Doriandarko / maestro

A framework for Claude Opus to intelligently orchestrate subagents.
3.49k stars 569 forks source link

Never End #33

Open Roforum opened 1 month ago

Roforum commented 1 month ago

The discussion between the agents is super funny, it amuses me a lot, especially when it goes into a loop. Then you give them a task and they start discussing something else. I'm using the ollama version and so far I haven't been able to finish anything, I left it to a small task to see when it finishes, 26 hours have passed and it's still going.

I think that in many aspects it is much better than Davin or CrewAI, but it needs to be tickled a little to complete a task.

Then the option for long term memory should be added, which saves everything in the /data folder in the same folder where the python file runs and for each task to create a new subfolder in the /data folder.

Left4haxx commented 1 month ago

Same, one time the agents started speaking spanish. Also used ollama but with phi3. I think this could be addressed if there was a moderator agent. Messages could be logged and store information such as :

mfp20 commented 1 day ago

Same here. I'm asking "create a snake game using HTML, CSS, JS." and 4 times out of 5 they keep talking and cheering each other on how good the design rules are, slowly shifting on more general terms until they start speaking about spacetemporal analysis and ... if I let them go ... I might get the blueprints for a time machine, or teleport, maybe, in the next days ... but I was bored and cut them off after 2 days only. Tried different models (llama3, codelama, qwen2, codewen, deepseek-coder, deepseek-coder-v2, dolphincoder, ...), and tried different prompts, including modifing the ones supplied in the python scripts. No improvements.

The other 1/5 attempts, I got empty files and folders or the files and code output in console in json format; partial success has been adding the UTF8 directive on file opens.

The whole thing looks like the callcenter of a big company: dumb operators wasting your time with politeness and useless procedures until you get a useless advice :)

That said, please keep trying because the thing is bloody sexy!