SafetyNet Failed with CustoMIUIzer but LSposed passes SafetyNet with CustoMIUIzer on. - Githubissues

ElderDrivers / EdXposedManager

Companion Android application for EdXposed

https://edxp.meowcat.org/

GNU General Public License v3.0

1.78k stars 247 forks source link

SafetyNet Failed with CustoMIUIzer but LSposed passes SafetyNet with CustoMIUIzer on. #214

Closed ghost closed 2 years ago

ghost commented 3 years ago

Include the following:

EdXposed Version: 0.5.2.2_4683-master_4683 (YAHFA)
Android Version: 11
Device Manufacturer: Xiaomi
Device Name: Redmi Note 8
EdXposed Manager Version: 4.6.2

Reproduction Steps

Enable CustoMIUIzer module in EdXposed Manager
Reboot
Check SafetyNet inside Magisk Manager

Expected Result

Attestation Succeeded with evalType Basic

Actual Result

Attestation Failed with evalType Basic

The module causing attestation to fail is specifically CustoMIUIzer, tried disabling all modules and enabling them one by one after reboots to find the culprit module. However, LSposed doesn't have this issue. LSposed doesn't have this issue: https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/71166028/135212707-6fdf4c47-8d4e-4fc0-b220-654c22ed2684.mp4 EdXposed has this issue, even with activation scope enabled from information found here: https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/71166028/135212613-52d341c7-ad79-4b67-896a-f4904640f2e8.mp4

YuMore233 commented 2 years ago

We don't play hide and seek anymore, just ignore SafetyNet. If you have the requirements of SafetyNet, please use the virtual framework, any global framework can not escape detection.