DiseaseOntology / HumanDiseaseOntology

Repository for the Human Disease Ontology.
Creative Commons Zero v1.0 Universal
336 stars 109 forks source link

Schwannomatosis (DOID:0111252 and DOID:3204) #1218

Closed sbello closed 11 months ago

sbello commented 1 year ago

OMIM has updated records related to Schwannomatosis and renamed several entries

OMIM:101000 | Neurofibromatosis, Type II; NF2 | Schwannomatosis, Vestibular; SWNV | DOID:0111252 | neurofibromatosis 2 (DO label) OMIM:162091 | Schwannomatosis 1; SWNTS1 | Schwannomatosis 1; SWN1 | DOID:3204 | neurofibromatosis 2 (DO label) OMIM:615670 | Schwannomatosis 2; SWNTS2 | Schwannomatosis 2; SWN2 | DOID:3204

Please review and revise the labels.

Also DOID:3204 needs a definition and child terms for the 2 different OMIM terms.

allenbaron commented 11 months ago

This is strongly related to #703 which remains open. I will re-review that ticket and include updates here for schwannomatosis, since they are now clearly delineated as distinct entities.

allenbaron commented 11 months ago

International consensus recently recommended that NF2 (DOID:0111252) and the two schwannomatosis subtypes be reclassified together as types of schwannomatosis (DOID:3204). Previously, schwannomatosis was a grouping term that excluded NF2, including only SWN1 & SWN2.

Plotkin SR, Messiaen L, Legius E, et al. Updated diagnostic criteria and nomenclature for neurofibromatosis type 2 and schwannomatosis: An international consensus recommendation. Genet Med. 2022;24(9):1967-1977. doi:10.1016/j.gim.2022.05.007 PMID:35674741

While neurofibromas and schwannomas are similar they appear to be distinct entities and a stated goal of the international consensus in re-grouping these diseases was to prevent confusion of NF2/SWN with NF1 (neurofibromatosis). However, schwannomatosis (SWN1/2) has traditionally been described as a subtype of neurofibromatosis (DOID:8712, #703). I plan to split schwannomatosis from neurofibromatosis, each as a a child of syndrome with their respective subtypes (if any). An appropriate alternative would be to place schwannomatosis a child of neurofibromatosis.

Currently, DOID:3204 is named neurilemmomatosis, is a child of neurilemmoma (DOID:3192), and lacks a definition and subtypes as noted above by Sue.

One more note: Orphanet ~and SNOMED~* have switched to using neurofibromatosis/schwannomatosis (ORPHA:634518) and do not include the individual grouping diseases. I think this will likely perpetuate the conflation of NF1 with NF2/SWN and should be avoided.

*sorry just Orphanet has taken this approach, SNOMED hasn't updated schwannomatosis or neurofibromatosis to reflect the international recommendation yet.

allenbaron commented 11 months ago

Instead of syndrome, the parent of these terms will be changed to RASopathy (which is a child of syndrome).

Support for this update

I could not find any direct evidence for SMARCB1 but given the syndromic nature of RASopathies, the SWN overlapping phenotypes, and the support listed here, I think it makes sense to include them all.