EdwardPiwowar / BBA

1 stars 0 forks source link

Strange bidding #73

Open ThorvaldAagaard opened 11 months ago

ThorvaldAagaard commented 11 months ago

721F651E06C3738FD37B49DDF84E image

South miscounted the diamonds and clubs :-)

EdwardPiwowar commented 11 months ago

BEN-UCBC has Multi-Landy = 1 Wbridge5-Sayc Multi-Landy = 0

ThorvaldAagaard commented 11 months ago

It was Souths bidding of Gerber followed by 6D I think is very strange with longer clubs

EdwardPiwowar commented 11 months ago

The explanation is simple, if you assume that N has: KXX diamonds Kx clubs so what would you rather play?

ThorvaldAagaard commented 11 months ago

I would not get in that situation :-)

But it is interesting how to show a two-suited minor hand in the system.

I would transfer to clubs, and then bid a short major, or a natural 3Dm but looking at the definitions, it is not clear how the continuation after the transfer is defined, image

image

If I transfer to 3D and bid 4C it is a cuebid. I tried that and noted another error as North now denied a spade control in this sequence: image

ThorvaldAagaard commented 11 months ago

When playing Texas I would expect 4S to be both minors.

EdwardPiwowar commented 11 months ago

Was a bug, but in the next build the bot no longer wants to bid 6D. image

ThorvaldAagaard commented 11 months ago

The missing cuebid is fixed, But I still think the Gerber followed by 6D is wrong - Can we add 4S as minors for Texas?

EdwardPiwowar commented 11 months ago

In the next version image