New minor forcing after 2N rebid is missing

[ThorvaldAagaard]

0CE0326B8297E58DFD15C038434D

3C is not 5-card, but just forcing, looking for 3-card support

Needs to be updated in the documentation too.

[EdwardPiwowar]

I can implement it but it is not clear whether it is the same for sayc and 2/1 and whether there is no error in the sequences after 1c and 1d. https://bidding.snippen.dk/bidding.asp?id=81&CID=&PrevBid=78788&level=4&Disturbed=false&Defensive=&Convention=&showRule=

[ThorvaldAagaard]

You should not trust 2/1 on bidding.snippen.dk - I have just imported it from someone, and can't remember the source.

If you are going to use the site as source, I will create the 2 systems on the site and start maintaining it (and use it as explanations of BEN's bidding)

When in doubt just check how GIB handles it http://ben.aalborgdata.dk:8080/gib?bid=1C-P-1H-P-2N-P-*

[EdwardPiwowar]

http://ben.aalborgdata.dk:8080/gib?bid=1D-1H-2N-* 3C shows clubs

[ThorvaldAagaard]

I think you are missing the Pass from the opponents http://ben.aalborgdata.dk:8080/gib?bid=1D-P-1H-P-2N-P-*

• is missing if you click on the link so that needs to be manually added

[ThorvaldAagaard]

I think http://bidding.aalborgdata.com/Overview.asp?ID=18 is an OK source, when in doubt but perhaps there are to many conventions unknown to BBA

For SAYC http://bidding.aalborgdata.com/Overview.asp?ID=19 is useable, but a lot of the conventions BEN is playing is missing.

So perhaps the best is I start the hard work of creating two new systems

[EdwardPiwowar]

I miss pass. Now it works. I think there is no need to rush into new conventions, they will not bring significant results. Both links show "HTTP Error 404.0 - Not Found"

[ThorvaldAagaard]

Ahh, forgetting that aalborgdata.com is my local server - just replace it with snippen.dk that is my external server

https://bidding.snippen.dk/Overview.asp?ID=18 https://bidding.snippen.dk/Overview.asp?ID=19

[ThorvaldAagaard]

Even without New Minor Forcing, this is wrong as we do not play Walsh 0C26AB6EC3807C57CE7ACDD33A4C

Without NMF and without Walsh 3D is just nat and showing 5H. If Walsh it could be longer, but I doubt it is a good agreement.

[ThorvaldAagaard]

Another example of NMF missing 06690024283552DE85F07FD09B35

Perhaps you should add Walsh as a convention so I can deselect it :-)