Correctly template `spec.type` and `spec.lifecycle` in `copier-template.yaml`

DiamondLightSource / python-copier-template

Diamond's opinionated copier template for pure Python projects managed by pip

Apache License 2.0

4 stars 2 forks source link

Correctly template `spec.type` and `spec.lifecycle` in `copier-template.yaml` #181

Closed garryod closed 2 weeks ago

garryod commented 1 month ago

There are currently 32 components erroneously marked with spec.type=documentation and spec.lifecycle=experimental in the developer portal, the vast majority of which originated from this template. Please could you update the template such that these fields must be specified. Additionally, it would be good to remove sscc as the default for owner as it has been used in 22 of the 32 aforementioned repos

callumforrester commented 1 month ago

Looking at this now...

I agree that spec.type=documentation is erroneous, but I'm inclined to say that spec.lifecycle=experimental is a reasonable default value for new projects. Of the list you linked, I would consider almost all of the components that come from this template to be experimental, some may be arguably alpha. I may have misunderstood the classification though, open to other views.

GDYendell commented 1 month ago

I agree most projects will start as experimental, but if it is a copier question then people will (might) read it when they update to the latest version and consider changing it.