[Long list] Bugs / Small suggestions

Kimod commented 8 years ago

First of all, I really love your app, like, really ^^ So after using it for a while I noticed a few things that bothered me, so I figured I would write them here, so they could get solved.

Bugs

Shows show average MAL rating only after I clicked on them - http://puu.sh/q7pid.png
- ✔️ Scores are cached and will populated if the value is known. Api limitation of sorts.
When there is back button on top, and I make search bar available, like if I'm on someone's profile and search something, the search bar covers the back button http://puu.sh/q7pAm.png
- ✔️ Fixed
Top anime can't load more than 250 shows
- ✅ Works as intended, explanation below
Gender, Time I Joined and Location in profile shows information from different things - http://puu.sh/q7rgB.jpg
- ✔️ Fixed
When I click on the author of the Article, it opens his profile in browser
- ✔️ Fixed
When I browse the "Top Anime" page and click at show I don't have in my list and look at the amount of episodes it shows a "?"
- ✔️ Fixed
Show title is in rare cases overlaping the number of the show on the list - http://puu.sh/q7uVT.jpg
- ✔️ Fixed, gave some love to those detailed grid items.
If I click "Anime Search" more than one time and then go to the "Anime list", search bar remains open
- ✔️ Fixed
When I have selected one show and press "Select one at random", it does show random show on the right but it doesn't select it in the list
- ✔️ Fixed, I did try to make it allow to use arrows to naviagte accross items but there's something with stock control and it will accept arrow movements after a few presses.
Anime Search is different than that on the website, it shows the shows differently, http://puu.sh/q7wPo.jpg the app didn't even list on the list Space Dandy, which on MAL is first
- ✅ This is what I get from MAL's API response nothing I can do here.
In Settings, when you click on drop down list, it makes the whole list move to the right http://puu.sh/q7xxi.png
- ❓ Umm, you mean that it hides originating combo box?

Mobile only bugs

There isn't "All" category in "Anime list", when I click to the right of the hamburger menu
- ✔️ Fixed
When I click on magnifier in "Anime list" i can't immediately type, while on deskop I can
- ✔️ Fixed
When you are viewing show details, then in the "General" tab when you grab and drag it diagonaly on shows details, like the amount of episodes or type of the show, you can drag it, I recomend looking at the picture http://puu.sh/q7sgO.jpg , it's hard to describe it, this also happens in the "Details" with Genres and Episodes, also in Recommendations details
- ✔️ Fixed

Suggestions

In reviews when I right click the review (or long hold it, or click on name, whatever), I could view profile of the writer
When I right click/long hold on Image in Article in "Articles", I would like an option to save it
- Pretty hard and there are more urging matters, maybe someday... ^^
Add a way to load more reviews
- ✔️ Upped the default number of pulled ones.
Add the show popularity and ranked number to anime details
- 💭 Data is scarce here but I'll try...
Add the episode length, so I would know how long the film is or how short the shorts are
- 💭 Same as above
A way to copy shows title, like I would like to make the title of the show selectable http://puu.sh/q7tOl.jpg
- ✔️ Done.
A way to don't show "Manga list", "Manga search" and "Top Manga" in hamburger menu (maybe pointless, but I would use it ^^)
- ✔️ Added.
Add the show "airing day in the week" / "number of the show on list" to the list view, it is already in detailed grid view
- ✔️ Added.
Add all seasons to the "Seasonal Anime" section, all are on the website
In list view on desktop when I have selected one show and press the down / up arrow, it moves but to make sure the viewer on right gets updated I have to press Enter, I would like to do it without pressing Enter
Add a way to view someones profile (now we can only view his list and even now I don't like that "List Source" button, I think it would be better in hamburger menu, but thats just my opinion ^^)
- Moved this button deeper (in the "more" section of bottom app bar)
Add producer of the anime to the details of the anime
- 💭 Again... missing data. I'll probably take this from html(duh) and redo details page in details page ^^

I hope that at least some of those bug fixes / suggestions will get implemented, so I could enjoy your app even more ^^ and also I hope, that some of those pictures helped to describe, what I meant

Drutol commented 8 years ago

Wow, good job listing those! Some of these are just api limitations, there is no specific data on certain page etc... It's hard to get the data :) I'll elaborate a bit more when I get to my computer. Thanks a lot!

Drutol commented 8 years ago

Bugs have been fixed, I'll look at suggestions tomorrow :)

I'll try to upload today new preview builds with these changes.

Kimod commented 8 years ago

Here is the bug in settings regarding drop down lists more explained, I hope you will understand now, because I don't know, how to make it clearer... http://puu.sh/q8jH1.png
Thank you for your fast responce and resolving that many bugs. shame that APIs are sometimes messy :(

Drutol commented 8 years ago

Ooh I get it now... It's stock behavior of combo box control and I didn't find any options to customize it. Changing it may prove more problematic than its worth ^^

Kimod commented 8 years ago

When I right click/long hold on Image in Article in "Articles", I would like an option to save it :question: How would you like to save it?

Well, on deskop, you can already save the image of the anime cover art, it opens save dialog and you can save it, so on deskop you can open save dialog and save it where you want it On mobile, you can't even save the anime cover art, so that's something, you forgot to add? Because for example in readit, when you click on "Save image as", then it opens file manager in the app. Also in readit, there is an option to "Save image" which saves the image to special folder in Images folder, so this is what i meant. Also for gifs, in readit, there is an option to "save gif as video", but I don't know why it does it this way, isn't .gif good enough?

Drutol commented 8 years ago

Hmm, it may be impossible. When rendering html (article in this case) special control is used which behaves like web browser and I have very limited options of its customisation (I even cannot change the look of scrollbar). You cannot save images in readdit when actual website is loaded unless it detects that link leads to single image and renders it in different way.

I could create list of all images in an article and allow to download them but I feel like there are more urging matters :)

Kimod commented 8 years ago

Big mobile bug

When viewing the list in Detailed Grid mode, it will only list two shows for me, in Grid mode it will all eventualy load, but if you reach the bottom while it's loading, it will never load more. List view loads fine.
- ✔️ I did try quite a few scaling options and it worked fine... I played with code and added a few more checks so it shouldn't occur now.

Bugs

When you click on "Select one at random" it's still a little buggy with selecting the items in the list for me (sometimes stops working and I have to click on the list again to fix it), but you probably noticed this when you tried to fix that "bug" what i had with it (it was more like suggestion tho…), if it works fine for you, try reopening the app and doing it again, I can't 100% reproduce this
- Hah, I'd tried this in various configurations and it worked well... I'll investigate ...
- Oh, it just tries to select show, that isn't loaded, that's why it didn't work after restarting app, so it's similar issue to that I have bellow with the scroll bar and incrementally loading items...
- ✔️ Fixed but added switch for this in settings (disabled by default) because it may consume quite a bit of resources resulting is short "lag".
When you fresh open the app, the scroll bar isn't at the edge of the window, you can only get it after you click on one show from your list - http://puu.sh/q9LVT.gif
- ✔️ Fixed
No "&" in Panty & Stocking with Garterbelt in the title on that right viewer - http://puu.sh/q9Msk.png'
- Mal can return unparsable xml and I have to remove some characters like "&" as they may confuse xml parser. I could probably check its "parsability" first though or improve filter because last time I touched it was like in January ^^... or I'll just take this from anime item... anyway ✔️ Fixed...
When you are viewing someone's anime list, it shows my favorites, not theirs (maybe this is intentional, because you said, that pulling favorites is difficult?)
- ✅ I could block those buttons and I even did but it felt pointless so I left option to make these your favourites without much of a hustle.
You probably know about this and you don't see a simple solution, but I will list it anyway. At the start, the scrollbar is big, but when you grab it and move down, it starts shrinking, so if you grabbed it low enough, you won't reach the bottom in single drag - http://puu.sh/q9NiJ.gif (this is also a problem, when you just use scroll wheel, it's a little choppy when you haven't loaded all of the shows in that list)
- ✅ This is intentional, items are incrementally loaded so the overall performance is better. It's litrally the core of this app and I don't see myself changing this now :)
When you change "My Start" or "My End" on anime and then reopen app, it still updates on the site, but the app has cached the old date, so it will show My Start and My End unchanged (so only visual bug that fixes itself, when the cashed data expires)
- ✔️ Fixed... True, cached data isn't updated
The "Select one on random" button will never select last show on the list, also it can select the same show that was already selected
- ✔️ Fixed...Randomizer just got some brainz...
Sorting in top anime doesn't work, it will always show them in the order they go in that category (I think that you could even delete sorting in top anime, why would anyone use it? Also it will be easier to just delete it than fix it :D)
- ✔️ Believe me or not but I had logic and just forgot to hook it up to this button...
All dialogs are in white theme, f.e move the show from watching to completed, or disclaimer in messages
- ✅ They are stock ones with pretty limited customization... I will probably make my own some day. There is going to be theme setting in widnows Anniversary update so maybe this will change something.
gif - http://puu.sh/qhgco.gif , 2 things that I think are a bug. 1. when I search for 'ore' it doesn't show all the shows that have 'ore' in them, then if I type 'oree' and then I delete one e, so it's 'ore' again, it will now show all shows, that have 'ore' in them. 2. when I search for something, it has to be more than 1 letter (that is maybe intentional?). Anyway, if I search for it, it doesn't respect 'Watching' or 'Completed' and all the other categories, it shows them like I have selected 'All'. If this is intentional, maybe have "All" selected by default when searching and when you finish searching revert to category that you had selected earlier? And a little suggestion, when I search for something, could the list wait like half a second before it shows me the results, because I thing that refreshing the list after every letter I type is unnecessary and laggy
- ✔️ Fixed added tuned adjusted
- Classic off by one error with going forward/backward and misssing items :) There will be now delay of 500ms before search query is submitted + check whether it's the same if so search method begin its work. 2 letter requirement is intentional.
- I was going to say that searching in current category will be a bit hard but to my surprise framework just worked... yay! I guess. Anyway, when searching it will switch to "All" by default but it will take into consideration other filters as you suggested.
When you click on the check mark next to "list source" multible times, it will show duplicates in the list - http://puu.sh/qhgOx.gif
- ✔️ You could do this with refresh button too!
When you are in "Anime List", then you click on "Settings & More" and then you click on X so you close "Settings & More", magnifier will disappear, because "Settings & More" is still selected in hamburger menu. When you click on "Anime List" magnifier will appear once again
- ✔️ Fixed
In reviews, when the author of the review didn't add detailed scores for story, animation etc. the "Sound" rating won't show at all http://puu.sh/qhmFh.png
- ✅ I'm taking data straight from here: What anime is it/is it present on website? There may be some different pattern that I'm not aware of.
- oh, I just looked at MAL and when the review doesn't have detailed score for sound, it doesn't show that category at all, so a bug on MAL side, my bad... (Also I saw you added Panty & Stocking to PTW, I recommend english dub, it's so much better... :D https://youtu.be/ojiOyoyUYC4 )
- I added this for testing purposes but I might watch it now as well!

Suggestions

In profile, if you don't have any favorite manga or people (or other things), wouldn't it be better, if it wouldn't show the whole thing? Because this looks really dumb: http://puu.sh/q9PFN.jpg
- ✔️ Applied
On mobile, when you click on a show, it should show the title of the show instead of the category, on left current, on right suggestion - http://puu.sh/qhhrq.png
- ✔️ FIXED

So the next two will probably take you a long time, so you can put them on-hold, just the idea that you will consider and maybe add them in the future will make me happy. (Currently I'm really glad you inplemented characters in show details ^^)

So I still use the website for two things that your app can't do, so if you would implement those two things, you would make me really happy, but you would probably have to pull some things from html

So every Saturday on midnight I go to this list (http://myanimelist.net/history/Kimod/anime) to see, what and how much I actualy saw in the last 7 days, you could probably pull that data from website or somehow store what changed and when it changed in app, but it will probably be easier to pull this data from html, you could even make a notificaton like: "See what you watched in the last week"
- ✔️ Added
And the second thing is comparing lists, if you don't know what am I talking about (but you probably do), it's this: http://myanimelist.net/shared.php?u1=Drutol&u2=Kimod&type=anime I think you could come up with something that could work… Alternative and more simple solution would be to show your score when you are viewing their list (in that place, where + and - is, because you can never change their amount of watched episodes)
- This is going to be pretty hard, forums are first in queue :)

Drutol commented 8 years ago

Is this big mobile bug still a thing? I believe I addressed it in last update... + it works on my machine ;d

I'm taking break from forums btw :D

Kimod commented 8 years ago

That mobile bug is still present on my device, according to my research, it has to do with scaling of the display, it will load on 150%, so it works on that scaling, but when I have the display in 200% scailing, it won't work...

Drutol commented 8 years ago

了解

Drutol commented 8 years ago

I was planning to send you new build today but I'm too tired to package everything now... Expect them tommorow :)

Drutol commented 8 years ago

Okay, now I'm going to look into history

Drutol commented 8 years ago

In the meantime...

Here are promised builds with stuff fixed as indicated in your last list :)

x64: https://1drv.ms/u/s!Am1xQK-HVf_IkdJe2T917pFMChEhnQ

ARM: https://1drv.ms/u/s!Am1xQK-HVf_IkdJf3uMnxmR-5yTxBg

Kimod commented 8 years ago

Daily dose of new bugs ^^

"Big mobile bug"

So now when I view the list in Detailed Grid mode, it will now list exactly 10 shows instead of 2 shows, so progress? :D And also there is an issue in Grid mode. When I move too fast down, the shows stop loading. Here are both bugs shown - http://puu.sh/qj6bh.gif
- ✔️ Okay found the issue... it will work now. I don't know though how did you manage to scroll fast enough to defy incremental loading.

Bugs

(Mobile) You didn't make the title selectable http://puu.sh/qhhrq.png
- ✔️ Fixed
The scrollbar is correctly placed at the start, but when you select a show and then you click on X, the scrollbar dissapears http://puu.sh/qj6HS.gif
- ✔️ Fixed (again...)
You can select "Setings -
" - http://puu.sh/qj6Nh.png
- ✔️ Fixed
There isn't scrollbar in "General" and "About" settings and the Up and Down arrows switch the Color theme instead of scrolling in General settings
- ✔️ Fixed.
When I try to select show really fast after the last one, or on some rare ocations, the Image and Synopsis won't get updated. In this gif it will happen 2 times, first is nearly at the start and the second is like 1 minute in… - http://puu.sh/qj7Y5.gif
- ✅ Wow... Kizumonogatari was good wasn't it? This is fixable but it creates a bit more code intricacy... eh... I did fix different yet related bug with opening details from related anime (introduced in 4.4.7.0).
You could maybe add a little logic to figure out, where to place those boxes, instead of making it 2x2. http://puu.sh/qj8hR.png Only in Favs, I get that you want to have favs and Recent updates separated. While we are talking about this, couldn't you move Recent Updates above Favs? Maybe this is only me, but I will more often check Recent updates than Favorities on friends profile
- Okay... Don't ask me how, why nor how long will this work, it just works... I did try to make this work like this when first designing profile page but I had no idea how to achieve this effect... now I'm consuming your whole processor to arrange these grids nicely ^^ It isn't the best possible outcome but arranging items which contain more controls which arrange more items isn't easy ;d
When the dialog for setting the Status from Watching to Completed appears, the Status on that right viewer won't update (but when you manualy change the number to match the amount of episodes, it works as intended, so it is bugged only if you use the '+' button) - http://puu.sh/qj8Wc.gif

Drutol commented 8 years ago

About history... what do you think about this organisation? Each section (today, last week etc.) will have grouped anime/manga and in these groups all relevant updates will be displayed.

(Just displayed raw processed data)

Kimod commented 8 years ago

If you saw the comment before editing, sorry I was blind, nevermind... :D Looks pretty solid ^^

Maybe a little question, when the whole week isn't finished, the days in that week will show up below each other on the left? Won't that make that column too long? Or you will make "This week" and show them similarly like "Last week"?

Drutol commented 8 years ago

Let me do the layout and I'll post ss once I'm done :)

Drutol commented 8 years ago

Something like this? There will be some empty space and I don't really know what to do about it :(

Kimod commented 8 years ago

Looks good, really good ^^ any word on viewing somebody else's History? Also on the website you can delete each entry. Could you implement something like that?

And the scollbar isn't at the edge in the first pic :D

Drutol commented 8 years ago

Okay, this the build with fixes from your last list + history + profile comments.

I don't know how bugged this is but you seem to have natural talent for finding bugs/issues. And I've little time to check this now thoroughly. I want to upload this version feature wise to the store tommorow ^^

x64 https://1drv.ms/u/s!Am1xQK-HVf_IkdMGLdSF12rZOZAODw

Drutol commented 8 years ago

Uhuh I see crashes ;d

Kimod commented 8 years ago

Oh I will post this commend now when you are here and maybe edit it later if I find something :)

The only problem with this build is that when I view somebody's history from profile, it crashes (but not always). First it crashed even for my history list, when I viewed from my profile and not through hamburger directly. http://puu.sh/qkBPs.gif
- ✔️ Fixed +/-

Love the history though, better than I imagined ^^

If you have time for a few issues that I recently discovered

In recommendations, the details for the show on the right are on the right too much, so if you have that right viewer opened, it covers your's details - http://puu.sh/qkCbb.png (the recommendation is also worth reading... :D)
- ✔️ Fixed
In top anime, when you don't have a show in your list, it doesn't show the show's type, even after I click on it - http://puu.sh/qkCpt.png
- ✅ Umm there's no type of anime in seasonal page and these items are not preserved in any way that includes stuff like this. Works as intended.
When somebody doesn't have a profile picture, it is blank, so maybe add something like on MAL?
- ✔️ There'll be big white question mark :)
Bug/Feature - I found a way to load more than 250 shows in Top Anime, when you load all 250, then go to PTW, and then switch back to All and then you have the button to load more there and it works :D http://puu.sh/qkDlG.gif
- I believe I did write something on this matter before... it will work but I don't really want more than 250 ;d
- Well I thought that you should prevent it from appearing, not make that button available, I know that you don't want more than 250 ;)
- Let's call it easter egg, shall we?
When you have empty list and click on Select one at random, it will crash - http://puu.sh/qkFL6.gif
- ✔️ Fixed

It is harder and harder to fing bugs/issues :D

Drutol commented 8 years ago

How many times did this app crash on most recent build?

Kimod commented 8 years ago

Only sometimes when I opened History, elsewhere it didn't crash at all, well I have one bug regarding empty list and clicking on Select one at random, but I believe that it was there before

Drutol commented 8 years ago

So it didn't crash ... ... 29 times?

Kimod commented 8 years ago

Well, it is possible... :D I tried to find reliable way to make it crash, but didn't find any

Drutol commented 8 years ago

Okay, I was hoping that crash analytics on windows store were more accurate xd

Drutol commented 8 years ago

I'll upload next build in a few minutes and I'm off to preparing mobile views.

Drutol commented 8 years ago

Okay, play with this and I'm going to start working on mobile...

x64 4.4.11.0 https://1drv.ms/u/s!Am1xQK-HVf_IkdZiIIjbT12-cSQ3gw

Kimod commented 8 years ago

ok, it doesn't crash now, which is always good, right?

Sometimes history doesn't load and also you have a little typo - "epmpty" - http://puu.sh/qkMu8.gif
- ✅ I did fix the typo but the reson behind missing history is still unknown...
The back arrow stays there when I go from history to my "Anime List". And when I view my history through my profile, the back arrow is there, but when i view my history through that icon in hamburger menu, the back arrow isn't there - http://puu.sh/qkMCi.gif
- ✔️ I rewrote whole navigation mechanism on mobile and adjusted dektop one... feel free to stress test it :)
When you are viewing somebody else's history list, the shows don't update their amount of watched episodes. You have to go to their list to update those shows - http://i.imgur.com/5hRTGqR.png
- ✅ That's because they are cached for some time, I don't feel like pulling whole library, parsing it and creating models in order to display a few more episodes.

Drutol commented 8 years ago

First mobile build with new stuff: (I'd like to treat these like RC's without changelog but we all know how this will turn out...)

ARM v4.4.14.0 https://1drv.ms/u/s!Am1xQK-HVf_IkdZjnvZfo5-3ZfuZ2w

x64 v4.4.13.0 https://1drv.ms/u/s!Am1xQK-HVf_IkdZkScENmvUmNZHslQ

Kimod commented 8 years ago

First I tested mobile

Here is how I see the history tab, http://i.imgur.com/527x2gs.png the first two are how I see it, unfortunaly, it is too big, when I see it in my small scalling. The one below is a little concept, that proves, it can fit, if the borders aren't that big
And can confirm that Detailed Grid and Grid mode now work flawlessly ^^

But anything besides that mobile bug regarding history on small scaling are pointless things so you shouldn't worry about making this version public (at least for desktop, if you want to fix that mobile history bug is up to you... ^^)

Drutol commented 8 years ago

Fixed this mobile history:

03.08.2016 -  v4.4.16.0 & v4.4.15.0

Added profile comments.
Added profile history.
Improved organisation of profile page.
Gave some love to light theme.
Search will be now more accurate and there will be delay after typing in query.
Resolved issues with being unable to load more items on mobile.
Selecting at random will be now smarter.
Fixed visual bug with start/end dates.
Fixed bug where refresh button could create duplicates.
Status bar will now correctly show show titles and other headers.
You can now select and copy text from header in anime details.
Navigation mechanisms have been rewritten.
Profile page will no longer show empty favourites.
Resolved with adaptation issues in recommendations page.

Kimod commented 8 years ago

Found some bugs and also bugs from earlier lists (I did this because I wanted them to be in one place ^^)

There is pin my profile, it appears if you reproduce the same things in my gif - http://puu.sh/qmYRS.gif (My profile, click on friend's profile, click on my profile (in my friends friends), refresh - pin button there!)
Scrollbars in my "Anime List" in Compact list and Detailed Grid mode, in profile and in history aren't on the edge after fresh open, if you click on a show, then they are moved to the edge, seems like every other scrollbar in the app is moved a little too (for example the scrollbar in Grid mode is moved just a little too and also to be clear, I'm not telling you that the scrollbar in Grid mode should be at the edge)
Details under Recommendations weren't fixed completly - http://puu.sh/qmZgy.gif (If you had one show selected before you went to the recommendations, the data in details would never go under the each other)
- :heavy_check_mark: Fixed
I can't disable "Enable swipe to increment/decrement on grid items" - http://puu.sh/qmZMO.png
- :heavy_check_mark: Fixed
When I click in my profile on History (not in hamburger menu, in my profile), it also creates that back arrow (but if I click on Anime List/Manga list in my profile, it doesn't create one, so inconsistency? Sorry if lately I'm just pointing out pointless stuff ^^)
- :white_flower: The idea here is that you navigate there directly so there's no back navigation stack really. When you are browsing profiles you want to be able to go back.
When you were making white theme prettier, you missed this - http://i.imgur.com/E1hMNf0.png (You should probably make the star white, so it matches the white text on gray background ^^)
Settings in windows 10 and other UWP applications show category when you click on them when you are in that category, your app still shows Settings - (version) - http://puu.sh/qkEeu.png
- 💮 I'm to lazy to make switch for all those pages right now... nanana
In Anime Search 2 things: 1. Only every other item is visualy selected. 2. When I clicked on something from the list and then close that right viewer, I can't open that thing that I selected earlier http://puu.sh/qn7bp.gif
- :heavy_check_mark: :heavy_check_mark: Fixed
URL in anime/manga details - http://puu.sh/qncWR.png
- :white_flower: I'll want to parse this like readit one day but not today ^^
In Top Anime with extended flyout - When I click on Top Anime, it should select "General" in that flyout. When I select for example Favourities and then click on Top Anime, it should then select "General" as well - http://puu.sh/qndft.gif (the flyout works perfectly in "Anime List")
- :heavy_check_mark: Fixed
If I click on show in history, it does select the whole box, but if I click only on the box, it doesn't select the whole box - http://puu.sh/qq1EP.gif
- :white_flower: That's quite a find... I had to hack this thing so that scroll viewer with episodes doesn't consume mouse click... and getting this selection border would be trouble some to say the least.
In my profile, if I click on a show, then close that right viewer and then click on that show again, it doesn't open that right viewer again - http://puu.sh/qq2zW.gif
- :heavy_check_mark: Fixed
In history, manga also has "Episode" like anime, when it should be "Chapter" - http://puu.sh/qq3MO.jpg
- :heavy_check_mark: Fixed
When manga has 0 chapters/volumes read, it shows "? Episodes" instead of "? Read" - http://puu.sh/qq3Ws.png
- :heavy_check_mark: It'll now display either ? Chapters/Volumes
When you have Settings opened and you click on a show that you had previously selected, it doesn't close the settings and open the show details - http://puu.sh/qq4zk.gif
- :heavy_check_mark: There are some quirks with back now but w/e.
When you are in someone's manga list and then click on "Anime List" in hamburger menu, it doesn't close that back button - http://puu.sh/qq4qt.gif
- :heavy_check_mark: Fixed
When you are in history, if you click on anime show and then on manga, it shows Name - Watching 100% consistently for me - http://puu.sh/qq5gs.gif (Nisekoi is over? wow...)
- :white_flower: What is this sorcery? Yup, it's over, done, 終わり my ship has sunk tbh :(
The dialogs are still white when I'm on black theme, even if I have the whole system in black - http://puu.sh/qq5wO.png , looks like you will have to create your own dialogs, AU did nothing to this sadly...
- :eyeglasses: I'll burn your eyes muahaha.
- だめだよ :/
When I start the app in smaller resolution and then go fullscreen, the panel with "Watching", "Completed", "On hold" etc. is cut out - http://puu.sh/qr4Dw.gif
- :heavy_check_mark: It will scroll like pivot now too.
I have 2 monitors of different sizes, when I have maximalized the app on my second larger screen, then I move the app to my primary smaller screen, maximize it and then move it back and maximaze it, then Favorite Anime will be higher than favorite characters... Weird right? Really wide gif - http://puu.sh/qr6aX.gif
- :heavy_check_mark: I did adjust the height but I have no clue whether this will solve your issue ;d
Could you please instead of 0/10 show N/A (or Unranked) in recommendations? - http://puu.sh/qrfZL.jpg
- :heavy_check_mark: Fixed
When you right click on a grid item and have that show ranked, you have that score selected, but when you have that show unranked, "Unranked" won't be highlighted - http://puu.sh/qrg9Y.png
- :heavy_check_mark: Fixed
When you are in that right viewer and click multiple times on refresh button while you are in details, reviews or recoms, it will load multiple times (Also, isn't details tab broken? It loads on like 1/10 of shows for me)
- :heavy_check_mark: Fixed. As for details I'll have to scrap this from html (or wait for hummingbird V3) one day because external apis seem to work poorly.
That anime viewer on right shouldn't have back button when you first open show details (you had to have one show shown and then close it) (Steps: Click on one show, close the right viewer and then click on another show, now that another show has back button that leads to the first show) Experiment with this some more, like clicking on more shows before closing the viewer and then the back button. Gif that shows something I just described - http://puu.sh/qn0SA.gif
- :heavy_check_mark: Fixed
Bigger thing - Could you add to the settings select a timezone? You could use it in history - http://puu.sh/qkERZ.jpg (on MAL I have correct timezone) and in airing days in list, because when I move it by 1 in settings, it is too much (for example I watch Re:zero on Sunday (Broadcast: Mondays at 01:05 (JST)) and Shokugeki no Souma: Ni no Sara on Saturday (Broadcast: Saturdays at 22:00 (JST)) (they are 1day, 3hours and 5 minutes appart. In Japan they are between 2 days while for example in my timezone they are between 1 day). This is maybe bigger thing but it would add something that would make your app better than the website
- Let's talk about sliders maybe...? I'll have to think about it because it's not trivial matter.
- Yea slider with -12 hours to +12 hours should be good, I understand that you will have to think more about this one...

Some mobile only bugs

When you are in subcategory in settings, when you press back button, it closes the settings completly. When it should go to the main menu of settings
- :heavy_check_mark: Fixed
I believe that my Start page watching/reading should also be the last page before the app closes when I click on back button. But if I'm in "Seasonal Anime", "Top anime" or "Messages", and click on back button, it closes the app. Also when I'm in completed, on-hold, dropped, PTW or all, when I click on the back arrow, it should go back to watching/reading and then close the app
- :heavy_check_mark: Fixed but filters won't affect navigation stack.
This http://puu.sh/q7sgO.jpg (<-- this one was fixed) happens in other places: http://puu.sh/qnc48.png
- :heavy_check_mark: Fixed, history will have this thing though.
Settings inconsistency between desktop and mobile - http://puu.sh/qn0ca.png (Desktop - Start page -> Color theme, Mobile - Color theme -> Start page
- :heavy_check_mark: Fixed
Profile without picture doesn't have "?" - http://puu.sh/qn0iA.jpg
- :heavy_check_mark: Fixed
There isn't "goto profile" on mobile
- :heavy_check_mark: Fixed
Maybe you should add an option to "Enable swipe to increment/decrement on grid items" to mobile, because I accidantly like twice now incremented the amount of watched eps in History, or maybe add a setting to disable this swiping to increment/decrement only in history, doesn't mater to me, I only use detailed grid on mobile
- :heavy_check_mark: Whoopsies daisies... forgot to disable it there.
History tab almost there… - http://puu.sh/qn1Eo.jpg
- :heavy_check_mark: Stuff has been tweaked.

Love the flowers, because thanks to them is my list fabulous ^^

Drutol commented 8 years ago

I'll resolve these over the weekend as I'm working on demo version of my internship app right now. Additionally I'm planning to either add character details or forums in "beta" version. And those dreaded ads will appear next week...

Drutol commented 8 years ago

Once more... screw ads.

Fixed some things, some of them I don't even want to touch and some are left for tommorow :) Because of new AU emojis we are switching white empty checkmark to :white_flower: because why not :D

Kimod commented 8 years ago

It's that time again! More bugs, Yeeey ^^

Wasn't fixed for me - When manga has 0 chapters/volumes read, it shows "? Episodes" instead of "? Read" -http://puu.sh/qq3Ws.png
- :heavy_check_mark: Should be fixed now.
When profile doesn't have profile picture, it doesn't show profile details (names to test on: THAT_IS_NOT_OKAY, Ahrichards5241) - http://puu.sh/quizm.png
- :heavy_check_mark: THAT_WAS_NOT_OKAY
When you click on "Profile" in hamburger menu, it should delete that back button on top, because if not - http://puu.sh/quiGT.gif
- :heavy_check_mark: Fixed
Articles and News doesn't have a scrollbar at all
- :white_flower:
- fml... :D
The airing day in "Anime List" disappears if you go to "Top Anime - Airing" - http://puu.sh/qz0UP.gif
- :heavy_check_mark: That was quite the hunt
Capital letters in user names aren't capital, only if you are looking at someone's list/profile - http://puu.sh/qz1wg.gif (Desktop only)
- :question: Soo... your name should be in capital or not?
- So... Checked some of your screenshots from store and it seems like you don't have that issue, which is weird... Anyway, on MAL my nickname is "Kimod" with capital "K", but almost everywhere in your app I have lowercase "k", the only exception is when I view my profile from different place than hamburger menu - http://puu.sh/qCpTo.png also small thing when I enter in "Goto" drutol, your "d" ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°) will be lowercase, but if I type "Drutol" your "D" will be capital, OHH and also I figured out why is this "There is pin my profile, it appears if you reproduce the same things in my gif - http://puu.sh/qmYRS.gif (My profile, click on friend's profile, click on my profile (in my friends friends), refresh - pin button there!)" happening, it's because my name is different, instead of "kimod" I have "Kimod" and I can pin it... - http://puu.sh/qCtUG.png but it seems like I can only pin 2 types, the correct one and then one that is wrong, it won't let me pin another wrong
- :heavy_check_mark: Yeah, probably beacuse when signing in you've typed lowercase letter.
Arrow to top disappears after you click on a show - http://puu.sh/qz2Li.gif
"Last watched" wasn't implemented, or why is it grayed out? - http://puu.sh/qz3vS.png (in general settings)
- :white_flower: This is hummingbird specific and I was/am too lazy to hide this.
That pivot which you implemented for "Watching" "Completed" etc. doesn't have those left/right switching arrows and also the most right item is higher that the others - http://puu.sh/qz42R.gif
- :white_flower: Modifying pivots is pure pain, and don't ask me about this sorcery with right most item :white_flower: :white_flower: :white_flower:
If you have subcategory in settings opened and then click on anime/manga, it does have that back arrow too - http://puu.sh/qz4iV.gif
- :heavy_check_mark: Fixed, literally typo
In profile, clicking on a show multiple times brings back both back arrows - http://puu.sh/qz4zg.gif
- :heavy_check_mark: Fixed
When you select watching on a show, it does select My start, but if I click on "+" and it asks me to switch it to watching, it doesn't select My start - http://puu.sh/qAjtm.gif
- :heavy_check_mark: Fixed
In Synopsis, on some shows instead of dashes are semicolons - http://puu.sh/qz55I.jpg , http://puu.sh/qz5mg.png or some other special characters - http://puu.sh/qz5II.jpg
- :white_flower: Say hello to mal's unparsable xml responses... fixed some of them
When reviews are loading and you click on refresh button, it loads the reviews multiple times - http://puu.sh/qz6sO.gif
- :heavy_check_mark: Literally typo... again
That place in Compact list where +/- are, are taking unnecessary space, when you are viewing somebody else's list - http://puu.sh/qz959.png
- :heavy_check_mark:
Tags on Detailed grid mode are behind the text http://puu.sh/qzK5i.jpg (you could probably move the tag below the star)
- :heavy_check_mark: Fixed but I kinda dislike this detailed view... designing things is pretty damn hard.
The dialog when you right click on selected text is white in dark theme - http://puu.sh/qBv5U.png
- :white_flower: Your are better off to complain to Microsoft about this.
If I click on "anime list" in someone's profile and then go back with that back button, I'm back at their profile, whereas if I click on "manga list" and then go back, I'm back in my profile - http://puu.sh/qzKiX.gif
- :heavy_check_mark: Fixed
When you extended one review and then clicked on different show and go to reviews, it has one review extended - http://puu.sh/qAiJG.gif
Favorites won't load if you spend some time (I reloaded, clicked on history, went back and then again reloaded profile) in a profile without favorites - http://puu.sh/qCsyd.gif (I pointed this out because you said "Profile page will no longer show empty favourites." in your changelog :D)
- :heavy_check_mark: Fixed

Crashes

When Detailed grid doesn't have enough space, it crashes - http://puu.sh/qrJvr.gif
- :tada: You have just found out the reason behind this odd exception, good luck with finding the rest :tada:
Maybe this will help you solve something? I felt like this is just some memory leak, so I didn't bother listing it - When you load too many profiles, it will eventualy crash - http://puu.sh/qCta2.gif (it's a pretty long gif..)

Not really bugs

When you close settings, if you had something selected in hamburger, select it back - http://puu.sh/qAjKu.gif
When that right viewer is at 0 width and click on the same show that was previously selected, it doesn't extend it - http://puu.sh/qz9Fv.gif (maybe when it is at 0 width, just close it? more touch friendly closing)
- :heavy_check_mark: Doned
When you click on History or Messaging, it should select that icon in hamburger menu - http://puu.sh/quiDO.png
A way to modify tags (deleting and re-writing them is too much work... :D)
Some shows have their airing day still after they are done airing - http://puu.sh/quioF.png , you could probably somehow check for "Status" and if it's Airing > show airing day and if it's Finished Airing > don't show it
If I were you, I would focus next (of course after you are done with character details ^^) on "Details" page in details page, because now it's pretty much useless (you could put there the episode length, producer, show popularity and ranked number, which I requested in my first comment ^^. And also you said that you will redo details page in details page earlier :p) and also it's broken (now I don't mean "Data unavailable") for some shows - http://puu.sh/qz7GM.png so I guess just scrap the details page you have now?
- 分かった　I'm plain sick of html scrapping but you are probably right that it should display something... On the bright side there's not much scrapping left :)
- :heavy_check_mark: Done

Mobile only

I can't load somebody else's history, it shows empty every time
If you click in your "Profile" page on "Anime list" and then click back, it goes back to "Anime list", so nothing happens
Clicking back in forums main page closes the app
In anime search, if you clicked on a show, went back and then tried to click on it again, it doesn't go to the show details
If you click on Anime stock photo in anime details the photo is in the middle verticaly, so if you are for example in reviews, it isn't visible right when you click on it, you have to scroll down and the save button is even lower
In settings in Account if you click on back arrow, it closes the app
Grids in history have different widths - http://puu.sh/qBvGE.png

As always, if you didn't get something what I tried to explain here in my poor english, feel free to ask ^^ (that's why I have gif/image for almost everything, you don't have to view them all, they are there to better explain the issue) Also if you were wondering, that thing with different heights on favorite anime and characters in profile when I was switching monitors wasn't fixed, you can skip this, just letting you know ^^

Drutol commented 8 years ago

How is/was railgun/index?

Kimod commented 8 years ago

Ohh, I really enjoyed Index and I think that I'm enjoying Railgun even more, so many best grillz :3 I really like how it's lighthearted and the comedy was done just right 👌👌

Drutol commented 8 years ago

Yup, many best girls ^^. I deem first railgun the weakest of four but still very good nontheless. I'm even going through light novels now and next contestant is making her appearance. Let's hope for index3 :D

Drutol commented 8 years ago

I also feel like this list is becoming too long, how about creating new issue next time?

Kimod commented 8 years ago

You are probably right, I didn't want to spam your issues with my lists ^^ So next time, instead of commenting with the list, I will create new issue.. And a little question: Should I copy previous bugs to new issue, if you didn't fix them and didn't even coment on them. for example that issue with scrollbar not being on the edge?

Drutol commented 8 years ago

Yeah, copy them just in case...

This update will take a while because of the amount of various stuff I'm changing :)

Drutol commented 8 years ago

New build available in #29. Open new issue if you happen to find something (what am I even talking about ^^ )

Drutol / MALClient

[Long list] Bugs / Small suggestions #42