EdwardPiwowar / BBA

1 stars 0 forks source link

(GIB) Unusual 1NT sould only be when opponents have bid 2 suits #153

Open ThorvaldAagaard opened 10 months ago

ThorvaldAagaard commented 10 months ago

There is no description of this agreement on the website

003E759DAB284B5E9DC1834DB476 image

1N seems to be other minor + a major

0CA87F8FBD0643784F95B0249067 and 0F9FA76779856E59AB0078B63419 image

T/O Double is more important than unusual 1N

Do we want to specifically play 1NT as 4-5 with 4 in the higher suit? Jack plays this and either doubles or overcalls with the other shape. I (IAN) tried it for a while and it seemed sensible.

EdwardPiwowar commented 10 months ago

Like a Raptor 1NT? image

ThorvaldAagaard commented 10 months ago

Perhaps but 1: Unpassed hand always bids 1N Natural 2: D is 2-suited (or strong bal) 3: 1N From passed hand is 2-suited, but only 4-card major. With only 4-4 double is probably best anyway 4: with 5-5 2N should be preferred if losers allow it. 5: With 2 many losers and 5-5 and to weak to double 1N as a preemptive bid could be OK

ThorvaldAagaard commented 6 months ago

This is still a problem.

Usual 1NT is only when both opponents have bid as written on the website

image

07BE387B40F703A6ED864CE3770C image

If 1N is minors it is a bad bid with 4-card spades - it is a perfect T/O D of 1H

The south hand with 4333, should just bid 2H After 2C there is no clear description of 2D. Is it responding to Drury?

EdwardPiwowar commented 5 months ago

Next BBA https://sites.google.com/view/bbaenglish/description-of-conventions/unusual-1nt image

ThorvaldAagaard commented 5 months ago

094ADD1CD36398276B1EC839F1D5 image

According to the documentation Unusual 1NT is when both opponents have bid. But here BBA is using it on a passed hand.

That is fine for me, but it is not how GIB defines it.

So we need the documentation updated - and it is probably another convention image

EdwardPiwowar commented 4 months ago

Next BBA corrected as described: https://sites.google.com/view/bbaenglish/description-of-conventions/unusual-1nt

ThorvaldAagaard commented 4 months ago

Fine, now we just need a way to deselect the second option