search

ESA-VirES / VirES-Python-Client

viresclient is a Python package for easy access to Swarm & Aeolus products as xarray.Dataset
https://viresclient.readthedocs.io
MIT License
15 stars 1 forks source link

Kp, Dst, F10.7 and IMF #44

Open lmar76 opened 4 years ago

lmar76 commented 4 years ago

As already done for data downloaded from the VirES web interface, we should disable the download of Kp, Dst, F10.7 and IMF indices via Python client.

smithara commented 4 years ago

Is this because of the non-ESA sources of the data? The access to these indices through viresclient is quite useful for some workflows (I use it myself).

Perhaps instead of removing them, we can add some source acknowledgement with links to the responsible organisations. This might be as metadata in the data objects created and/or as an info message at run time when these data are accessed.

lmar76 commented 4 years ago

Yes, we are trying to understand if it is possible to redistribute this data. For the time being, please put this issue on hold.

smithara commented 4 years ago

These data are available (redistributed) through a number of other channels, perhaps most notably by the NASA OMNI service (https://omniweb.gsfc.nasa.gov/html/ow_data.html#3) and there are other Python packages out there (e.g. pysat) that provide access. I have no idea of the legal issues about ESA providing access to these, but the data are all publicly available.

AFAIK the IMF data are all originally sourced from NASA (spacecraft upstream from Earth) - the OMNI service has some description of the contributing spacecraft and processing method. I don't recall the exact origin of the IMF data as part of the Swarm AUX - it may well be via OMNI.

The magnetic indices (Kp, Dst) are organised through IAGA and I think the actual responsible institutions for distributing them have changed over time, though the contributing measurements come from a number of observatories in different countries. For info and citations: see:

F10.7 comes from Space Weather Canada - https://www.spaceweather.gc.ca/solarflux/sx-en.php

I would expect to provide some explanation like above when users access the data, and ideally the recommended text to include in acknowledgements in publications. In reality, these data often don't get acknowledged properly though many many papers rely on them in part. So it would be good to improve that.