search

EdwardPiwowar / BBA

1 stars 0 forks source link

reversing with no shape or values #383

Open Muppet1 opened 7 months ago

Muppet1 commented 7 months ago

image 0385EF53A54CF2F8D71E4BAA0219

can we completely revise reverses? currently they are meaningless.

2h should be extras and hence shape as otherwise u bid 1nt in this case,

it does mean you have to decide what to do with min balanced here and 2nt seems pretty sane rather than making it forcing with 15 which would already have opened 1nt too.

ThorvaldAagaard commented 7 months ago

Perhaps it is an idea to add the system that has the problem in the description of the issue (Here it is PC)

EdwardPiwowar commented 6 months ago

Currently image

ThorvaldAagaard commented 6 months ago

A bit optimistic 5N with 4333 19 HCP opposite 12-14. seems more like a quantitative 4N