search

EFForg / privacybadger

Privacy Badger is a browser extension that automatically learns to block invisible trackers.
https://privacybadger.org
Other
3.19k stars 386 forks source link

Anti adblocker wall on loot-link.com #2952

Closed DogancanYr closed 4 months ago

DogancanYr commented 8 months ago

What is your browser and browser version?

Firefox developer latest version.

What is broken and where?

pagead2.googlesyndication.com It thinks it's an ad blocker if it gets blocked.

ghostwords commented 8 months ago

Hello and thanks for opening an issue!

Could you link to an example page where you see this happen?

Related to #1596.

DogancanYr commented 8 months ago

My mistake I forgot to give the link . https://loot-link.com/s?p7do

ghostwords commented 7 months ago

The thing is, Privacy Badger is not an adblocker, and it's not clear whether we should try to circumvent anti-adblocker walls or not. Since we don't yet a good response to this class of nuisance, it's a shortcoming for sure, but I don't think it merits a one-star review. It is clearly something for us to improve in the future though.

We got a bunch of information on what makes Privacy Badger special on the homepage FAQ. Let me know if you have any questions.

DogancanYr commented 7 months ago

Privacy Badger is only using static filters by default, which provides no real benefit over uBlock Origin. It used to "learn" about trackers, but this was turned off as a default because of security and fingerprinting concerns and since uBlock Origin blocks domains, blocked domains would also be blocked from setting cookies.

ghostwords commented 7 months ago

Privacy Badger does not use any filter lists. While there is likely to be overlap between the various advertising/tracker lists and Privacy Badger, regardless of whether you enable learning locally, Privacy Badger can automatically discover new trackers that list-based blockers don’t know about.

Besides automatic tracker blocking, Privacy Badger comes with privacy features like click-to-activate replacements for potentially useful trackers (video players, comments sections like Disqus, etc.), and link cleaning on Facebook and Google.

Privacy Badger is also a political tool. By using Privacy Badger, you support the Electronic Frontier Foundation. Privacy Badger sends the Global Privacy Control signal to opt you out of data sharing and selling, and the Do Not Track signal to tell companies not to track you. If trackers ignore your wishes, Privacy Badger will learn to block them. The idea isn't to block all advertising but rather to promote a better Web.

uBlock Origin is an excellent privacy tool, but just as Privacy Badger is not a replacement for uBlock Origin, uBlock Origin is not a replacement for Privacy Badger.

DogancanYr commented 7 months ago

potentially useful trackers (video players, comments sections like Disqus, etc.), and link cleaning on Facebook and Google.

I think these will be the Disqus tracker cookies or to transmit data . resim

ghostwords commented 7 months ago

I'm not sure what your point is. If uBlock Origin blocks some Disqus tracking requests, great! That is not at all the same as what Privacy Badger does for Disqus and a whole bunch of other widgets.

In fact, this seems like another case where uBlock Origin and Privacy Badger pair well together.