search

EdwardPiwowar / BBA

1 stars 0 forks source link

fourth suit not gf #344

Open Muppet1 opened 7 months ago

Muppet1 commented 7 months ago

image 088DAFC2DA15BB286DA4DC057FFA

according to thorvald north should not bid 1 spade but 1NT.

I tried 2 spades which it passed. so then i tried 3 spades and it passed that.

ThorvaldAagaard commented 7 months ago

The explanation for 3S is obviously wrong as opener can not have 5S, 4H, 3C and open 1C. It is 4-4-1-4 or 4-4-0-5 and extra. 2S is the same but minimum.

EdwardPiwowar commented 7 months ago

Next BBA image image

No idea ad 1C-1D-1H-? BBA bids 1S or 1N depend on 4SF or GF. If you want something else then you would have to specify all the bids.

ThePokerDude commented 3 months ago

Different but still wrong. Instead of 2h 1nt would be correkt. 2h is explained as 4 hearts but north has 3. image