vocalpocal
commented
6 years ago CM
Right now too weak because of her long cooldowns and slow to hit effects.
If she missed one of her slows, her other skills hardly even matter because missed skills don't charge her basic attack and the enemy has to be slowed first before it can be stunned. This makes it so that even in skilled hands she can do almost nothing to heroes with spell evades such as Ember and Antimage.
I believe her pub-winrate would benefit quite a lot if her W channel time was just reduced. It is hardly ever a smart choice to fully channel it, and new players can't into cancelling.
Her Dash could even be global ranged because it is just so slow, and because it can be used offensively only on melee range.
13lackHawk
ghost
Legion commander
2 dash abilities are superfluous. Leaving just Q (and moving it to E) is reasonable. What to replace it with? Her W is a questionable ability. It provides a decent potential for mindgames but could still be improved. It's never used on allies because it's simply not worth it. R provides too little of a bonus and is not super useful and you die after it anyway.
Sniper
R is atrocious. It should be replaced with a channeling jetpack flamethrower ability (which comboes with E), but the issue is the animation.
Brewmaster
There is no reason to NOT use his Q all the time, it could literally be replaced with a passive ability which gives you a charge of beer per 1.8s and almost nothing would change.
Slark
EVERYTHING is wrong. He has no identity. A's damage is the only reason he is relevant, the effect is stupid and offers nothing interesting Q is a bland dumb ability which ruins the flow by putting your basic attack on cooldown W should be replaced by a spell shield which deals 2 damage when triggered E leash is never used, the leash component could literally be removed and nothing would change R is a dumb ability which offers nothing other than a mean of survival
Sand King
Everything except his E requires a complete rework because they are all worthless
Queen of Pain
Q is anticlimactic and does not offer much counterplay once you've been hit, I would like to replace it with a leash like ability which slows an enemy down and deals damage + silence if the enemy stays in a certain range long enough R is a stupid hit or miss snowball ability, total replacement
Lycan
His innate ability is not clearly defined and could be improved R bonuses are mostly boring and most are underutilized, could be improved
Undying
Every ability is just totally wrong Q can never fulfill its potential against good players or in a big fight. It could offer a temporary shield, but the growth should be permanent. The cooldown should be bigger. Maybe it shouldn't be an instant ability but rather an ability with a delay akin CM Q. W is a boring damage filler with a neat visual effect E never goes off and acts as a damage sponge, I bet nobody even knows it can deal damage R makes the gameplay boring, there should be combo potential and alternate abilities and something that makes R form gameplay actually difficult
Ursa
E gives too much snowball potential, it should NOT be a simple dash. It could be a flying dash which pushes the enemy it hits away or a bouncing dash which deals damage to the ground.
Tusk
Both empowered A and Q are basically the same ability The proposed solution is to replace the empowered attack with a ranged snowball attack with a strong knockback, make W point-targeted and allow moving it, while making all attacks inside W empowered. Q could be dota-like ice shards but destructible like WK E, inflicting damage and slow on enemies around upon being destroyed R could be an ability out of #203 or something simpler
Storm Spirit
R is a boring ability and suffers greatly from arena crumbling so much
Tiny
Q is too easily destroyed with holes in the ground and lost E is still fairly underwhelming compared to other abilities R options are not great. An eventual RQ is fine, RW never pays off and RE is just not used, while everyone just spams RA.
Vengeful Spirit
R is too easily destroyed, often making it a damage sponge rather than an actual opponent. Some number tweaks + making her destructible in 2/3 hits could work great.
Earthshaker
Has almost 0 combo potential, the only real combo is EAWAQ, anything else just won't work R mainly acts as a stun, the ground destruction part is fairly useless especially since the last island-related update
Ember Spirit
Burn-related combo effects are boring, he could use something better than just simple damage/stun/slow
Juggernaut
The spin is not a great ability by itself, it could be replaced by a simple movement speed boost with almost no downside
Windranger
W is underused as a projectile redirector E is too spammy
Antimage
Q disabling other abilities is awkward at best Lacks any catch up potential after having his W procced