search

ESIPFed / sweet

Official repository for Semantic Web for Earth and Environmental Terminology (SWEET) Ontologies
Other
119 stars 33 forks source link

examine owl:equivalentClass relations for synonyms/acronyms #118

Open brandonnodnarb opened 5 years ago

brandonnodnarb commented 5 years ago

As the development of SWEET initially pre-dates SKOS, there are tens, if not hundreds, of owl:equivalentClass relationships which appear to be a mechanism for adding what is essentially alternate labels (i.e. skos:altLabel), including synonyms and acronyms (the latter is much more prevalent).

A candidate list is needed for acronyms and synonym labels.

Related to #20 in particular https://github.com/ESIPFed/sweet/issues/20#issuecomment-491018463

lewismc commented 5 years ago

@brandonnodnarb I think that this issue is an excellent candidate for the forthcoming ESIP session - https://sched.co/PtTi

Thursday, July 18 • 1:30pm - 3:00pm ESIP Geoscience Community Ontology Engineering Workshop (GCOEW)

@charlesvardeman @pbuttigieg @cmungall @brandonnodnarb does this sound reasonable?

brandonnodnarb commented 5 years ago

Excellent @lewismc. I'll be there only virtually.

brandonnodnarb commented 5 years ago

There are ~240 owl:sameAs relations and ~415 owl:equivalentClass relations. Obviouisly all of these aren't synonym candidates but the raw numbers without context help understand the scale of the proposal.

lewismc commented 5 years ago

I think this would be an excellent candidate for the ontology engineering workshop on Thursday.

brandonnodnarb commented 3 years ago

As per the discussion on #250, if skos labels are introduced, should owl:equivalenClasses which are obvious acronyms be deprecated with the label moving to an skos:altLabel of the class with the full URI and label?

I have found ~80 such classes --- see this google sheet for reference.
The 'Acronyms_only' tab has the ~80 classes which appear to be obvious acronyms culled from the 'all_SWEET_owl-equivalentClass' tab. The 'all_SWEET_owl-equivalentClass' tab has all owl:equivalendClass relationships found in SWEET listed (dump from SPARQL query).

graybeal commented 3 years ago

and it looks like one goes the other way, line 22 of the all_ list has envirStandards/RfD in the right column and ReferenceDose in the left column.

brandonnodnarb commented 3 years ago

There are others, see lines 73 and 74 in the Acronyms spreadsheet for example. I missed this one.

It's now been added.