Closed teixeirak closed 3 years ago
@ValentineHerr , it would be great if you could take a look at what I'm planning before I get in too deep into the revisions. I've made some changes and annotations in the manuscript to indicate what I plan to do, and I'm also tracking some of these above.
Sorry, I didn't get a chance to look at this yesterday...
I like the new title! For the intro, I agree that you can cut most of the paragraph starting with "Dendrochronological methods". Keeping something equivalent to the last 2 sentences of that paragraph seems enough. I think the new table 1 and how you broke out the validation of the methods out in the results are great improvements. For the DBH, keeping most of the content about it seems right.... Being able to use DBH is one of the key point of this new methods and it seems to be what ca-authors/audience remembers the most.
Let me know if there something more specific you'd like me to review.
Thanks! Glad you like the changes. I'm working on it and will follow up later.
This point of time windows is a bit buried to some extent but is a big component of the results. I wonder if adding a sentence about the timing of climate sensitivity and changes in that timing in the introduction could be useful.
Thinking of citations that used standard dendro data to look at some of this:
Maxwell, R. S., Belmecheri, S., Taylor, A. H., Davis, K. J., & Ocheltree, T. W. (2020). Carbon isotope ratios in tree rings respond differently to climatic variations than tree-ring width in a mesic temperate forest. Agricultural and Forest Meteorology, 288, 108014.
Gao, S., Liu, R., Zhou, T., Fang, W., Yi, C., Lu, R., ... & Luo, H. (2018). Dynamic responses of tree‐ring growth to multiple dimensions of drought. Global Change Biology, 24(11), 5380-5390.
D'Orangeville, L., Maxwell, J., Kneeshaw, D., Pederson, N., Duchesne, L., Logan, T., ... & Phillips, R. P. (2018). Drought timing and local climate determine the sensitivity of eastern temperate forests to drought. Global Change Biology, 24(6), 2339-2351.
Kannenberg, S. A., Maxwell, J. T., Pederson, N., D'Orangeville, L., Ficklin, D. L., & Phillips, R. P. (2019). Drought legacies are dependent on water table depth, wood anatomy and drought timing across the eastern US. Ecology Letters, 22(1), 119-127.
Points to highlight:
from PZ, regarding DBH trends: I’d remove this .. not really news
Recording some suggestions from coauthors:
more emphasis on the ecology
clearer balance of methods vs ecology
present a less overwhelming amount of info
other