbvVLQYPcK2PsKLoKo dfip-2202-a-no H88XYTe8kNASpHrBFHU4joNlKrVwU9USzuYEE0Yrwm/zWqe9zHrS6pHcPnxUdkJC5oTCr8ej9C0vQQj+I2MBZB8= $ defi-cli signmessage 8HAZg7LsQgE7AgUn64phjpg2ZyhLNcxtMx dfip-2202-a-no HzxjRtgySDQIb8l/s8PEnDSugCvKWtHy6bP7OzwBYC0TNEisgABaDjhnQs7WljjiXwvyDJPlwHR11d1ThF/KybY= $ defi-cli signmessage 8U8DBmY7qXLoq2f2JycLGzDX3qv2VQNtJL dfip-2202-a-no HzKdscT5nyrz6vriS5/CBcX6sTfYp1x3tkwCf8GlC/K7QF8lPLedhStq+XJoKz8/UWsL07gQ81+DkO89aD9u3V4= $ defi-cli signmessage 8dJLPQGhCP3yQp34RNhddP4vc9sqrxk9gq dfip-2202-a-no H6F5AMXeMKJzfO85IST0B0C5Bcww/oskZtc68g4qI7X6cjoKNUrN2dBU6Gs6AheL0wxyM0YZ0fo7G2ZvuphXNJM= $ defi-cli signmessage 8c5MhVHu9sRT27547UrhAEx8JRqoxVHPLD dfip-2202-a-no H31TdDJhXXBHrqbvmI3Y5QW1NYUvHGuyJwT4YKggptaiEuDyKuGc1mVBjIY9NhkyGAMA/lU3e4H6k/UvmabV4DE= $ defi-cli signmessage 8RKdgXgKZXe4GFsXtBwuHaJz5WFSddzvdP dfip-2202-a-no H4xCmdwqO+3Pi0R2f+iECZH4elzMtfVtjTR4uWjrnDF0UBipAyGmm6INdmsRNPpHPwTEAMDPyx1ND0AB3lga+kE= $ defi-cli signmessage 8MaE5KgCAm8UnxSDwyYnWZ4C7HQNSSTREB dfip-2202-a-no H7cE/WirYIVjlUxB7Z4zztK1B3zWZH8Kk8umQJ+zeKmbUlolCqaXTbkOc59Z+McFzmZatiP9AEB5cdq0/3YlEl4= $ defi-cli signmessage 8Z5yj2tBhUZDj8U63h2VUerrpGnxFHMCsQ dfip-2202-a-no H+plU0OeVWhfqTtEZEHcXB7Log+qiMNooNpafVu0F+tJWx64zQEoOSCD6aiijI5hn1RyAxwt8ib/8KSMCA2qiQA= $ defi-cli signmessage 8KrQFFQpRBGT1P1BLg9b6d3HkMBvE92p9h dfip-2202-a-no IH8Fa4VtXp9eJBHL8reuowcObC8Vt9MA3HX1t4IE7sL+fmSWep+tfuY6Ofz+6QoA6bkeGzjDlQVzIn0VBT3OupQ= $ defi-cli signmessage 8W4FvnuQpUeAbHEKEi3Pt5rNxzegrpaons dfip-2202-a-no ILFWlc0l/uw7cBWrq/Z/xB6Ww5wGdqLaGIa8rQ543hfaSxU6Grx0rO0otUqwARTGkWBjEat5SgRk+WTMQ6okeHU= $ defi-cli signmessage 8bYKEDnwbVCAj7RCBT8Ah6G1fDPGsy55x9 dfip-2202-a-no IN2xAKSS1TZIwRV0W2olLxA2iJyi/BeLcnAApDDTWpNsQlmLRRCCT7iMag5uQ2mwno9vl3s400sCIdNFyKguoS8= $ defi-cli signmessage 8Y727d85iV6tumeSeWZ1PsEghP4ZovjQdG dfip-2202-a-no ID+T1hEjL2FTuAAdwSE9cIcFWoNrckGsLWO2+TDbHyv3CDgB06YTeMgogGNgHBoPwC/6+00P08a3kcY7tgM/NAs= $ defi-cli signmessage 8XmR43vrB8kaUVRona6F7wd6FTZzfZi6DL dfip-2202-a-no H5flPUcM8OMPkk37EcjlpFL7XEnEAR5CK4hRjW2D4r1eODCA3GRACPrNAt1V7CkqDiOJHq9tgD6jdFn8ax3H/oc= $ defi-cli signmessage 8VZt4CZzH59FHYBb6dt7XUkRiasuHvh3q9 dfip-2202-a-no H99x8aMhJTr/YpzhuGP9g8k/nN810tdTQPtnjK9FXwqnZPAe/RJalk54HLroMHCj28Jnj5DroeT3rCRx3IjZFEU= $ defi-cli signmessage 8WpKkyyMdDQVnuYxZ87aqremVQ4GKnRTJL "dfip-2202-a-no" HyLr32QQ8zgvKALcS+czEdB6FQ0QdgA6OzizRK9Xv1BJUvsOdpCItsIzgUQt240UmjKuTxhSyxLbXXkB84mDtwQ= $ defi-cli signmessage 8MHJGoybb1V5LM3ykQCWWnuQHVdYs2MKro "dfip-2202-a-no" H+31e1lR/S8IuEG1LKuV2Rw3DG4OMMjEnKg1p4/CqCvURVL46NpLvAga+C8e2qxYdqQPhaPAe4YGTOcxfp9sOAw= $ defi-cli signmessage 8VwNTviWsAqnXMs3XsnegTSijRj4K7NqFV "dfip-2202-a-no" ILOkmYVHwxSizkHmxPEyY15hLV/fXhfuz6VVk2U3QSYoIuLpGx6wOE3IXZ6lYVZxaHCGJeT0LB3zk0YGQ04IlNQ= $ defi-cli signmessage 8FBCdrt3aEfadkJKLCssGUnvvAdDBFaVYZ "dfip-2202-a-no" IEnKLVZnh4Gyuqe42///6bfYooNFWXace+nj6QKtEY40Ykw1cTGaPw6/yVVajV82oht6MTousW86DuPVF8CvI50=

RESULTS for dfip-2202-a
===========================
dfip-2202-a is rejected by 91 votes majority
YES: 156
NO: 247
Neutral: 43
Total valid votes: 446
Total rejected votes: 34
===========================

mnstate_validate.log validate_dfip-2202-a_failed.log validate_dfip.log

DeFiCh / dfips