search

ESIPFed / sweet

Official repository for Semantic Web for Earth and Environmental Terminology (SWEET) Ontologies
Other
119 stars 33 forks source link

Correct semantics of "Calf" #102

Closed pbuttigieg closed 1 year ago

pbuttigieg commented 5 years ago

Hi SWEET team,

We're at a cryosemantics hackathon at ESIP Winter 2019, and have spotted the following error: https://github.com/ESIPFed/sweet/blob/master/src/realmCryo.ttl#L63-L65

Here, a "calf" is asserted to be a kind of "sea ice". However, as sea ice is frozen out of sea water and calved ice can fall from other ice masses, this isn't so.

ENVO's next release will clarify some of these semantics in detail: http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/ENVO_01001506 (not live yet)

@rduerr

pbuttigieg commented 4 years ago

@smrgeoinfo also noted the problematic nature of the label here

rduerr commented 4 years ago

Per the GCW the synonym "Calved ice" probably should be used here.

rduerr commented 1 year ago

The term at least should be moved to a parent up a level to somaw:Ice (http://sweetontology.net/matrWater/Ice). Will change the label to be "ice calf".

brandonnodnarb commented 1 year ago

addressed in #286