all lights are switched on when putting 1 on

[charlez79]

When i put 1 light on, the other that is in the same group does the same after 1 sec. I'm not using the group id. When i put the same light out, the other stays on. Changing the color does not have the same issue. Only the put on is responding to that command.

[En3rGy]

I can not reproduce that behaviour. Can you give more insight? Is this still an issue with the current version?

[charlez79]

Hi, you can close this topic. After rebooting the bridge the issue went away. Don't know what caused this in the fist place.

[charlez79]

Running the latest version. Today the issue is back, will try to do some network tracing one of the days Could you re-open the issue?

[charlez79]

I think the problem is related to the feedback. Central addresses made 2nd device turn on, removed those now. Now only feedback is wrong.

`

#

Time

Service

Flags

Prio

Source Address

Source Name

Destination Address

Destination Name

Hop Count

Type

DPT

Info

60

7/09/2023 20:21:05,059

from bus

Low

1.1.65

Tastsensor 3 comfort viervoudig F100

0/1/30

Licht Master Bedroom Bed Rechts Schakelen

6

GroupValue_Write

$01 | On

61

7/09/2023 20:21:05,466

from bus

High

1.5.1

Gira Homeserver

0/1/33

Licht Master Bedroom Bed Rechts Feedback Schakel

5

GroupValue_Write

$01 | On

66

7/09/2023 20:21:06,394

from bus

High

1.5.1

Gira Homeserver

0/1/23

Licht Master Bedroom Bed Links Feedback Schakel

5

GroupValue_Write

$01 | On

68

7/09/2023 20:21:06,449

from bus

High

1.5.1

Gira Homeserver

0/1/24

Licht Master Bedroom Bed Links Feedback Helderheid

5

GroupValue_Write

$3D | 24%

69

7/09/2023 20:21:06,556

from bus

High

1.5.1

Gira Homeserver

0/1/34

Licht Master Bedroom Bed Rechts Feedback Helderhei

5

GroupValue_Write

$3D | 24%

`

Address 0/1/23 is feedback of 2nd device that is reporting ON while no command is given.

Could it be that the status is not filtered to the corresponding configured ID?

[charlez79]

In your code you are looking for "on" in data stream to report the status of light/group. In my case i'm only turning 1 lamp on. The group will also report ON since 1 light of 2 in the group is ON. Should there not be a filter that only looks at the lamp status with ID of the lamp in stream instead of all "ON" statuses?

[En3rGy]

In line #147 of src/14100_Hue Group (14100).py all IDs not corresponding to the designated item are skipped, so the on check is only performed on those IDs.

But a valid ID is each ID correlating to a specific item. So e.g. item id, room id, group id ...

I don't know when which id will be triggered by the bridge.

Du you suggest a different behaviour?

[charlez79]

I saw that. I need more insight on what data is sent back. I'll try to run the simulation one of the days on my pc. To see what is happening

[charlez79]

i'm not able to get the simulator working, getting this error. Never worked with custom modules

Traceback (most recent call last): File "C:\tmp_fw_dir\HSL20_Framework\simulator.py", line 956, in File "C:\tmp_fw_dir\HSL20_Framework\simulator.py", line 824, in start File "C:\tmp_fw_dir\HSL20_Framework\simulator.py", line 374, in start File "C:\tmp_fw_dir\HSL20_Framework\simulator.py", line 428, in _init_logic File "", line 1, in File "Hue Group (14100)14100", line 464, in ImportError: No module named hue_lib.hue_item

[En3rGy]

Check out the readme.md to get info regarding the development environment. as soon a syou have set this up, you can run the unsit test in the ./tests directory an work with them thesting in your local environment.

[charlez79]

Those tests i can run now. But i would like to test the module itself. Missing singleton module, it's not in the package.

File "", line 1, in File "Hue Group (14100)14100", line 468, in ImportError: No module named singleton

[En3rGy]

added the missing file

[charlez79]

still not getting the simulation to work.

File "", line 1, in File "Hue Group (14100)14100", line 887, in File "Hue Group (14100)14100", line 505, in init NameError: global name 'random' is not defined

this code block is still causing issues, don't know why. When i remove the simulation starts, no errors, but nothing happens...

self.logger = logging.getLogger("{}".format(random.randint(0, 9999999)))

        # Create a custom logging level TRACE
        logging.addLevelName(TRACE, "TRACE")

        def trace(self, message, *args, **kws):
            if self.isEnabledFor(TRACE):
                self._log(TRACE, message, args, **kws)

        logging.Logger.trace = trace

        self.bridge = hue_bridge.HueBridge(self.logger)
        self.server = html_server.HtmlServer(self.logger)
        self.singleton = None
        self.eventstream_thread = threading.Thread()  # type: threading.Thread
        self.eventstream_keep_running = threading.Event()
        self.event_list = []
        self.msg_last = str()
        self.curr_bri = 0
        self.g_out_sbc = {}  # type: {int, object}
        self.debug = False  # type: bool

[En3rGy]

Todo:

• Switch a light in a group via Hue App.
• Record received messages from bridge
• Check code regarding correlation of IDs, or set vs. get

[En3rGy]

2x call of switch on / off is triggered by an input on the logic module:

1. https://github.com/En3rGy/14100_Hue/blob/40fdb2e489e0d74eacd7860c815ff4349b2277a0/src/14100_Hue%20Group%20(14100).py#L434
2. https://github.com/En3rGy/14100_Hue/blob/40fdb2e489e0d74eacd7860c815ff4349b2277a0/src/14100_Hue%20Group%20(14100).py#L463

Receiving messages of hue bridge results in https://github.com/En3rGy/14100_Hue/blob/40fdb2e489e0d74eacd7860c815ff4349b2277a0/src/14100_Hue%20Group%20(14100).py#L114 and triggers output signals only.

The observed behavior seems to not be the result of the logic module but the surrounding logic.

[En3rGy]

Seems like the light/switch does not turn on but the status output states that the light is on.

[charlez79]

Installed v3.10 and fist test seems to fixed the problem. Keep you updated