Pam Trees converting to normal Trees (Dynamic without Fruittype) after a while

[cad435]

Some times after placing for example an Apple pip, the tree turns from "Oak, Species Apple" to simply "Oak" with no species (without ever showing an apple at all!).

I had Lychee Trees growing with Jungle Wood, the "Lychee Tree form", suddenly turning into normal Jungletrees and getting super tall normal Jungle trees.

We are running a server with Spongeforge. Other harvest related mods are Agricraft, Pam's and Roots.

Dynamic compats for Pams, Thaumcraft & Roots are loaded in as well.

Full modlist: https://prnt.sc/r7fj8m https://prnt.sc/r7fjo2

Any suggestions what this can cause? My guess is that sponge somehow will interfere, but I'm not sure...

Greetings, cad435

[Hexidecimark]

Same error. I haven't been able to determine the cause. Also running spongeforge, with a modlist here: https://www.curseforge.com/minecraft/modpacks/hexworks/relations/dependencies

We're also running Nucleus and a handful of plugins like Luckperms and Eagle Factions.

The only real way to replicate the glitch is by growing a tree over the course of an average of about an hour, or harvesting all the fruit on the tree. I have no idea what the trigger is, but it never seems to happen before the third growth happens.

OVERLAPPING MODS that I can see: -Antiqueatlas -Bibliocraft -Cooking for blockheads -Dyn Trees + Pam + Compats -Tinkers -JEI -JER -HWYLA -Reauth -Streams -Vanillafix

[ferreusveritas]

I run with -HWYLA -Dyn Trees -Pam's HC -Dyn Trees Pam's HC -JEI -JER

and I'm NOT able to produce the problem so it's not any of those mods.

So it's PROBABLY not Antiqueatles(because It's just a map mod) It's likely not Reauth(because Client side only)

My guess is that it has something to do with spongeforge though I don't know jack about how it could.

[Hexidecimark]

Just finished testing- it doesn't seem to happen in singleplayer, which does support that hypothesis.

[ferreusveritas]

When it does happen is there a rootydirt block under the trunk of the tree or is it just plain minecraft dirt?

[cad435]

It is very likely only an issue with sponge... I don't run this server anymore, but I discussed it with some of my technical stuff and they thought about the grow-tick system of sponge... There are dozens of little optimisations built-in to sponge (Wich makes it so tempting to run on a highly modded server, because performance would be boosted excessively, but also can break a lot of stuff)

Rooty blocks under the trees were present.

[Hexidecimark]

From the Spongeforge discord: If you wanna troubleshoot it, you’d likely need to set up a dev environment with spongeforge and Pam and dynamic trees to hit some breakpoints in both mod block code and sponge block capturing code.

[Hexidecimark]

I do not have the means to do this.

[supermassimo]

@Hexidecimark is this issue still happening with the latest DT and DT-PHC updates?

[Hexidecimark]

I've been too busy to check properly, but the latest DT update alone did not fix it. May not be able to check for quite some time.