search

EdwardPiwowar / BBA

2 stars 0 forks source link

Hamann's rulle #554

Open ThorvaldAagaard opened 1 month ago

ThorvaldAagaard commented 1 month ago

Hamman's rule is that if there are possible calls and one of them is 3NT, then 3NT should be chosen

4581884580D5F6576E38B0CC5471 image

After having rebid 2C, I see no other bid, than 3N over 3D, so this is not Hamann's rule :-)

EdwardPiwowar commented 1 month ago

Next BBA First room - N shows 9 HCP only, S can't bid 3N. image

ThorvaldAagaard commented 1 month ago

This is a good example of a board (Room 1), where South should describe his hand, and 3N is perfect for that. With only 9HCP in North and partner showing 6+ C, there should be compensating values to bid 3D.

So 3N is showing an unbalanced hand with a spade-stopper and minimum, and not a calculated bid