EdenServer / community

35 stars 17 forks source link

"Accuracy varies with TP" is not implemented correctly #622

Closed beauxq closed 4 years ago

beauxq commented 5 years ago

DSP contains the claim: "acc varies with tp ALL apply an acc PENALTY" This is false. I have looked for a source for this claim and can't find one. I asked in DSP development discord, and nobody there had any source for it either.

I have noticed, and gweivyth reported documenting, that this makes Asuran Fists worse than Raging Fists. Anyone who played MNK in retail era knows that Asuran Fists was not worse than Raging Fists.

Here is the fix: https://github.com/bdhs/darkstar/commit/bb97b5c1ae07be63eb3332ee4693fc0c16b7bd4a

Altnob commented 5 years ago

Yea, as someone who's been playing FFXI since RoZ, I have never heard of a acc penalty on those weapon skills. It was always my understanding that the more ACC the higher the ACC was.

100=1 200=1.25 300=1.5 just an example, no source but i've always noticed that with 300 i land all hits much easier.

this explains so much.

Qair commented 5 years ago

bump for this please, asuran is trash at the moment

tectal831 commented 5 years ago

Moved to in progress since fix has been given with ticket

gweivyth commented 5 years ago

Here's a VOD with me using both weapon skills a bunch on Aura Pots in sky. It's muted, so now you don't have to listen to my stupid ass talk over the entire thing. (Mostly because I was listening to copyrighted music while streaming...)

https://www.twitch.tv/videos/340819341 https://www.twitch.tv/videos/340838175

I hit a lot of 400~ damage Asurans during the video, where I was fairly consistently hitting 750~ with Raging Fists on the normal pots. I don't know if the live chat transitioned over, but Serephim and I talk about it quite a bit in the chat as well. TP returns also seemed incredibly wacky...

beauxq commented 5 years ago

The TP return is a different bug reported and fixed a long time ago. (But the fix hasn't been put in Eden yet.) https://github.com/EdenServer/community/issues/214

KnowOne134 commented 4 years ago

This issue was corrected last update