Input for review of imported WikiData definitions - for various terms

[rrovetto]

Description

The imported WikiData definition in SWEET 'star', and others (below), does not match the intended subject matter (scope) of its SWEET modules. Recommendations below. Will add more observations as I find them. This is a review in the context of WikiData descriptions to identify obvious errors, not a thorough analysis. A more thorough semantic analysis would include suggested edits to a given definition, suggestions for a missing or replacement definition.

Context: https://github.com/ESIPFed/sweet/pull/200 , https://github.com/ESIPFed/sweet/pull/205 , etc. Related: Thus far, I've done a partial cursory review of some of the recently imported WikiData definitions, and have added observations/recommendations to the provided spreadsheet offline for some of the terms. Will continue as able.

What would you like to see changed?

Recommendation: Delete WIkiData definition of 'star' (http://sweetontology.net/realm/AstroBody/Star) Reason: Mismatch between intended scope of the SWEET module, and the imported definition. Alternative WikiData definition: https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q523

Recommendation: Delete definition of 'satellite' (http://sweetontology.net/realm/AstroBody/Satellite) Reason: Mismatch between intended scope of the SWEET module, and the imported definition. Alternative WikiData definition: https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q1297322

Recommendation: Delete WikiData definition of 'moon' (http://sweetontology.net/realm/AstroBody/Moon) Alternative WikiData definition: https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q2537

Recommendation: Delete WikiData definition of 'planetary boundary' (http://sweetontology.net/realm/PlanetaryBoundary) Alternative WikiData definition: https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q1757268

Recommendation: Delete WikiData definition of 'position' (http://sweetontology.net/propSpaceLocation/Position) Observation: WikiData currently seems to have it synonymous with 'location' (https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q17334923)

Recommendation: Delete WIkiData definition of 'size'(http://sweetontology.net/propSpaceDistance/Size) Reason: Mismatch between intended scope of the SWEET module, and the imported definition. Alternative WikiData definition: https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q322481

Recommendation: Delete WIkiData definition of 'axis' (http://sweetontology.net/propSpaceDirection/Axis) Reason: Mismatch between intended scope of the SWEET module, and the imported definition. Alternative WikiData definition: https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q1783819

Recommendation: Delete WIkiData definition of 'attitude' (http://sweetontology.net/propSpaceDirection/Attitude) Reason: Mismatch between intended scope of the SWEET module, and the imported definition. Alternative WikiData definition: https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q2235286

Recommendation: Delete WIkiData definition of 'shape' (http://sweetontology.net/propSpace/Shape) Alternative WikiData definition: https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q207961

Recommendation: Delete WIkiData definition of 'abyss' (http://sweetontology.net/realm/Ocean/Abyss) Reason: Mismatch between scope of the SWEET module, and the imported definition. Comment: the context of the SWEET module suggests intended meaning is related to the abyssal zone, abyssal plain, etc. of the ocean.

Recommendation: Delete WIkiData definition of 'file' (http://sweetontology.net/reprDataFormat/File) Reason: too specific, i.e. wrt Unix. Alternative WikiData def: https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q82753

Recommendation: Delete WIkiData definition for 'data' (http://sweetontology.net/reprDataProduct/Data) Reason: can be more precise. Alternative WikiData definition: https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q494756

Recommendation: Delete WIkiData definition for 'process' (http://sweetontology.net/proc/Process) Reason: Mismatch between scope of the SWEET module, and the imported definition.

Recommendation: Delete WIkiData definition for 'realm' (http://sweetontology.net/realm/Realm) Reason: Mismatch between scope of the SWEET module, and the imported definition.

Recommendation: Delete WIkiData definition of 'bombardment' (http://sweetontology.net/procPhysical/Bombardment) Reason: Mismatch between scope of the SWEET module, and the imported definition.

Recommendation: Delete WIkiData definition of 'arc' (http://sweetontology.net/realmGeolOrogen/Arc) Reason: Mismatch between scope of the SWEET module, and the imported definition.

Recommendation: Delete WIkiData definition of 'substratum' (http://sweetontology.net/realmSoil/Substratum) Reason: Mismatch between scope of the SWEET module, and the imported definition.

Recommendation: Delete WIkiData definition of 'structure' (http://sweetontology.net/reprDataModel/Structure) Reason: Mismatch between scope of the SWEET module, and the imported definition.

Recommendation: Delete WIkiData definition of 'pole' (http://sweetontology.net/reprSpaceCoordinate/Pole) Reason: Mismatch between scope of the SWEET module, and the imported definition.

Recommendation: Delete WIkiData definition of 'circular' (http://sweetontology.net/reprSpaceGeometry/Circular) Reason: Mismatch between scope of the SWEET module, and the imported definition. Alternative WikiData definition: https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q59564206

Recommendation: Delete WIkiData definition of 'sphere' (http://sweetontology.net/reprSpaceGeometry3D/Sphere) Reason: Mismatch between scope of the SWEET module, and the imported definition.

Recommendation: Delete WIkiData definition of 'bottom' (http://sweetontology.net/stateSpaceConfiguration/Bottom) Reason: Mismatch between scope of the SWEET module, and the imported definition.

Recommendation: Delete WIkiData definition of 'high tide' (http://sweetontology.net/stateTimeCycle/HighTide) Reason: too specific. can be more precise. Alternative WikiData def: https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q20631632

Recommendation: Delete WIkiData definition of 'era' (http://sweetontology.net/stateTime/Era) Reason: too specific, if the SWEET module is not geo. Should be more general, e.g., as a reference time. Alternative WikiData def: https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q2703

Attribution

if needed, http://orcid.org/0000-0003-3835-7817

Labeling your issues

if needed, 'realm', 'enhancement'

[lewismc]

@rrovetto are you suggesting that we remove these skos:definition's? I don't have an issue with that, I just want to clarify. Thanks

[rrovetto]

@rrovetto are you suggesting that we remove these skos:definition's? I don't have an issue with that, I just want to clarify. Thanks

Yes--for those I wrote 'delete [...]', provided that the skos:definition annotation contains the Wikidata definition indicated in the spreadsheet provided.

For example, the wikidata definition, references in the spreadsheet, for the SWEET astroBody/Star should be removed. If desired, I included alternative WikiData definitions I found that more closely matche. If not, then the minimum recommendation is to remove. Sorry if my wording in the post isn't clear. If you prefer, I can edit it to say 'remove current wikidata def in skos:def annotation', etc.

[lewismc]

I've encoded the above contributions in the updated PR. Thanks for looking at this @rrovetto