search

DeFiCh / dfips

DeFiChain Improvement Proposals (DFIP) & Community Fund Proposals (CFP)
https://defichain.com
131 stars 24 forks source link

DFIP-2207-B: Introduce USDC-DUSD and USDT-DUSD pool for a stable DUSD peg (including shortterm relief for DUSD discount) #184

Closed kuegi closed 2 years ago

kuegi commented 2 years ago

DFIP Overview

  1. Requester(s): @kuegi
  2. Reddit discussion thread (optional): https://www.reddit.com/r/defiblockchain/comments/vlsgxx/dfip_introducing_usdtdusd_and_usdcdusd_for_a/
  3. Proposal fee (50 DFI) txid: 6d60bc223bf3890c14700ea48344687ce79ba8393c5e4aa0d61ecc6ae54335e6

On the nature of automated marketmaker (AMM)

On the DEX of defichain we have liquidity pools with AMM. This means that at every time and price we have the same liquidity. The price in the pool is calculated via the ratio between the two assets in the liquidity pool. So the price only moves if someone swaps through the pool and therefore changes the ratio of the assets (by adding one asset and removing the other). This also means that in big pools you need a lot of trading volume to significantly move the price.

The effect of AMM on the DUSD discount

The DUSD-price is calculated as the ratio between the price in DUSD-DFI vs the "real" DFI price. Since DUSD-DFI is a big pool, when the DFI price moves we need a lot of DFI being bought or sold for DUSD on the DEX to move the DUSD-DFI price accordingly. The DFIPs of the previous voting rounds have multiple mechanisms to trigger that volume in trading on DUSD-DFI anytime the DFI price moves. Those mechanisms are important for longterm stability and a healthy ratio of loan-based DUSD vs. algorithmic DUSD. But I think we can do even better.

USDT-DUSD and USDC-DUSD pool for a more stable DUSD-peg

Let's imagine a DEX without a DUSD-DFI pool, but only USDT-DUSD pool, with this pools ratio at a perfect 1 DUSD = 1 USDT. If USDT-DFI drops 50% this would have no immediate effect on the DUSD-peg, because USDT-DUSD wouldn't move unless people actively swap in the pool. So the DUSD-peg would be more strongly disconnected from the price of DFI.

I don't think that no DUSD-DFI pool is the solution, but that we should split the DUSD-DFI pool (and the rewards on it) onto three pools: DUSD-DFI, USDT-DUSD and USDC-DUSD. If we had that, the nature of AMM would support the peg (via the stablecoin pools) instead of hurting it. Also the DUSD peg would be an average over 3 pools instead of the result of 1 volatile pool.

Simulation, Arbitrage and Short Term Effect

In the current situation (with DUSD in a 20% discount) introducing a balanced new pool would allow for immediate arbitrage, which would also reduce the DUSD depeg by a great deal within hours.

If we simulate the effect of such a new pool, based on current numbers we have the current situation:
we have around $77 mio liquidity in DUSD-DFI and 7.2 mio in USDT-DFI.
If we move 2.5 mio DUSD from DUSD-DFI and 2.5 mio USDT from USDT-DFI to the new pool USDT-DUSD (introducing the new pool at perfect peg). This would leave 5 mio DFI free in the system and pools with the following liquidity and prices:

After the arbitrage evens the pools, we would end up as

The stronger move in USDT-DFI is due to the imbalance in liquidity between the DUSD and USDT pool.

To sum up: introducing a stablecoin pool with only 5 mio liquidity to the system right now would reduce the DUSD depeg instantly from 20% to less than 8% and help stabilize the DUSD peg on the long term.

Challenges and Transition

In a perfect world we could instantly switch and have all the liquidity moved, but in reality this needs to move gradually over time. When we split rewards from DUSD-DFI over 3 pools, the existing DUSD in this pool will spread accordingly over the 3 pools. But we would need additional USDT and USDC in the system to provide liquidity for the new pools. Since we won't magically get 10 mio new USDT and USDC onto the chain within a day, the rewards should be moved gradually.

At first I would recommend to split the 50% rewards from the dToken pools that currently go to DUSD-DFI to be split 1.5% for USDT-DUSD and USDC-DUSD and keep the remaining 47% on DUSD-DFI. With the current liquidity in DUSD-DFI, this would lead to roughly 5 mio liquidity in the new pools in the beginning.

To ensure that we don't get instant arbitrage on a low liquidity stable-coin pool I would suggest to create the new pools and move the rewards, but not activate trading until we reach a minimum of 5 mio liquidity on those pools.

Summary of suggested changes

How does this DFIP benefit the DeFiChain community?

A stable DUSD-peg is essential for the longterm success of the dToken system. Additional to the approved measures from other DFIPs the proposed stablecoin pools would provide for possible shortterm solutions which help to quickly restore faith into defichain and naturally (via AMM) stabilize the DUSD peg in the long run.

Additionally stablecoin pools would further incentivize additional funds flowing into defichain since these provide cashflow on stablecoins without the need for vaults.

Non-obligation

I understand that vote of confidence for DFIP carries no obligations by any developers to implement the proposals. DeFiChain is a community projects. Pull requests can be submitted by community and reserved to be evaluated for safety and general community acceptance.

mydefichain commented 2 years ago

defi-cli signmessage "8Rqu842qDGAVd63TMxqqkEvsVCmr16UU6U" "dfip-2207-b-no" IKLTM3Nfz9azZVlUDkVWV+aL1GO5WOlrcm3WZ26fGmX6A1wVdx2F75n/GhKJzqwwpwV5ib53TLbAO0k9iaUaNe4= defi-cli signmessage "8bHMRMJBLfpUMpsz7kCtYEswEcURxaEC8B" "dfip-2207-b-no" H39IBBZ6M2Ml7D7lN0cyvC0vZEH+/YT1Adz/iiJxjstjdoh+BMVrH7cN3hIlBu4JK9SUT8JBm4W2I5pm7L9dcgo= defi-cli signmessage "8d6q37gmBtLKH6KUY8FPQkXfPHnCTJbsHb" "dfip-2207-b-no" H2co51BG8VFT6IQdeuRyL2fULUyTC6LVQ3b14gMBinAed/w3ufP0+m6kWlP9ioR10y5s3I/dJQoRi4Ej8SXZgUI= defi-cli signmessage "8NRFussvGyHameJSxdvJnB6sH8Z2frJkws" "dfip-2207-b-no" IO87lFKSfKdWRqh7XVysP0Re3LSk6U/gRVVhvOh1E8r6JB/xwg20mgu0Udpmjmewa2S0hj8nT+RCb0Q6LWexU68= defi-cli signmessage "8e4WKyiM79WHDN3vzyWJ7QBjo85VAGQteq" "dfip-2207-b-no" H9DIxGnvQ5GScoMSKOFj5fzBNjnxJ276uSSiwCfBuy5hBxEMBEomHm2RV/PcnLD0jChKA8PxtuRmCMwGQT/5PKM= defi-cli signmessage "8d8PAcXKW8oySLgCrvewxWUYQhvoA13WLJ" "dfip-2207-b-no" Hw7/75NmiyMTtrC8QiPhGlswYZJis8NSz/N9MtPTJ4QZHVdweFog9oYKFz6tiPjILXo2l1gN9CiHSttEI/RBfD8= defi-cli signmessage "8c8ckkRxtCwVuSzDAFwK5ueMieXJS7Popp" "dfip-2207-b-no" INhxmK3jq9XqCs5fZkWT+rm6jqylJl4NPStvh0zwxeOob2x3wMRwefJt5cefZx6Ewy5TK2jqbrWG9UBAFRAoZbQ= defi-cli signmessage "8J4dMfnSVduwLBmr76V3VqfEkSVXqnbuDL" "dfip-2207-b-no" IFUVTFKBhJt35aNqdM0uRd2hmf/Hqr5EVwZ1rNB0TK1LLMVISLh9cgIWOca7q4o6d9D5wWhacvtlvhMoCvNIQHE= defi-cli signmessage "8WD4RW9c5N6VdgrwAJvzH4mq3V1r7m9t6w" "dfip-2207-b-no" HxZ3kN1v04HlhkhLFUbMJuatORKftA4QbPZSRNEv4V8eUzkMKOZK0lTTGvvDf4b/cdOCMOTzCLylrs2VMjkMgng= defi-cli signmessage "8eL3FiupHR1jFpSDVohFdFqtzwCbjNmc3B" "dfip-2207-b-no" IOaoOWtzsZjOOs3x6X0hdPIYd2iWYkoPRQYSM2kVve9bXQDGVTxmel8ca0mgfa341IsLcHSxi5qVDWMaRghq7uM= defi-cli signmessage "8USj72RkqTuVuzDC1YQVAF4xp2Ns1wsELZ" "dfip-2207-b-no" H2qmxw4cLmJEL/ziyGCU3zNV03dv2OCSk3ONRgsIj+/XM2aPw4kyXDXneZ/v+waG2GBZSk+WCkWEYDfy079jNec= defi-cli signmessage "8cr9WW7oevKc8zvMKHQgffSPHuBoeK8h4B" "dfip-2207-b-no" IJoHi4oyXkKDuGHcKm3UgjT14PlIuHtiUp5t9A1uapftUIdgmY6zQhb/o2FTrH8hhdkdQbgzC6fMfk+JUO0jMwg= $ defi-cli signmessage 8dXgX2qd82eyF4qRUhanypMTrcvVf86rVN "dfip-2207-b-no" HyaRBIAXqbN547Fk5+P+Rqh/KcKkwcS1VqaXGakslFA8KJlnZQj2XOO54yL+hSIdM3cuCNg1RvRcBkjXGuAFHHQ= $ defi-cli signmessage 8Y8kN74DNNGPZbxDHCCzH5yNW4nM1kJhtd "dfip-2207-b-no" IIBTQS/pO0koMeZg7BJMZZ+ayeEH95jigk95c3ieluAcIFWA1NpPBrjwFAd/d50IeWfMGyZSt+kXvf4hiISnVSU= $ defi-cli signmessage 8bEsSfQtaNCfc8UCDQV6HfPuiB2LtcRnpR "dfip-2207-b-no" H9HvnuI3Bi+soZ/gDk8mlSXdph9gnFt4QQPOmqHWNT9hAVjDmVX18hxeG+GMUOYlO5DkEfbncGoiwdmhnES3vhM= $ defi-cli signmessage 8HVmfHsB2QUF2uUrWNs68aoiXxyC21QW19 "dfip-2207-b-no" IKrnda/xk4mssQN7rCVx50R1mkpAISA4zMcxB2qEvNbvXYHuuIO6+ji30zzrqe//X46r9LhsWy+GF9RjRn1cVIw= $ defi-cli signmessage 8ZBjZjFhjnbm2CK92toF5Bvw4DVvbVn7aM "dfip-2207-b-no" H1+XIjE5x1zWpdG2sgNnM+bnuh7TWhBhoztJJlMdHV8VQaPgbpGlHdeTJCvePlCdq4iw6/QVs0up/ATquqjdBMQ= signmessage 8TWPQCWHfdTSur6TZEWRDBCP9G9tGH3YD4 "dfip-2207-b-yes" H/9vrmD4s37CrHvDTAVE9h2/X/OvF5W7v/V6UdF2XP5TGN1o42NyOdYxZDXauP184DFq3KPvs8HUGlehFxKifio= signmessage 8JJSzvSY6Krb127JSwoxHZnpEWwfbFTSre "dfip-2207-b-yes" H+pTJR+MCOtSBOKAc59Yv25gzdKtSkmr/WGd0thsguLQM+0C8qjbM4c8VH3dwUqoy2l+AMdNW6XGaYYG62fsy28= signmessage 8bPt28EHM1Tabbkd1ZMmNydXVty8wofCXA "dfip-2207-b-yes" H7yVaJs08tqifJPXc/qALXF1BaxTKA2Y3TNbrZq4Q8tfOI1NhZOWLD1h/ulwhLhTGEj3z5ivrUo4XY9wvJbGWqg= signmessage 8LXtM3xBk68eEKnfFYTphcpemjabs1mtmz "dfip-2207-b-yes" IKAzVxdy6xf74ajqLUvjXIC89v7LVt2nuCV/QqZTeIrdaLVuLgTK9/8WxU5DTumYGkqvNjmK8xLNkeWQuWJJg0E= signmessage 8Ynwzb9Z9FBrK8D7LTaDtruBJks4SCkhgf "dfip-2207-b-yes" Hw8V3qSbxoKlJbTgXcMyurlmit7QFieUPixdi6qW05OnPnO4P1wKIBDpMswqsFtEz1uRsrr+9MKKlttGlSnYfhw=

addictedtocookies commented 2 years ago

$ defi-cli signmessage 8T2G1f8nzKNDPi9fC3mHfHgkdu18eT6iJW "dfip-2207-b-yes" IB3ppcvtT6cBwrRZq0slv8ZIQJgO7cJyzzc/5f2cfUfRam46T0vjnECyyYTt66bEnDJNRHbk2v+U1tS5q8QcaAM= $ defi-cli signmessage 8HT6qknYpb1M43i6hqB9t3SC1XotaMxtDT "dfip-2207-b-yes" IJZjp0S1+yNzCx8Ok5a0Cr4REL+BquegT2CibnGf4Co0BcnpqFTY0xQVs1M5e5OwwSdGIn+txrfKgu4gYf1a2UU= $ defi-cli signmessage 8TubXASruyitPa98N8ery1GtuP5BZaDTth "dfip-2207-b-yes" Hwrsj1IUVXNEKx5vmpRiEAot6eC6Z6h17QI748r2f6lIPOOy9RxmpgnlY6GHg953LiDQd0qeHcBLib896TefZRk=

rmcookie commented 2 years ago

$ defi-cli signmessage 8a8oePZg9NimfqKWDMZszgxy78PoW7Aqg1 "dfip-2207-b-yes" IA+Liey4lKKGoCnwXDl1tkTecwkoZMLPiXP5jy6WNXmCVUEnak8UlqwW6hubnZu89q3i1GpNTS2pjZ18tWskqn4= $ defi-cli signmessage 8MTKMLEb6Wc1fcimtNC2sCoSra36RJwuaC "dfip-2207-b-yes" H6l4uFWY2QTo2fgECDOnopCasIDse8blY6Ee/se2FDVhQ8Onhlg2OXTtjVZi+tY0aJL6VpMjoyIGE4KxclFgHEc= $ defi-cli signmessage 8TfGnk6o2RSwUDXKKxujVYifTFFmfjys7q "dfip-2207-b-yes" H1ILKiTh3YKqH+CdGHCNFnR3biroMnoK/i/BxTNghEBsIbmd0mf023zt4LFqIqDb6QHkGa8RxjB7m6N93PdWyeQ=

sandstumpen commented 2 years ago

signmessage 8XjGQuumUBGyevsG8Jn4yZQ6QBpkA4ukgM dfip-2207-b-yes H3kTuP4GikplRel6x2h8whguPWbFIj0XgP7ivMhpOEmHT0+UP0R/N++WhTN12oMql4utpev2LO4wvK915yzUBaY=

chicken-george-junior commented 2 years ago

$ defi-cli signmessage 8brUn3gHT24umDuV4uwk4fzSZFrHmsB1HT "dfip-2207-b-yes" H11H5w+Hv0ueDfBEFLkc0CPuRuPmNXfht/lm/3Nh1V/QRJMqlFsJPKhvFOyKlzVwY5lb3xjYkdjc6fHzgVZmjew= signmessage 8QaLNFpB9fgYxu1zhEmLywkGiaJGnAQnJW "dfip-2207-b-yes" INyoYsNP1+G0yXyjpOloFw6e3FSkYN63xpRzI2tz2hX2JrFqePyKP32ho0/omG+6SEVf8/FgZNEv/R4dIUM8+qI=

kneides commented 2 years ago

$ defi-cli signmessage 8HwvE3zhYr7fcsTFu8bh1a7TQueuWC6KQ3 "dfip-2207-b-yes" HzuStpKn9R+uVPEz49LkGPjuNt/R2jTs6OZ8+IVTp0+4KT6/Te8J0E/z58ijvgyS476UaL9WY0e2e67l+X4hmIY= $ defi-cli signmessage 8Lup7XrpLTJNuHQkQd3meaPJ5ShbgyJKCE "dfip-2207-b-yes" HzpeQwYWHVhnTkc8utQWFdteMdVykfLuZti9bQrUgleFakYnv87aQIXwMO7iII4e8Sj5YkXclYh8Hj28BvHeQgg=

DeFiChainLover commented 2 years ago

$ defi-cli signmessage 8Vm9Xt1pB7vzkJdCaJihT4rKKMjmLkdUDC "dfip-2207-b-yes" H+wfzQIAWaHJVahH4gTmmymzzWxu77cLeWAMzOvl+78cJZdVDC/rx6TqyR5kqPCvC3mej98NGo9mNy2bh9uNECQ= $ defi-cli signmessage 8SY9tQaYviDF7Q68dbaNFMrPQpoD9FPyCk "dfip-2207-b-yes" ICmsrryaAM2HQy32sxx5FP71xDTkWTJPoydOjQAonWU4U9DOWGDwt7POnTgejIg8JAMkigIr+56VMiNkOaXDwlo= $ defi-cli signmessage 8YMCXcq567WibXnRtrBdKAiwkhR1EMuvKN "dfip-2207-b-yes" H42DhXPj62ciCiJMbCayd5/ZsrJMc9Wf/KqqmX6k3osgO0mXtREcAzTCBsNK2vrCFn2CQs3KaxSGL6cGWJnx1tY= $ defi-cli signmessage 8KWvcJ1Tzv7xmSL7NhhHT58UKPu5J7LoHy "dfip-2207-b-yes" IIuS3jwl8kdXyY1WQkcyzyYMwJgUYSAO5IiUIsnLs8AeFSm1M6xHVc6RO96UjUMkz9/oQ/wyn6MyNjfRno9EfQM= $ defi-cli signmessage 8KbpstzBkCA41j1K44GZRv8NVARvkGRrxf "dfip-2207-b-yes" H2WGuHxwwHZcC5Y79kjgpIvFias2qQbUEilrihGDfY3dNUn0lfIu5onPCdjZijpS1zQMagq1llMI29G3J2Kbo+I= $ defi-cli signmessage 8THaiD8raw1zeGa6H3qzKNivqCMWoLjYwf "dfip-2207-b-yes" H5oIx4/3fbAx04oNTrqCGiN6DykfruORB1JZOyhddyLGLl8N1xb9vU9G+jM/Fs4muRBEsMDY0C8BZhtbi4FLmnU= $ defi-cli signmessage 8RnyaCsBVfTRWAFC835nG8RQs1Fx1FoV2X "dfip-2207-b-yes" H+a70zTpSH/YOuDVrLSQ9hUUi23cLhM7aq0gg+jiE1omUaXG700KDrUQ9iShBGV5ys3Xi6CLYw5co1y1ndTXKMc= $ defi-cli signmessage 8GKy2PgryNxaxk6LQPDzaQKhp9f5cDM3tt "dfip-2207-b-yes" IBR6RKsV6bZfQEyf/Zg9PrrHajBOEUfwYlDaIjPriK9Oct5CaLaq17AK5nwh46UJhbpqBAb/MabRf+hgwAOzYL0= $ defi-cli signmessage 8K4AGBFrwagca3iT7UnnKzg9J5JuQiz5JK "dfip-2207-b-yes" H9ZKn/VQBwXzOsQCXxVrThUn/2MEk1UrH5lWar+Y8ZOEKfMyBsE608M8wDY1a1lYE4rRFf2+i1IKKh/jwB9G8LU= $ defi-cli signmessage 8Zppd91EDpkj1jrcfvcxtnPNxhFtNB8xZ9 "dfip-2207-b-yes" H4cODOIQkCCBSdvU8TlmRSNBGSD5DcRPGq9zS/7F6hM/Eh7SZclm7UEtsMjkwump8qJLBdSxmPJUzcILAtPY1jg= $ defi-cli signmessage 8Rcvi8JtY6UQ99j9TS1bspYYVHEBKnnkuk "dfip-2207-b-yes" H1MR9tZ0CVjE++FCksERUb3pySGAsZ86YJvz5B8Za7AWeckrP0leE5Z09E6UFFfv4DnPRZd6W2oA5xtfg64f8G8= $ defi-cli signmessage 8RBbc498fiMjieQLq493Y31FoL32fi6Bhf "dfip-2207-b-yes" H/MIBC7v8A/AoG6H+nMsj8s+Q1HNq0vAWkZRh7f9z6fIVFc5mRq2GWK2qRwFr4AR0QdIELEEwyifQ+aHMLbH/wM= $ defi-cli signmessage 8Lre7shBqc9b9rXqxsV435wohiW5efRKQw "dfip-2207-b-yes" HyyChhurnBRUNXE8Ad+pYhGnab3hcY3XYO6KFZp7XgauIaTmn0zt3mq1RU7T/h0z5yXQcGKc0Zu5Yhv6LKpZKew= $ defi-cli signmessage 8MFezpQ1CZkidq59bpW7daLz6ctC1q7aeL "dfip-2207-b-yes" IKRlmMCKdHpq+gLRnfFpf4eStkVOuZSJN5kSLHIuBSH2fddh238n/wwr8u9EB75iIXOtS7dE7YNIWQDsvimwNls= $ defi-cli signmessage 8JPPdXi1yk3k8HGU6SUAtweqRf2EcUJQ3D "dfip-2207-b-yes" IKIYR2ltjSTegNDbyUb3+37e4pHAQaZRhNiVfs6dBRxpfPsaRV0ob/0fVqgOBwy07vK0V3Xf9bL212izEEqDogg= $ defi-cli signmessage 8cNo2Z3c2VfZbKMtxNbnrpdh2jbFDui2tr "dfip-2207-b-yes" H0ZAIx9BLKz702jzCWR6EPWBVOLlQDacsr/00PZ3flUTU0d594MUME7sniZxC20U2A1qjE70qV9U5NDe3Bg4/fs= $ defi-cli signmessage 8SLuVC4ncN7tSwUgxBmUERHGKs4q6Qi1rX "dfip-2207-b-yes" H2aKtGDzoxEbAaZ3XSuC5Y7No/lw0jiUmFYpanOwOT64a9sYCUADJtEWTxo3xz2sNJ9datCbKAg18po0G2+vu5o= $ defi-cli signmessage 8Jqd2cDgkpVTQyNN7PfNBy88e47VB6Jw6t "dfip-2207-b-yes" H90Ca9aDPJ/prTSM2OYSiQ9HYxsUHMwytW8kZ+ArAvq6U4z0rWd2+SEgP9ZBYEFk0f/o0ro3MBgNF9W5GWi1DmM= $ defi-cli signmessage 8WAd7WttGhgKPQvmVNN1nJhEc5ZJ6Su4YP "dfip-2207-b-yes" IMUB/d+bHLqIowKMmaZXPB1sRYz19tZPnNJCMTp18VbhCy0TRS2AWxu1Kh9S0bYuQAiz9vU86pIz7swm1OgNdC4= $ defi-cli signmessage 8d8DEAreP71CmMxcUTM3J2rbpkDUCAcW9D "dfip-2207-b-yes" IDdDbEag28UvFNF3DNJ8tGfMn8oIhq0L86uxTU0klbwvZLWGFJ6Bs5Dx7MhfUQGmL3f8ve4dxyVsqVI699MEkt4= $ defi-cli signmessage 8Tbeoci4jLHvuniFdx3nAy7iDV8LDshGuk "dfip-2207-b-yes" H0Eij+Tk584CHToMTINpaet7ElVcglub/I15bkV0+MQRK8J9nGFOlnTidzbOliIEpCARYONrT7dQIglgF0Rryw4= $ defi-cli signmessage 8LNoZDSnPsVQox9Vb3xjzg8gotFxnzdoFR "dfip-2207-b-yes" Hw4g/rskR/cg+4HnRBTs8xFZTdEje1391MgZiUZIJkbqAXQJASAmfNkse3QmaZAanSeuz4srsM6+of6d4i30qxo= $ defi-cli signmessage 8Xjrgt4JeJeaiPETmwQEqoybwL8TNk1x4a "dfip-2207-b-yes" HwmwO8r3CtTRvmm+y2jyGEBZI9MCLfduTlDhCagAla5OaVYwv/CKew0jJ7raxP8X/a7ezN+N9jt9NxhJdAL+YFI= $ defi-cli signmessage 8LemikVbCnVc6BPbJdCUgHeKgDUnEctfra "dfip-2207-b-yes" H6YKyXuFfcy17AUOLNxoYC64IZfEfnv/fZ37TzlFYhusQsJCUOsmGPdfbDhv2MB+wYugNRVZrqUvgnVZD0rDuIY= $ defi-cli signmessage 8MSztMvUao3sehmZCd1VwPAQy84RbTaw6b "dfip-2207-b-yes" IGKaLGvMJ1I/XBCE0roX4/Hh0znup3FAKWW7ajQB4aRibAceeKQ4J5SI4dh7xfrQ1NzjHmhKtnhNeNW/huWHanM= $ defi-cli signmessage 8ZBTJxB3Wp78hLTsjVpTRqGQFgpgq9xAoz "dfip-2207-b-yes" H68uGB/fxTix40bsIrJeeBayldlb715/ojuewMOeyolFOncGmmrA4v1Wvn93Jpgs9V1Ii5QGT/Z7wEzpnXgMFqM= $ defi-cli signmessage 8XfiWVYhCiGgcoBL1CKJDaiWoJxpvcY338 "dfip-2207-b-yes" H/Cnakcukkhl4d6e0YiAg37sYJvoVBgN4/6f8UQuw2QGO9VdiboW11OJhSu78HwKqEi0/uwFTvtTq3h622y6XMo= $ defi-cli signmessage 8UPfVSEG3TTDHFdeWLJDbvWrxDpYehV236 "dfip-2207-b-yes" IKjs+JSkXwZFfZ1HFqSNwK/Ehbp5uzK0fOk06JYGBEvPM1NmQqQnzuREUbgi050N+2hTJV/XTNfgzVsXEYQM2xo= $ defi-cli signmessage 8Vitm4tWh1au9MXydPDLQHTfC5N3RupPEU "dfip-2207-b-yes" H1Z2TAKUSE7YtF2DkNYqOrdI/PDsK+7QfgW1SGb0eHPBUB3eMLlvonabS61Yr+SIgWTqpZ3E4j2QdcaEW4oCpJc= $ defi-cli signmessage 8HU4a8Ab8mQUshsnpUrVyLwPmF19YqurLp "dfip-2207-b-yes" H+16OTgihasRiNJL42YYYQws1opjxuLRk9xZfboLF4RjUZRng1N/RCt5L2/8n1O/4Tpajqimp+rc0MbVxALbi4Q= $ defi-cli signmessage 8T8ivyTpW4Uzdd8eidEvHUfv4vLGMNs1xe "dfip-2207-b-yes" H0d+hvLa5s+cPkijJxZxErZc4GmDM7HRMaOQxeLS4M2OdxwvkcfREOI04s+YhAJZQHYVNoQlVFUsUNJX6ESZ/eE= $ defi-cli signmessage 8TpjNiwMuZwSMtvFo1nRMgGPRHhk7CZPy6 "dfip-2207-b-yes" IKCOMprBNY0+QLsTfUO1HTD1784dKCohDTTt3Un2e9NMaah6dIBejd7OzyPMzFqlutMSR//pcWeKselmAGJYO+w= $ defi-cli signmessage 8QB1oP1CEFghGYvk5cKrDFDAZcioZPF63P "dfip-2207-b-yes" Hxm3siFFDiY4ryUq0ZUrZbo5VQ75lW0R7cdNrNPUrH4SLAni7LZd08kY+vdawgbALTP68XkFjT6oNgo3t3bt3yA= $ defi-cli signmessage 8bocwwgRfGSxNHUfcds7AAhbvZbvF7vTwW "dfip-2207-b-yes" IIZc85Obt8ZCXCaGM3fzEac0mFIuc6z0O0LdwuKEfbc/VX2DtPiec69LepxE1XSsQzqaYpSgmrzOZkXtWcGPPco= $ defi-cli signmessage 8GAZMQBZKbgd9gCihMhHtZJMo961veLZ8B "dfip-2207-b-yes" H4+rTel+N4l/NHhsk+izCS85g2T5XG1pBa4igfXP21e3fbgtM7q8Fh/tg4mvXSgQNFuZHUSFpzHhU1DbZ+UmF80= $ defi-cli signmessage 8TVJbiXGa5qLjC7w1L9jVpbkBu51eHjfMZ "dfip-2207-b-yes" HyY+RwwWwq2lxBYKSZht5hccmZv+u9OUDmK8lFyI+1mMeLhzpP/y14ln9eMZ3ZoDnNoRDNjpBLH4Pr9jxDg0G2g= $ defi-cli signmessage 8FC8zJqPcPVDXqprbjH2pkxaP9tBeymMV3 "dfip-2207-b-yes" H9EG3obi70XWAt5Do0hf4RdX3jDVSgMXdhNTXpGB/sYnbcnWjOQt2jUnEkwwfYDJHHJhyNTVpia3UB+73i9bGqA= $ defi-cli signmessage 8KdW19zuCC5JMWfSJ8WsUjUGKFBEVjHir6 "dfip-2207-b-yes" IOJ5NJkWVfshb/Rnk0QLjEIzUnf6pflf8/ZvA1au6HUPBLnmb5r1i8R1KzCB7UMBuLq4ZSMBtO4iQBjnsPpJcCk= $ defi-cli signmessage 8XJAF8wJaNQcrBxUCHHvpbsuMhAL8UMZSo "dfip-2207-b-yes" IG+CGkbHiU14JRDz3iM0mg8VyiCQS/6BhViQS4b2i1J9BbaSovQPkooUhGscMEoSNO859fVAh/wicIHFNxiTZ6g= $ defi-cli signmessage 8SCc5Ehc4RkG4ieLqzKxtAMrNfErEB2Zss "dfip-2207-b-yes" H+ZEEFqj8Ud+IUus7dXXCop3JbwkWjUHVzag/OrOH9VtOtrUf++3882Fw/EZopZfz5K6AJQDzQTILZ5UvdZsf2E= $ defi-cli signmessage 8Z7Q5pdtBsfP4d7HsW58ZUSxYVPTxQmucm "dfip-2207-b-yes" Hw1QRLNwUFoZEp9us5aVAUHj4fzaa5QmZ49gGbWsuXV5ZJNRDw/ziNs2tl+CVicFqO4viaBrf4+r37IK3vpZTkw= $ defi-cli signmessage 8S5kUq5axL7Kg7eGwkaJRiSWXpyHEdJ8Lx "dfip-2207-b-yes" HwUmJ5CTb73oai8QteUwesvSRj7fT/ca/S2StWzsDWPeEwYgWksYD3bHCP9PQG2a9Ig1ctms9EgiI510MzBK9Us= $ defi-cli signmessage 8GurX5UptFxqgtGuESc1qQ5zK1DqrKXuaB "dfip-2207-b-yes" IJXi/LnOvCUA6Cvg5GZRrSyBdf2GiUir+R0c9uvwPCb6DIJK/gimsMCbtwk1wMyjbINv6A5KpdreabbLPFf19NU= $ defi-cli signmessage 8GEhTT9q3LDqZuaGREeyYmHxYt9s9C7tKJ "dfip-2207-b-yes" IAGF5rE/shM3ETDU8+Jo1DZ9gu9b9vokctCDf5OHpSjZV0ZULjpEXI0JY2blhMUS0adgEz7yRmPuA08x9J45jUk= $ defi-cli signmessage 8co5FbMqSsJdCafZYfvQ3tvaQwbF3tpmP6 "dfip-2207-b-yes" IJpse65MybJUnFpzQzKnQP3OE3iVxCe4jRfkXwVm1/48T8sDgUEpwhw2GLcXGihNkBD5D0HkxNhTXt/Vjbe/VO0= $ defi-cli signmessage 8c5Xzydq1R6MYPCUAa6d2VMsmVdcWrSDag "dfip-2207-b-yes" IJJDZLyRQyudHddkoMAUMqIIVgu9up9sLEJsUX/g2Ye0U5PQSsryUqvNZFCqPaE5hcPRyYmh2agxyOHnGtU9PvI= $ defi-cli signmessage 8Whs1ggBEy7CjFTd5C27s31oFPWmXN48Xc "dfip-2207-b-yes" H4xWnVwVYqVPNoTGT1FryCs75SBHNla1UKRJeMGUQtL0V79yP0boGIqrbO2RmTP0IcWR7BrrOjZb4urWVSNoqHI= $ defi-cli signmessage 8RJdymyDJqrVS36kKSMTBdsZwfh1zCWcYN "dfip-2207-b-yes" Hzne4zBNeqJErh+nadtChKW4EC1DZ2QDwdMUc4+vDYG4EdpjRGT79sHYJvQvsYYqDSy5AJul8qZ30JcYT7PffRI= $ defi-cli signmessage 8RiG1mz3CA1mS6jXzg1h1Pz6696x5rsTec "dfip-2207-b-yes" ID51/7A8Tx73+t7ZlCuCuFg1ld979cfPo+r11Bgff/xpcbl8NCLjqC3bY4cIFSpLCVvJRAVlkVzaGuTf7gIrj/U= $ defi-cli signmessage 8cJsb4UmxnwLBrgeWfo2K49gUq1rEXaPFG "dfip-2207-b-yes" IJp8WPfQcEF2WGabPARphLnnL3g0j9+B8iX/obb0hkkUQHOfoIVuv4SK9O/2cop4YUkw9nNl4ngN0nDtEh/Wwvs= $ defi-cli signmessage 8P9pwKU8ukYybjVkSrTWjRJRPuV1pcHHrX "dfip-2207-b-yes" IH7quFWVtHA4spleV7Lp5qKMa8Nm8gwELT7+8OeikmiDbpH7ZOwF0DlgR7rj0iAuFbyglEW6cSPShoLs54Nx45M= $ defi-cli signmessage 8aurcQcJjs1nSYqMsRAhrHtGNEzPSdZ9c7 "dfip-2207-b-yes" H907Xv7RW1LBGOp8vW+2SNKyZJ0elMDL4cKIJnbCKTNBOB9BTn2casQsPXMStBK9qei5Pqu+dvb5PeMQG74jkQw= $ defi-cli signmessage 8ZbtfywWaLQMuKehQtFE45vDUsFYdkwJMF "dfip-2207-b-yes" Hw3t4a0Vi5yVE5nYH8y/zGwnjEROrva5YPL59xnRE2cKNn9BFMyZOA8eT/KfP90A7DumyaUCv3Rt/xJjsZyszB4= $ defi-cli signmessage 8PjaaVMpzu4eUALzUyB7pu3DTZXBgpTDUF "dfip-2207-b-yes" ID2Wd/4ogcD6BOB7pOf5L2en88sVPOVRC8Z4XAlOlEM5enCR5hedCBdlmq+U9ECU8eiEUvWwo1nQKZmU0p1Rj7c= $ defi-cli signmessage 8M62UjwHs9xC3Nt1DSBkjcTTJrJ3YXNap4 "dfip-2207-b-yes" IA7JxLaaUC/WRpdkTO2i4/e7FWUxhDnDTKUnvsRXcDLQMUz8TPjlzUTTiRxf7heQ5avvaTtVP+0tqYp9/gHFTwA= $ defi-cli signmessage 8MphHNirj95PQnwCUZNUhj9cfPGpquJNey "dfip-2207-b-yes" IJC6bCAS+cqXtNdh5iBsFE15zH1JPG2cDkd6ScRAxx+aQTIMEorVp/5S+i22N110p5uMXdiIeeO1EMftD0eldY8= $ defi-cli signmessage 8YRX3srYkZWAJ54UaUpSmifhsBE7TpmJyN "dfip-2207-b-yes" INx89OD/L009feuU08RTW6IXPWh6xxUgUJ48GrHIAmg6MU/7sji2hHtphLsY/xUNzBxa8AB++KyOCcqoooajScg= $ defi-cli signmessage 8PQiixk6tiusnWFXqCLJfuNK4jd1eSirLa "dfip-2207-b-yes" IInBxyWQplCGj6H0ruR9DTJsxz4gvHp/Fp+ohMRlmRNcRuGOMQK/9LYW3sVd6cz+T7UbSL3sLpV9wr+Bn9quXX0= $ defi-cli signmessage 8QGhSJNonDu6e2BpFdWYwspTTiyfJScqPZ "dfip-2207-b-yes" H6iKMA3TnedWKQvTcfMErKL185bzNkMywrdZWmJdZFehGtFd97YQQnni/iwarW9UJfxNUUGX9UXlontDciYRDok= $ defi-cli signmessage 8T658AH6iWeEFWLH9pHsYZ5N3HuzsdxxQe "dfip-2207-b-yes" IJ7YGHjAPGknn4NkE1XdmK1uagE7oM5hyOr/YJ+82un6ffrI41b6MulnnbWlfM6QozerZqBz+PYfsgZM7A+I+sA= $ defi-cli signmessage 8QzfhB5ftY8pJvxLMVkFN8FSbuxNjgVeG2 "dfip-2207-b-yes" HyGNGrgj7ROBjYETCEuOhe99R/zSVBXfvqOGVuqkQ5p6dQ+FhTkcZFjEar2pKQS2eQxRYpIM7zz9HuwEyt4P4FQ= $ defi-cli signmessage 8SbG8s7RM3uWUwVNvSkWb2QYKitnb7zUJU "dfip-2207-b-yes" INHoG+tCn7H9V8w7zNuooUqlwLxmR17ijD0ptAvYkMECJP8w/THq9VEfOzWlc5hZxuNzGRdGrM2fPh56WSw6JBg= $ defi-cli signmessage 8Pd833jPvne3ZWrn5jcAqVAXaZML2Sak4A "dfip-2207-b-yes" H+6dhFKiNur0zthKixs3MUl5FNWMDc8uV+IG1hFkPf+bChJtHNeVk6SvO9/Vob0T+rhWacfdOoFBMwj3wT4Uk6k= $ defi-cli signmessage 8GYLLTaRBNFDANVQf6hBSvH8ShtpXcpTLt "dfip-2207-b-yes" IIgSEe6Ss9D0bifBWccvVqdnAMMwC115JgfMMV8dloFUGyX7HMz+7l2IKNAHlQaRtA21DGaEA7vqoD1P9QFohKQ= $ defi-cli signmessage 8a6ZYU5vXYVYJcgfQXYZCLwqdAKoEb6cRY "dfip-2207-b-yes" IA6X1RPQivzYmEz7iXdF9GShaJqM2vuDAfrvXE26FIEkEHq3/T/IfETOx1UtBo2OFDCp+5KMVVZLd3e6y5r7kLo= $ defi-cli signmessage 8KFeJA9vYXjoNrgEntbBVoF6XFri4iozoE "dfip-2207-b-yes" IA5r9ruOSHtIEFzkzc8YmtUU9HAP3sxAx4VYtLMdmVpGCqwKuUYIgoZYp6XhlguSfwqFIUmTrRlhS/OX/3KfTC4= $ defi-cli signmessage 8UTLDXmSYGa25Ew6vGVsQurFM4Mr5puBpp "dfip-2207-b-yes" IFvRYSsIb9vXm5CA+gxMVzY2e0RGm3MIhFvfhZTQ7lWucbuMI10IbWh1rdF/gP9W/3XklLQ9Qjult1yiMDpnDnQ= $ defi-cli signmessage 8Q5qU7dsUcB7pKd3kSP1ua3DqxovWFotpk "dfip-2207-b-yes" IEeWJa7d+G/ou4zHEJ5HAJKO/3lZTyWKUGJXvrbiGJcmcNpUNRSYXUdxF6onhEFTrnJUiOzX6UR9ZiBZtB/GBio= $ defi-cli signmessage 8bHmnKHfGi4YWuMb2W3cCbAspiYtcPM7ZS "dfip-2207-b-yes" INuaKQUkVW4Wf4ZmdI3iZMiRMmP8kl1CqpFqxk0NGIT9FZJbpDqWnBGVfbwhXTPqP9E4k8Erdi9aifLdOsFFXqs= $ defi-cli signmessage 8bv4A4tvEaTbGTsqVn4LqQSqf73VaRubUi "dfip-2207-b-yes" H3p9B2ryx1NimZQdEyGhNWuBUBXrbeimicidI3Xfz0WBVmZ+Qip4dIGEbxbC3aeccHFI/yKZ134SNpY/L2RwTkQ= $ defi-cli signmessage 8ZmCuY5u92QUujHmtY2YjKv6VpFXcouCTn "dfip-2207-b-yes" IKVOW6RVdix/q9FVdPqSsWBT/o07eKZbNlke5aAXw0ANRZf0kqkmHpEhs3iqi6JORLby8gLa7uompWjUGpMUaBA= $ defi-cli signmessage 8PPohq5rfv6RbNKg5Saxn5Ppty1DJHwwQL "dfip-2207-b-yes" Hz6nhjCgw1IkW9dPW3HrxgpnL1BkK5mH5ihQ+CQWJsgjLp5GxA5BMzYPmi/wJrG5hTHOQBzkM4FIio6j9erwu5Q= $ defi-cli signmessage 8V1KJh6WztGJwsBYSyRLKpNnaaS2PMNZtq "dfip-2207-b-yes" IN+CMKxFAW2PEub+o04OjQh6Y6h1mSSWKYpkFofP64/aZtLpiqjBGonXMenOwDTUtvsqCuO8ZiTc7v3EyZIvxOA= $ defi-cli signmessage 8dgBBQJ5jzJ9WJ7MVCd6cwfyipJZ1UCWod "dfip-2207-b-yes" H3avHxaJxuhMu/5EhmX9y3HPGld3ZqxhjKcGv3XaGp3cRswKP/B8PAFR9HL1fu7tfesEAN1V4zYCRhW1+gf6Ook= $ defi-cli signmessage 8NyFjfFgGQu7jfFVMUyvnUHKjcVXXK72jv "dfip-2207-b-yes" IGswE4t5zUpfU4RD5ReutppBb4MzikYPpQI0jJpXyNXgee+DTcM0CUgP9e697+1cYUK3MQOW87dJlbBwjtNKEyw= $ defi-cli signmessage 8dyC53f6r9GaEFCHmZmZevVQDJYyRaSd1m "dfip-2207-b-yes" H7vjjF0dZdYXqXdgLaJwpdJnv/OXpw3/pSOf+XN1uK4UOF1RPr7Xjpoh1rRQgeRFE9x0XPumywGm2Djodcr5vtA= $ defi-cli signmessage 8dFrQvsj6RUZvF77k2LYTCtmRGPdj6QJZN "dfip-2207-b-yes" IMvf4KxC3Kw+w9QyQAtlbRwAUtPMhLXYG0pjY+qKAY7ISlH1E38AsWblLE81iPecFqeF2jVmDnaUEJtrK6bvpa8= $ defi-cli signmessage 8Yt34fTYRwzvJnhbd1FdAPLcW5uikLgRgn "dfip-2207-b-yes" H8gSpKboRqGuM5ksgk0pw2kSRkUyRAi+dGxLtef/SuLFVUTk4OaRRoYdgScbF0jkqxFdMDOS+S8Zu4C3MM6+LsQ= $ defi-cli signmessage 8WiDNE31tGbmuuAymZro5y7m3uGS5AHRgg "dfip-2207-b-yes" H6mxP+8qk4f8WF6wgOHxBPQzbwwKdLraIrnaM1O24NwZDGTjPxpBl8ERF/xhbH49AC4JXw16gj4wxtCoD1ObdYw= $ defi-cli signmessage 8bes6iKNfLXvmd7JjBctfo5UM5P3MB2Rt2 "dfip-2207-b-yes" H6aDI6ZtGUwR4vwUhNlBD4tJsMYFcvl6SH0Qo/WbKy+Xc/svZHSraqPqKjW780QdNU2m2lwmESo30WSxDg6UXjo= $ defi-cli signmessage 8FQQwqyT2eiW3CdU1nsNNeS3c7uJ1VxyNg "dfip-2207-b-yes" IDwCwXhFTuK9q7DeP2tLWSl7W7Gb85t7Rt/MK/cIA3AjV3GunjFQbYs1tI8V8IH3m/fM6dbDCqnIqBgHDhpcy84= $ defi-cli signmessage 8cwX1HZt5YrrrCDRPuxhKCX7cgMqwH4Byx "dfip-2207-b-yes" HwUfBIOTw+EzLbDPgOJuUJsGRlqRb4Vdh5Um1sd2fwRnU6sx8kvnQUZaZjb+DAG9WBu9jMGPsV45j0CnIZCMmcw=

DrDrCat commented 2 years ago

$ defi-cli signmessage 8RLGUA8T7GX5xKGQ56VtoJH9gd8DdCUthL "dfip-2207-b-no" IPD2LbbtRA+I5xa7/a2KGkJQha8WHYmtvMcqnJ1WMNgjZlobkGQs4ClaYEh8yjTr0LCYUGQKJX+W+UZ9QOFAB/E=

saurin13 commented 2 years ago

signmessage 8doBDqvnPdfcHHjDBk1AqdywwaUNf8WgxS "cfp-2207-b-no" H3fB45SBu+t0wPsYwpue5LHbz+2wC2KwDkA7wqU+JgD5C7lfQdJnS1DaxbSOmqJbPjrrbbHqFI/Wp+elo0brwIk=

surangap commented 2 years ago 
RESULTS for dfip-2207-b
===========================
dfip-2207-b is approved by 441 votes majority
YES: 474
NO: 33
Neutral: 5
Total valid votes: 512
Total rejected votes: 89
===========================

mnstate_validate.log validate_dfip-2207-b_failed.log validate_dfip.log