DiseaseOntology / HumanDiseaseOntology

Repository for the Human Disease Ontology.
Creative Commons Zero v1.0 Universal
336 stars 109 forks source link

Review 'mediastinal neurilemmoma' (DOID:6175) & children #1249

Open allenbaron opened 11 months ago

allenbaron commented 11 months ago

'mediastinal neurilemmoma' (DOID:6175), which is a schwann cell tumor, currently has the children:

Both of these tumors are derived from different types of cells and need to be re-classified.

allenbaron commented 11 months ago

'mediastinum leiomyoma' (DOID:5123) is an inferred child due to the EQ axiom:'benign neoplasm' and ('disease has location' some mediastinum). That axiom is not specific enough, it needs to be defined by cell type.

The grandparent of 'mediastinal neurilemmoma', neurilemmoma (DOID:3192; aka schwannoma), is the highest level benign tumor of this cell type and has the cell type textual definition: "A neuroma that is characterized as a benign nerve sheath tumor that is composed of Schwann cells." It lacks an equivalence axiom.

It makes the most sense to add an EQ cell type axiom to neurilemmoma (DOID:3192) and to redefine 'mediastinal neurilemmoma' based on this relationship.

'mediastinal neurilemmoma' lacks a textual definition and needs to be reviewed more generally for updates.

allenbaron commented 11 months ago

May want to consider renaming neurilemmoma(s) to schwannoma(s). Both are used but schwannoma is used about 1-2 times more often.

allenbaron commented 11 months ago

Just noticed 3 diseases that might be redundant and in need of deprecation:

  1. 'benign neurilemmoma' (DOID:955)
    • Child of neurilemmoma which is already defined as benign with no text or logical definition.
    • Has 1 xref to UMLS 'benign schwannoma' which is linked only to MTH/MDR; this is probably also a duplicate in UMLS and needs to be merged. We can drop this xref completely since the xref on neurilemmoma is correct and relevant.
    • --> DEPRECATE with replace by pointing to DOID:3192.
  2. 'benign mediastinal neurilemmoma' (DOID:7922)
    • Child of 'benign neurilemmoma' that is equivalent to 'mediastinal neurilemmoma'
    • Has 1 xref to NCI retired concept that was replaced by the NCI xref on 'mediastinal neurilemmoma'; I guess it was a duplicate at NCI.
    • --> DEPRECATE with replace by pointing to DOID:6175.
  3. 'benign mediastinal psammomatous neurilemmoma' (DOID:7921)
    • Child of 'benign mediastinal neurilemmoma' but with no apparent equivalent in the DO.
    • NCI xref 'Mediastinal Psammomatous Schwannoma' is still active and a child of 'mediastinal neurilemmoma'.
    • This disease is highly specific, with both a location and a specific defining feature (psammoma bodies, according to NCI). However, I could not find this disease name anywhere in PubMed or EuropePMC, which makes me doubt that it is an actual disease. Maybe this was created from some automated update?
    • For the time being I will add the definition from NCI and reclassify this under 'mediastinal neurilemmoma' but it should probably be deprecated.
allenbaron commented 11 months ago

mediastinal neurilemmomas are common enough to remain in the DO... still not sure about DOID:7921.

Also still need to review and move 'mediastinal granular cell myoblastoma' (DOID:5046) which is currently an asserted child of 'mediastinal neurilemmoma'.