Open Dethada opened 3 months ago
Thank you for raising this issue. While we acknowledge that this may cause inconvenience to some users, addressing this particular issue is currently not within our scope due to existing project priorities and resource constraints. We have mentioned also mentioned it as a parameter constraint in the UG. UG:
Our team is currently focused on addressing critical bugs and implementing essential features to enhance user experience. However, we have noted your feedback and will consider it for future updates to allow more flexible names. Thank you for your understanding.
Team chose [response.NotInScope
]
Reason for disagreement: I believe that allowing of special characters is a necessary function as this is an app targeted at computing professionals for professional usage that does not contraint the targeted user base to people that only knows people with names without special characters, which is good, it should not be restricted that way, hence the limitation should be resolved instead.
Knowing contacts' names is a basic form of respect. To keep professionality, which is important for a professional app targeted to professional users, it is all the more important to respect other people's names and hence be able to store their name as is. And as an applicant, users do not really get to request for a contact for you with no special characters in their name, so such situations cannot be actively avoided by users.
This would not be an uncommon problem as even from a more localised point of view, in Singapore, many people have commas, hyphens and slashes in their names, and not to mention in a global context how different can naming conventions and formats be. Personally, my groupmate also has a comma in their name.
Thus, I believe by intentionally implementing this field to be discriminatory is a huge oversight of the team.
Bug Description
Names have the following constraint given in the UG.
This means users are unable to add a name with
/
which is not rare in Singapore, such asJohn Doe s/o Mathur
.Steps to Reproduce
add cn/Google n/John Doe s/o Mathur p/98765432 e/johnd@example.com a/311, Clementi Ave 2, #02-25 tt/121220221400 i/Birthday: 12 May 2001 s/5000 pl/Java t/friends t/owesMoney pri/2
Expected Behavior
The command should succeed.