DimensionDev / Maskbook-Talks

Where talks of Maskbook happen.
7 stars 1 forks source link

Brainstorming: Natural Post Integration for Plugins #50

Open neruthes opened 4 years ago

neruthes commented 4 years ago

We will try finding a better solution for https://github.com/DimensionDev/Maskbook/issues/1360 here.

OiCkilL commented 4 years ago

image Here is my design. I thought it would make it easier to use.

neruthes commented 4 years ago

image Here is my design. I thought it would make it easier to use.

LGTM. Any other idea for entry point? In my initial draft, the entry point is in a dropdown menu and it seems that you have alternative proposals for it.

OiCkilL commented 4 years ago

image Here is my design. I thought it would make it easier to use.

LGTM. Any other idea for entry point? In my initial draft, the entry point is in a dropdown menu and it seems that you have alternative proposals for it.

The dropdown menu not a best solution. It is not user-friendly to add encrypted descriptions after using the plug-in.

neruthes commented 4 years ago

image Here is my design. I thought it would make it easier to use.

LGTM. Any other idea for entry point? In my initial draft, the entry point is in a dropdown menu and it seems that you have alternative proposals for it.

The dropdown menu not a best solution. It is not user-friendly to add encrypted descriptions after using the plug-in.

Is there a specific alternative solution that you recommend?

Jack-Works commented 4 years ago

I thought you are talking about API here

neruthes commented 4 years ago

I thought you are talking about API here

API is important, too. Let it be discussed here. Also feel free to create a separate issue if you find necessary.

OiCkilL commented 4 years ago

image Here is my design. I thought it would make it easier to use.

LGTM. Any other idea for entry point? In my initial draft, the entry point is in a dropdown menu and it seems that you have alternative proposals for it.

The dropdown menu not a best solution. It is not user-friendly to add encrypted descriptions after using the plug-in.

Is there a specific alternative solution that you recommend?

Like facebook may better?

截屏2020-08-11 下午2 10 52 截屏2020-08-11 下午2 10 58
neruthes commented 4 years ago

image Here is my design. I thought it would make it easier to use.

LGTM. Any other idea for entry point? In my initial draft, the entry point is in a dropdown menu and it seems that you have alternative proposals for it.

The dropdown menu not a best solution. It is not user-friendly to add encrypted descriptions after using the plug-in.

Is there a specific alternative solution that you recommend?

Like facebook may better?

截屏2020-08-11 下午2 10 52 截屏2020-08-11 下午2 10 58

We have 2 restrictions related to this matter:

Both restrictions propose challenges to the idea of merging the entry of Plugins-defined custom types to SNS-specific lists of types.

OiCkilL commented 4 years ago

image Here is my design. I thought it would make it easier to use.

LGTM. Any other idea for entry point? In my initial draft, the entry point is in a dropdown menu and it seems that you have alternative proposals for it.

The dropdown menu not a best solution. It is not user-friendly to add encrypted descriptions after using the plug-in.

Is there a specific alternative solution that you recommend?

Like facebook may better?

截屏2020-08-11 下午2 10 52 截屏2020-08-11 下午2 10 58

We have 2 restrictions related to this matter:

  • It should work in the current framework before future refactoring.
  • Its entry should be as similar as possible across different social networks.

Both restrictions propose challenges to the idea of merging the entry of Plugins-defined custom types to SNS-specific lists of types.

The entry is identical on this case, both from the Compose window. I don't understand the limitations of the current framework, I asked the Binrui and he said there is no problem to implement it.However, the drop-down menu idea would be difficult to implement and would be a UX bug.

neruthes commented 4 years ago

image Here is my design. I thought it would make it easier to use.

LGTM. Any other idea for entry point? In my initial draft, the entry point is in a dropdown menu and it seems that you have alternative proposals for it.

The dropdown menu not a best solution. It is not user-friendly to add encrypted descriptions after using the plug-in.

Is there a specific alternative solution that you recommend?

Like facebook may better?

截屏2020-08-11 下午2 10 52 截屏2020-08-11 下午2 10 58

We have 2 restrictions related to this matter:

  • It should work in the current framework before future refactoring.
  • Its entry should be as similar as possible across different social networks.

Both restrictions propose challenges to the idea of merging the entry of Plugins-defined custom types to SNS-specific lists of types.

The entry is identical on this case, both from the Compose window. I don't understand the limitations of the current framework, I asked the Binrui and he said there is no problem to implement it.However, the drop-down menu idea would be difficult to implement and would be a UX bug.

A prototype in Figma will be helpful for further detailed evaluation, as we visualize the idea.