[CrudUrlBuilder] Transform crudControllerFqcn into crudId fail to generate url after redirect

[cristobal85]

When transform 'crudControllerFqcn' into 'crudId', there are fails on associationfield links and actions link after redirect to URL generated by CrudUrlGenerator.

The "App\Entity\Requester\UserRequest" entity with "id = 46" does not exist in the database. The entity may have been deleted by mistake or by a "cascade={"remove"}" operation executed by Doctrine.

However, the link is an AssociationField to App\Entity\Requester\Request, no App\Entity\Requester\UserRequest. The UserRequest Entity is the current entity (UserRequest has one Request).

The links generated are:

• ORIGINAL (WORKS FINE):

Current URL: /admin/requester?crudAction=index& crudControllerFqcn=App%5CController%5CBackend%5CRequester%5CUserRequestCrudController& menuIndex=2& signature=-HCz9mpXuN7krlQPJuFrOtnGNNuOUkJUabgvuGWnLho&submenuIndex=-1

AssociationField URL: /admin/requester? crudAction=detail& crudControllerFqcn=App%5CController%5CBackend%5CRequester%5CRequestCrudController& entityId=46& referrer=%2Fadmin%2Frequester%3FcrudAction%3Dindex%26crudControllerFqcn%3DApp%255CController%255CBackend%255CRequester%255CUserRequestCrudController%26menuIndex%3D2%26signature%3D-HCz9mpXuN7krlQPJuFrOtnGNNuOUkJUabgvuGWnLho%26submenuIndex%3D-1& signature=s9WceVxIiH9bKq1A_Ls6lhcIZv4dqZPZuh-f3M0jfcg

• After redirect with url generated by CrudUrlGenerator with transform crudControllerFqcn (WORKS WRONG):

Current URL: admin/requester? crudAction=index& crudId=a22e04b& entityId=13& menuIndex=2& signature=yrRyZQ1wT_OoVJReVIbQd65GYt-kANIfOGDwpsNc2Dk

AssociationField URL: /admin/requester? crudAction=detail& crudControllerFqcn=App%5CController%5CBackend%5CRequester%5CUserRequestCrudController& entityId=46& referrer=%2Fadmin%2Frequester%3FcrudAction%3Dindex%26crudId%3Da22e04b%26entityId%3D13%26menuIndex%3D2%26signature%3DyrRyZQ1wT_OoVJReVIbQd65GYt-kANIfOGDwpsNc2Dk& signature=YUmbljefwTLOLsuxLPYsTc1bu3WchB9dleNqYl2ji3U

• After redirect with url generated by CrudUrlGenerator without transform crudControllerFqcn (WORKS WELL):

Current URL: /admin/requester? crudAction=index& crudControllerFqcn=App%5CController%5CBackend%5CRequester%5CUserRequestCrudController&dashboardControllerFqcn=App%5CController%5CBackend%5CRequester%5CRequesterDashboardController& entityId=13& menuIndex=2& signature=g8DN-BrJhWMwhqyF4YipJjWdI0dudiwnE8zU4lVw3jI

AssociationField URL: /admin/requester? crudAction=detail& crudControllerFqcn=App%5CController%5CBackend%5CRequester%5CRequestCrudController& entityId=46&referrer=%2Fadmin%2Frequester%3FcrudAction%3Dindex%26crudControllerFqcn%3DApp%255CController%255CBackend%255CRequester%255CUserRequestCrudController%26entityId%3D13%26menuIndex%3D2%26signature%3Dg8DN-BrJhWMwhqyF4YipJjWdI0dudiwnE8zU4lVw3jI& signature=s9WceVxIiH9bKq1A_Ls6lhcIZv4dqZPZuh-f3M0jfcg

Enviroment:

• Symfony: 5.2.1
• EasyAdmin: 3.2.1

[michael-roth]

We have the same problem with our edit action links with EasyAdmin 3.2.7.

I think this can be fixed by adding the crudId param to $requestParameters in ActionFactory::generateActionUrl()?

https://github.com/EasyCorp/EasyAdminBundle/blob/3a4c9bc2991dd1f94acce13c790dfc4063930cc2/src/Factory/ActionFactory.php#L152

$requestParameters = [
    EA::CRUD_CONTROLLER_FQCN => $request->query->get(EA::CRUD_CONTROLLER_FQCN),
    EA::CRUD_ID => $request->query->get(EA::CRUD_ID), // <-- add this line
    EA::CRUD_ACTION => $actionDto->getCrudActionName(),
    EA::REFERRER => $this->generateReferrerUrl($request, $actionDto, $currentAction),
];

[treenoder]

Same problem with EasyAdmin 3.2.7. After clicking on default edit link from an index action.

[treenoder]

Strangely, it works with Country entity, but not working with Price entity.

[treenoder]

So, for future readers. The problem was mistyped repository class name in the entity class.

[javiereguiluz]

I'm closing this old issue because CrudUrlBuilder is no longer used in the project and we've switched to an AdminUrlGenerator class. Hopefully this problem doesn't happen in the new URL builder. Cheers!

[m-schmale]

I had the same error message today. I generated two urls and for second url I forgot that the entity id of the first url was still in place. Maybe this helps someone with the same stupid mistake. 😆