Initial Thoughts / Feedback / Bugs

maia-fw commented 3 weeks ago

Hey there, here are my initial thoughts after downloading this new module. I made a screen-recording as I thought that would be faster/more efficient and that way you can see me walkthrough this all for the first time and everything I encounter. Found a couple bugs as well.

https://www.loom.com/share/0489297081554065b366ff8558f1e487?sid=a4d8b09d-97c2-4a5e-be9e-cea5f56fdd03

maia-fw commented 3 weeks ago

I'm also a UI/UX designer, so if you need someone to help out with those designs, lemme know :)

maia-fw commented 3 weeks ago

Written version

Feedback + Suggestions

Archetypes could be selected via a drop-down menu for easier selection.
Flaw text box could be longer, similar to the description text box, to accommodate more detailed information.
The "dream" field could also use a larger paragraph-style text box for better usability.
Suggested that the default value for health and hope should be five instead of zero, with both sides pre-filled to avoid confusion.
Consider adding plus and minus buttons (arrows) next to health, hope, or bliss for easier value adjustments.

Bugs

Default value for health and hope starts at zero, which can be confusing for users; needs correction or adjustment.
The editing field for "Notes" did not seem to be working.
Rolls were not working correctly:
- Supposed to roll the number of dice equal to the value set in the stats box, but only rolled one die instead.
- Equipment rolls were not working at all, no dice were rolled.

DrOgres commented 3 weeks ago

dice rolling is fixed

DrOgres commented 3 weeks ago

notes editor size was being set too small by foundry should be fixed now

maia-fw commented 3 weeks ago

dice rolling is fixed

Still only rolling one die
Not rolling at all for equipment or weapons
Still unable to edit notes

https://www.loom.com/share/cbe7129256654e1c920b5da8482f2691?sid=10cc2e3f-bcc5-4567-b538-c80f4ec5c574

maia-fw commented 3 weeks ago

ES 0.4.0 Bugs

https://www.loom.com/share/89d849c72d134694886535a81a5375b4?sid=c4c2eb5c-d2be-40aa-a86b-8225c154740f

[ ] Still only rolling one die
[ ] Not rolling at all for equipment or weapons
[ ] Still unable to edit notes
[ ] Keyboard arrows do not work changing Hope amount

maia-fw commented 3 weeks ago

ES 0.4.0 Bug - Not showing successes - 8 October 2024

Testing out rolling using the dice roller under chat and its not showing any of the successes rolled.

https://www.loom.com/share/c68474b3b71c42cc8770e6f52809c269?sid=c3932d4e-1103-4570-9c1a-7a83b36d5a8c

maia-fw commented 3 weeks ago

ES 0.4.0 Bug - Not showing failures after Pushing - 8 October 2024

https://www.loom.com/share/e90dde95a10d461f89b1e0a16c83a5de?sid=0ec04c3c-5032-4652-a31b-ee460c2ddccf

DrOgres commented 3 weeks ago

ES 0.4.0 Bug - Not showing failures after Pushing - 8 October 2024

https://www.loom.com/share/e90dde95a10d461f89b1e0a16c83a5de?sid=0ec04c3c-5032-4652-a31b-ee460c2ddccf

A future feature will be applying 1's on pushed dice as loss of hope and gear damage automatically. this is planned.

Nyogtha68 commented 2 weeks ago

RE: 0.7.0 Hope adjustment on pushed rolls is being applied, but adjustments to gear dice bonus of items doesn't seem to work.

DrOgres commented 2 weeks ago

RE: 0.7.0 Hope adjustment on pushed rolls is being applied, but adjustments to gear dice bonus of items doesn't seem to work.

If you are rolling from a token (in a scene or the like) and do not have the Link Actor Data checked it wont. this is because of the way items update. i will be updating actors have this set as the default in a future update

can you check this and see if it still doesn't work when this is checked?

Nyogtha68 commented 2 weeks ago

Still the same.

From: David @.> Sent: 13 October 2024 23:49 To: DrOgres/electric-state @.> Cc: Nyogtha68 @.>; Comment @.> Subject: Re: [DrOgres/electric-state] Initial Thoughts / Feedback / Bugs (Issue #19)

RE: 0.7.0 Hope adjustment on pushed rolls is being applied, but adjustments to gear dice bonus of items doesn't seem to work.

If you are rolling from a token (in a scene or the like) and do not have the Link Actor Data checked it wont. this is because of the way items update. i will be updating actors have this set as the default in a future update

image.png (view on web)https://github.com/user-attachments/assets/a55e830e-6e90-4ad8-91eb-fe86cc6e2726

can you check this and see if it still doesn't work when this is checked?

— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHubhttps://github.com/DrOgres/electric-state/issues/19#issuecomment-2409249304, or unsubscribehttps://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AVBJBWYRDXTZYLXKQZZTBWLZ3L2GBAVCNFSM6AAAAABPOPII5GVHI2DSMVQWIX3LMV43OSLTON2WKQ3PNVWWK3TUHMZDIMBZGI2DSMZQGQ. You are receiving this because you commented.

DrOgres commented 2 weeks ago

oh Weapons! no those aren't in yet, it's a different bit of code. Just Gear items are in at this point

Nyogtha68 commented 2 weeks ago

Ohh, sorry will test again. Thanks though. And thank you for the making the mod. Going on your previous work,I take it this is going to be an official release when finished?

Nyogtha68 commented 2 weeks ago

Yep works. 👍

DrOgres commented 2 weeks ago

weapons will be in the next update just testing it now

as of right now there is no contract with Free League, so I don't know they have plans for an official release (i think there may be some contractual issues on this but am not sure.)

Angrymog commented 1 week ago

Noticed this after the recent update.

If, as the GM, you have two or more player character sheets open, you have to close them in exactly the same order that you opened them in, or the following fields : Dream, Flaw, Goal, and Threat are overwritten with the values from the first sheet that you opened.

Note that the sheets aren't assigned to players because I'm using this as a solo game.

DrOgres commented 1 week ago

Noticed this after the recent update.

If, as the GM, you have two or more player character sheets open, you have to close them in exactly the same order that you opened them in, or the following fields : Dream, Flaw, Goal, and Threat are overwritten with the values from the first sheet that you opened.

Note that the sheets aren't assigned to players because I'm using this as a solo game.

fixed in v0.15.0

Nyogtha68 commented 1 week ago

Death Roll button reports can't be used if health is above zero, but when zero it doesn't do anything.

DrOgres commented 1 week ago

Death Roll button reports can't be used if health is above zero, but when zero it doesn't do anything.

fixed in 0.16.0

Angrymog commented 5 days ago

When using the Neurocaster, only Finding information has the adds correctly calculated. The other actions use the 'Real World Penalty' value in place of the stat.

When doing a Stat roll with the NC equipped, the RL penalty isn't applied automatically. (I don't know if you plan for it to do so, so this might be working as intended)

DrOgres commented 5 days ago

When doing a Stat roll with the NC equipped, the RL penalty isn't applied automatically. (I don't know if you plan for it to do so, so this might be working as intended)

this will be in an upcoming release

DrOgres commented 5 days ago

When using the Neurocaster, only Finding information has the adds correctly calculated. The other actions use the 'Real World Penalty' value in place of the stat.

fixed in 0.17.0

Nyogtha68 commented 4 days ago

Names dissapear from Tensions when edited by player and drop down menu not functioning.

DrOgres commented 4 days ago

Names dissapear from Tensions when edited by player and drop down menu not functioning.

the player must have Limited permissions to the characters they can use for tension, this is necessary to prevent them from seeing a list of all actors including NPC,s Robots and the like.

can you change permissions for me and verify that this fixes the issue?

Nyogtha68 commented 4 days ago

That seems to fix it, will keep an eye on it. Although, if the player opens another player's character sheet it won't let them close it again, saying they lack permission to do so.

Nyogtha68 commented 2 hours ago

Hull vehicle bonus applied to Armour instead of Hull.

DrOgres commented 1 hour ago

Hull vehicle bonus applied to Armour instead of Hull.

fixed in 0.20.0

DrOgres / electric-state