search

EdwardPiwowar / BBA

1 stars 0 forks source link

Way to optimistic #558

Open ThorvaldAagaard opened 5 months ago

ThorvaldAagaard commented 5 months ago

022FE98001489E133BF5BB4A5CE4 image

3C is a wrong bid

2H is showing a stopper in heart and denying diamond stop, not showing extra

4N is bad, and 5N is worse

Please look at the documentation at https://www.bridgebum.com/inverted_minors.php

This needs to be updated https://sites.google.com/view/bbaenglish/description-of-conventions/inverted-minors?authuser=0 Especially 3C, that should be 5-card (and 3D after opening 1D)

This is how it is played by GIB image

ThePokerDude commented 2 months ago

better but not good. The description says 3c is 4+ but we have only 3. 2nt is explained as 14-15 but standard is 12-14. So I see two options instead of 3c 1) 2h showing stopper and denying diamond stopper 2) 2nt showing a balanced hand with 12-14

3c should be 5+ clubs not forcing. https://www.bridgebum.com/inverted_minors.php image image

EdwardPiwowar commented 2 months ago

Next BBA image There are too many contradictory versions of "Inverted minors".