search

EcoClimLab / vertical-thermal-review

Manuscript and new analysis files for Vinod et al., 2022, New Phytologist
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International
0 stars 0 forks source link

add more theory, particuclarly on micrometeorology #94

Closed teixeirak closed 2 years ago

teixeirak commented 2 years ago

from R2: "Given the depth of what is known about within-canopy micrometeorology, I would have thought taking this on in a review wouldn’t be needed, or would be daunting and require too much detail to cover it all. As it is, I found the article launches into the empirical info too early in such an article. The article could be improved by going through the theory of how momentum and mass-transfers are attenuated through canopies and then show the empirical info from NEON in America. Overall there is too little on the theory end of things and too much 'case study' for this kind of article (see Monteith and Unsworth, and Gates to enhance the first-principle theory)."

(broken out from #87)

teixeirak commented 2 years ago

@NidhiVinod , I agree that bringing in more theory when possible would be helpful. This is something I want to think about more.

teixeirak commented 2 years ago

@TomBuckleyLab, this is one you can help with. I'll let you and @NidhiVinod coordinate.

NidhiVinod commented 2 years ago

I think this is done!