search

DynamicTreesTeam / DynamicTrees

Minecraft Forge mod providing dynamic trees that progressively grow from seed to maturity.
MIT License
218 stars 96 forks source link

Support For Additional Mods (1.12.2) #652

Closed supermassimo closed 1 year ago

supermassimo commented 3 years ago

To make it easier for everyone, I will be compiling all mod compat suggestions for 1.12.2 on this post going forward. From now on all 1.12.2 mod support suggestion should go as replies to this post. For 1.16.5 suggestions, please refer to the 1.16.5 suggestion list. Suggestions from the discord server will also be added here.

Please please please include how many trees a mod adds when suggesting

DO NOT suggest the following types of mods as they will not be considered:

  • OTG mods
  • Mods without a public source (such as MCreator mods)

Those in bold were considered and/or are being worked on. When a mod is finished and published, it is removed from this list.

The stars are a rough estimate of how likely it is for me (subjectively, anyone is free to pick any!) to choose that mod. It is based on how popular the mod is, how many trees it has, how unique these are and how interesting I find them. 0 stars just means i do not know enough about the mod, not that i do not like it.

If you continuously suggest mods that are already in the list multiple times, you will be blocked from participating in this discussion.

TheConception commented 3 years ago

As a request:

IC2 Exp has a popular fork called IC2 Classic. Current addon for IC2 Exp can't be used with IC2 Classic as it has its own implementation for rubber tree (you also cant load both IC2 Exp and IC2 Classic at the same time). It's literally the same tree with same mechanics but just with different IDs and stuff. It shouldn't be really hard to make a separate version for the IC2 Classic fork.

DizzyDJW commented 3 years ago

Rubber trees from TechReborn? I do believe they are the only trees in that mod

supermassimo commented 3 years ago

Rubber trees from TechReborn? I do believe they are the only trees in that mod

I have already done Tech Reborn https://www.curseforge.com/minecraft/mc-mods/dynamic-trees-tech-reborn

DizzyDJW commented 3 years ago

Rubber trees from TechReborn? I do believe they are the only trees in that mod

I have already done Tech Reborn https://www.curseforge.com/minecraft/mc-mods/dynamic-trees-tech-reborn

Ah, thank you kindly, it didn't show up in the search under "Dynamic Trees"

disastercube commented 3 years ago

Biome Bundle trees. The mod ads a lot of different new tree ( some bigger or smaller then normal). It be nice for it to be compatible with it and with its tree sizes (meaning new tree models).

supermassimo commented 3 years ago

Biome Bundle trees. The mod ads a lot of different new tree ( some bigger or smaller then normal). It be nice for it to be compatible with it and with its tree sizes (meaning new tree models).

Please read the post before commenting, OTG mods are not supported.

ZotyDev commented 3 years ago

GregTech Community Edition. Only 1 tree, the Rubber Tree, and it has the same structure of small vanilla oak trees.

WenXin20 commented 3 years ago

Pokecube AIO Support It adds several trees that produce berries, trees are only grown when the corresponding berries are planted on farmland.

Nathan22211 commented 3 years ago

is it possible tree tweaker support could be done this mod allows you to make your own trees

rubencillo900 commented 3 years ago

Terraqueus. It adds 10 fruit trees curseforge page: https://www.curseforge.com/minecraft/mc-mods/terraqueous

There is another mod called Realworld mod which is the succesor of plant mega pack, and adds many trees, but, now is discontinued and i dont know if his creator, 10paktimbits keeps the archives because the website is no longer active.

Gonbuto commented 3 years ago

Please support Heat and Climate. https://www.curseforge.com/minecraft/mc-mods/heat-and-climate This mod contains date, morus, olive, lemon and walnut trees. I know Dynamic Trees - Heat and Climate Compat, but this mod hasn't corresponded now Heat and Climate.

Sorry, I'm not good at English.

DanielGolan-mc commented 3 years ago

Quark Please Support it. Blossom Leaves Inside.

Harleyoc1 commented 3 years ago

@VarielForCode There’s already an addon for quark.

supermassimo commented 3 years ago

Please make compatibility mods for; Stygian End,The Erebus and Defiled Lands and maybe for recurrent complex?

The Erebus and Defiled Lands are already being worked on. Please read the post before suggesting

Atopik2 commented 3 years ago

Erebus and Stygian End Tree numbers are already written but stygian end only adds 1 tree please make a mod for that 🙏

supermassimo commented 3 years ago

Erebus and Stygian End Tree numbers are already written but stygian end only adds 1 tree please make a mod for that 🙏

Stygian End's tree is too big to be made dynamic. And again, both Stygian End and Erebus is already on the list.

Atopik2 commented 3 years ago

Can you make stygian trees in ahape of willow and in size of that giant redwood/speuces that willblook pretty good please.

6 Kas 2020 Cum 01:05 tarihinde supermassimo notifications@github.com şunu yazdı:

Erebus and Stygian End Tree numbers are already written but stygian end only adds 1 tree please make a mod for that 🙏

Stygian End's tree is too big to be made dynamic. And again, Erebus is already on the list.

— You are receiving this because you commented. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/supermassimo/DynamicTrees-ExC/issues/41#issuecomment-722672841, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ARUSFW5FGCJRSQDDQ33MSALSOMOSFANCNFSM4Q3BCNZA .

Harleyoc1 commented 3 years ago

Can you make stygian trees in ahape of willow and in size of that giant redwood/speuces that willblook pretty good please. 6 Kas 2020 Cum 01:05 tarihinde supermassimo notifications@github.com şunu yazdı: … Erebus and Stygian End Tree numbers are already written but stygian end only adds 1 tree please make a mod for that 🙏 Stygian End's tree is too big to be made dynamic. And again, Erebus is already on the list. — You are receiving this because you commented. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub <#41 (comment)>, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ARUSFW5FGCJRSQDDQ33MSALSOMOSFANCNFSM4Q3BCNZA .

We will not add trees to addons unless we can respect how they are in the original mod, or failing that how they are in reality. The Stygian End trees are too large to be made dynamic, it would ruin the whole look of the biome to have smaller trees.

Atopik2 commented 3 years ago

Thanks i understand why you cant make stygian end compatible with dynamic trees; Can you make compatibility between giant mushrooms from vanilla minecraft and the ones at the twillight forest and a compatibility for defiled lands,thanks :)

8 Kas 2020 Paz 14:29 tarihinde Harleyoc1 notifications@github.com şunu yazdı:

Can you make stygian trees in ahape of willow and in size of that giant redwood/speuces that willblook pretty good please. 6 Kas 2020 Cum 01:05 tarihinde supermassimo notifications@github.com şunu yazdı: … <#m7364260556337920694> Erebus and Stygian End Tree numbers are already written but stygian end only adds 1 tree please make a mod for that 🙏 Stygian End's tree is too big to be made dynamic. And again, Erebus is already on the list. — You are receiving this because you commented. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub <#41 (comment) https://github.com/supermassimo/DynamicTrees-ExC/issues/41#issuecomment-722672841>, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ARUSFW5FGCJRSQDDQ33MSALSOMOSFANCNFSM4Q3BCNZA .

We will not add trees to addons unless we can respect how they are in the original mod, or failing that how they are in reality. The Stygian End trees are too large to be made dynamic, it would ruin the whole look of the biome to have smaller trees.

— You are receiving this because you commented. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/supermassimo/DynamicTrees-ExC/issues/41#issuecomment-723564222, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ARUSFW6ZHASCVWI6DHZHVFTSOZ6ITANCNFSM4Q3BCNZA .

Harleyoc1 commented 3 years ago

Thanks i understand why you cant make stygian end compatible with dynamic trees; Can you make compatibility between giant mushrooms from vanilla minecraft and the ones at the twillight forest and a compatibility for defiled lands,thanks :) 8 Kas 2020 Paz 14:29 tarihinde Harleyoc1 notifications@github.com şunu yazdı: …

Defiled lands is already on the list, and dynamic mushrooms has been suggested as an idea in DynamicTreesTeam/DynamicTrees-ExC#28. Please make sure you look at the list before making suggestions (you could use ctrl/cmd + f to search for a mod).

SlimefrogSocial commented 3 years ago

1 vote more for The Midnight, Stygian (I read the other comments but it is still on the list so I will still vote), & The Creeping Nether

supermassimo commented 3 years ago

1 vote more for The Midnight, Stygian (I read the other comments but it is still on the list so I will still vote), & The Creeping Nether

All of those are already listed.

supermassimo commented 3 years ago

Hello. Could you add compability to Aether: Lost Content mod https://www.curseforge.com/minecraft/mc-mods/aether-lost-content ? It doesn't add any new trees but it adds a dungeon that has crystal trees outside it and those trees arent dynamic trees even if you have aether addon installed while the gold dungeon has dynamic trees outside it. https://puu.sh/GMFJg/ff37e71922.png

The Aether addon already has a certain compatibility with Lost Content. if its installed, you will be able to craft and plant crystal trees. Unfortunately i was unable to remove the crystal trees from the dungeon, as these are hardcoded into its generation.

DarkWolfe5 commented 3 years ago

I'm looking for Nature's Aura mod compatibility.for 1.12.2 When replaceVanillaSapling = true the Ritual of the Forest don't want to work. When I place either an oak acorn or a vanilla sapling, it turns into a DT sapling, which NA doesn't recognize as satisfying the ritual's need for an oak sapling.

I already have Dynamic Trees - Nature's Aura by HarleyOConnor installed, and that doesn't fix anything about the tree rituals.

From my digging in the code of both NA and DT, the NA check is trying to match the center block with instanceof BlockSapling or BlockLog. (Found in /naturesaura/blocks/multi/Multiblocks.java) I thought changing the extend of BlockDynamicSapling in DT to BlockSapling would work, but that build just crashes the client on loading. I've tried to add the DT saplings and branches to the ritual check, but that has no effect so far, but I could be doing it wrong. I'm not very savvy in writing Java, let alone MC mods.

I've also filed a report/request (#167) with Nature's Aura. I'll update here if I get a response over there.

Nature's Aura: https://www.curseforge.com/minecraft/mc-mods/natures-aura DT-Nature's Aura: https://www.curseforge.com/minecraft/mc-mods/dynamic-trees-natures-aura

Harleyoc1 commented 3 years ago

I'm looking for Nature's Aura mod compatibility.for 1.12.2 When replaceVanillaSapling = true the Ritual of the Forest don't want to work. When I place either an oak acorn or a vanilla sapling, it turns into a DT sapling, which NA doesn't recognize as satisfying the ritual's need for an oak sapling.

I already have Dynamic Trees - Nature's Aura by HarleyOConnor installed, and that doesn't fix anything about the tree rituals.

From my digging in the code of both NA and DT, the NA check is trying to match the center block with instanceof BlockSapling or BlockLog. (Found in /naturesaura/blocks/multi/Multiblocks.java) I thought changing the extend of BlockDynamicSapling in DT to BlockSapling would work, but that build just crashes the client on loading. I've tried to add the DT saplings and branches to the ritual check, but that has no effect so far, but I could be doing it wrong. I'm not very savvy in writing Java, let alone MC mods.

I've also filed a report/request (#167) with Nature's Aura. I'll update here if I get a response over there.

Nature's Aura: https://www.curseforge.com/minecraft/mc-mods/natures-aura DT-Nature's Aura: https://www.curseforge.com/minecraft/mc-mods/dynamic-trees-natures-aura

I never got around to implementing the ritual of the forest yet - it states this clearly on the CurseForge page. I never thought about replaceVanillaSapling messing that up so that’s an error on my part, is it something you need to work or could you turn it off for the time being? I will release a patch to the mod and remove the sapling replacer for the time being anyway.

DarkWolfe5 commented 3 years ago

I never got around to implementing the ritual of the forest yet - it states this clearly on the CurseForge page. I never thought about replaceVanillaSapling messing that up so that’s an error on my part, is it something you need to work or could you turn it off for the time being? I will release a patch to the mod and remove the sapling replacer for the time being anyway.

"Need" is always a subjective term. ;-) I can get away without this function, it just won't look as pretty as I intend in the long run. Bonus points if I could assign specific ages of the tree before the ritual kicks off, depending on the recipe (but that wouldn't be your dept. anyways).

I can turn off the replaceVanillaSapling setting for now and wait patiently, and hopefully, for this detail to be added.

Thank you for the quick reply!

P.S. I looked through the curseforge page, and didn't see anything about dynamic trees and anything in NA, other than a link to the DT-NA addon. shrug No biggie... I HAVE been going blind lately though... dang aging!! B-)

supermassimo commented 3 years ago

I never got around to implementing the ritual of the forest yet - it states this clearly on the CurseForge page. I never thought about replaceVanillaSapling messing that up so that’s an error on my part, is it something you need to work or could you turn it off for the time being? I will release a patch to the mod and remove the sapling replacer for the time being anyway.

"Need" is always a subjective term. ;-) I can get away without this function, it just won't look as pretty as I intend in the long run. Bonus points if I could assign specific ages of the tree before the ritual kicks off, depending on the recipe (but that wouldn't be your dept. anyways).

I can turn off the replaceVanillaSapling setting for now and wait patiently, and hopefully, for this detail to be added.

Thank you for the quick reply!

P.S. I looked through the curseforge page, and didn't see anything about dynamic trees and anything in NA, other than a link to the DT-NA addon. shrug No biggie... I HAVE been going blind lately though... dang aging!! B-)

This post is to suggest new mods for compatibility, for any other suggestion or bug report please open a new issue.

yinianshisanyue commented 3 years ago

Hello, I want to ask how worldgen is written. I want to generate Pam’s tree. Thank you！

LEWeee commented 3 years ago

★★★☆☆Sakura (5 trees)

Sakura apparently was supposed to have built in Dynamic Trees support at one point 0999312/Sakura_mod#44.

Response from the main dev:

目前放弃对动态树的支持 实在是过于繁琐，无法下笔。

Translated (at the courtesy of Google Translate):

Support for dynamic trees is currently abandoned It is too cumbersome to write.

Just thought it was worth mentioning.

Sakura also adds 6 trees, not 5 (Red Maple, Yellow Maple, Orange Maple, Green Maple, Sakura and Plum), 7 if you include Bamboo

tyon2006 commented 3 years ago

Hey, hoping for support for original Kathairis. Has 4 trees, but I think only 3 would be candidates because of a mushroom decorator. Link for the mod below:

https://www.curseforge.com/minecraft/mc-mods/beta-kathairis

barttraeger commented 3 years ago

Hi there, this one is quite tricky, I believe: Is it somehow possible to make a compat for the mod Maple Syrup ? (https://www.curseforge.com/minecraft/mc-mods/maple-syrup) It's a tree tapping system with custom config options which tree gives which fluid, which is great for modpack developing. Has this Stardew Valley vibe about it which is really neat. Problem is the tree tap block from the mod must be placed against a log, which is not possible with dynamic trees.

However, in the Dynamic Trees PHC Addon it's possible to tap maple trees by clicking the trunk with an iron ingot. Would it be possible to apply this system to configurable trees with configurable fluid output and amount ? Thanks for any ideas and thank you for all your work!

PessiPanto commented 3 years ago

Hey could you add support for Plant Mega Pack? Aside from adding many other kinds of flowers, crops, swamp plants, bushes and shrubs, this mod adds a variety of new trees--52 to be exact. Some big, some small, some short, some tall. Many are fruit trees. It adds coconut and other palm trees. It has to be one of the best tree mods. http://www.9minecraft.net/plant-mega-pack-mod/

LEWeee commented 3 years ago

Hey could you add support for Plant Mega Pack? Aside from adding many other kinds of flowers, crops, swamp plants, bushes and shrubs, this mod adds a variety of new trees--52 to be exact. Some big, some small, some short, some tall. Many are fruit trees. It adds coconut and other palm trees. It has to be one of the best tree mods. http://www.9minecraft.net/plant-mega-pack-mod/

Plant Mega Pack seems to unfortunately be discontinued as the official website for the mod is offline and the link you provided is from a third party site that often has outdated versions which may or may not even pose a threat to the safety of your computer, so I doubt Plant Mega Pack support will be done any time soon, if a all.

Which is kind of a shame though, I would certainly like to do something similar. It was very useful for decoration as well as breathe some new life into the world without neccessarily adding any new biomes.

SlimefrogSocial commented 3 years ago

2 things: 1 DragonFire mod support would be nice, they only have 2 trees and only 1 has leaves so hopefully it's pretty simple (it's a Patreon mod for now {Beta release} which I have, can't give it out for public for free but for development should be separate from that) 2 I noticed that the projects area hasn't been updated in a while, life just getting busy?

EDIT: Didn't see the rule about public source, I might be able to get it if you want to look into it but I would have to ask for it, it isn't "public" in that sense, sadly... I was really hoping for that mod to have Dynamic Trees as well, but I guess that's just my luck unless it gets chosen and they want to give me the open source version...

LEWeee commented 3 years ago

1 DragonFire mod support would be nice, they only have 2 trees and only 1 has leaves so hopefully it's pretty simple (it's a Patreon mod for now {Beta release} which I have, can't give it out for public for free but for development should be separate from that)

EDIT: Didn't see the rule about public source, I might be able to get it if you want to look into it but I would have to ask for it, it isn't "public" in that sense, sadly... I was really hoping for that mod to have Dynamic Trees as well, but I guess that's just my luck unless it gets chosen and they want to give me the open source version...

Even if you are able to get the source code, it has to be under such a license that allows for modifying the code as long as certain criteria are met (e.g.: you can't make money out of the creation you use the modified code for, or you can only modify the code if you give credit somewhere to the original creator, etc.), which considering the mod is a Patreon mod the license most likely isn't going to be met (because if it was at that point anyone could hypothetically just take the source code, compile it themselves and give it out for free). I think you would have a much bigger luck asking the original devs for built-in Dynamic Trees support as even if you were able to get the source code the license wouldn't allow us to do anything with it.

Harleyoc1 commented 3 years ago

2 I noticed that the projects area hasn't been updated in a while, life just getting busy?

This is mainly because we are busy working on the 1.16 port, once it’s done add-ons will be the main priority again.

Knight9910 commented 3 years ago

Not sure where to ask this. Wondering if there's any way to make Dynamic Trees compatible with Mystcraft. Mystcraft doesn't add any new tree types, but it does involve world generation, and apparently uses its own generation system to do it instead of the normal world gen system, which results in Mystcraft dimensions always spawning vanilla trees instead. I was wondering if anyone knew a way to make the two work together.

Cr4fTJuNkiE commented 3 years ago

Only 1 Star for Oh The Biomes You Go?! That mod is GREAT! Every bit as good as BOP. Please consider adding more stars! Especially when DT for 1.16.5 is out! Thank you!

Harleyoc1 commented 3 years ago

Only 1 Star for Oh The Biomes You Go?! That mod is GREAT! Every bit as good as BOP. Please consider adding more stars! Especially when DT for 1.16.5 is out! Thank you!

@Cr4fTJuNkiE This thread is for 1.12. We will likely never make an add-on for BYG for 1.12 because it's extremely buggy and I believe unfinished.

However, for 1.16 it will almost definitely happen. In fact one of the developers of BYG has shown interest in making it himself.

Harleyoc1 commented 3 years ago

Also, to re-iterate how the stars work:

The stars are a rough estimate of how likely it is for me (subjectively, anyone is free to pick any!) to choose that mod. It is based on how popular the mod is, how many trees it has, how unique these are and how interesting I find them. 0 stars just means i do not know enough about the mod, not that i do not like it.

Cr4fTJuNkiE commented 3 years ago

Aah. OK. Apologies. Didn't see that! Great news!! Thank you.

On Sun, May 2, 2021, 2:59 PM Harleyoc1 @.***> wrote:

Only 1 Star for Oh The Biomes You Go?! That mod is GREAT! Every bit as good as BOP. Please consider adding more stars! Especially when DT for 1.16.5 is out! Thank you!

@Cr4fTJuNkiE https://github.com/Cr4fTJuNkiE This thread is for 1.12. We will likely never make an add-on for BYG for 1.12 because it's extremely buggy and I believe unfinished.

However, for 1.16 it will almost definitely happen. In fact one of the developers of BYG has shown interest in making it himself.

— You are receiving this because you were mentioned. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/supermassimo/DynamicTrees-ExC/issues/41#issuecomment-830855259, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AL2RVPMXAXDCREMKQJETCPTTLWOKZANCNFSM4Q3BCNZA .

Nathan22211 commented 3 years ago

the 1.12 version of BYG, from looking at it with biometweaker is also an MCreator mod

Cr4fTJuNkiE commented 3 years ago

Yeah. I was. The dev ditched MCreator and codes with Forge now.

On Sun, May 2, 2021 at 5:11 PM Nathan22211 @.***> wrote:

the 1.12 version of BYG, from looking at it with biometweaker is also an MCreator mod

— You are receiving this because you were mentioned. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/supermassimo/DynamicTrees-ExC/issues/41#issuecomment-830872654, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AL2RVPLMN647BS4SVLP4DE3TLW5X7ANCNFSM4Q3BCNZA .

Cr4fTJuNkiE commented 3 years ago

*IT

On Sun, May 2, 2021 at 7:38 PM Bryan Wells @.***> wrote:

Yeah. I was. The dev ditched MCreator and codes with Forge now.

On Sun, May 2, 2021 at 5:11 PM Nathan22211 @.***> wrote:

the 1.12 version of BYG, from looking at it with biometweaker is also an MCreator mod

— You are receiving this because you were mentioned. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/supermassimo/DynamicTrees-ExC/issues/41#issuecomment-830872654, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AL2RVPLMN647BS4SVLP4DE3TLW5X7ANCNFSM4Q3BCNZA .

kittylegitcheck commented 3 years ago

Biomes o plenty for 1.16.5 pls

CrazyDinoLover commented 3 years ago

[Suggestion] Jurassic World Reborn mod (Basicly JurassiCraft but with more trees)

yggdrasil75 commented 3 years ago

is there possibility of support for future versions/nether backport fungi?

DarthCaesium commented 2 years ago

Advanced Rocketry - 3 trees

doarlock commented 2 years ago

[Suggestion]

Husbandry and Pies! (Forge) for 1.12.2 https://www.curseforge.com/minecraft/mc-mods/hsbdry

It adds a new biome named Mud Field. The mod adds too a new crops, seeds, food and a new entity called mud pig.

Harleyoc1 commented 2 years ago

[Suggestion]

Husbandry and Pies! (Forge) for 1.12.2 https://www.curseforge.com/minecraft/mc-mods/hsbdry

It adds a new biome named Mud Field. The mod adds too a new crops, seeds, food and a new entity called mud pig.

How many trees does it add/what is support needed for?