search

EngineerBetter / concourse-up

Deprecated - used Control Tower instead
https://github.com/EngineerBetter/control-tower
Apache License 2.0
203 stars 28 forks source link

Support Concourse 4.0 third-party authentication configuration in Concourse-Up #62

Open danyoung opened 5 years ago

danyoung commented 5 years ago

The Concourse-Up team are considering ways of addressing the change to how Concourse 4.0 handles authentication providers. We are aware that these changes will have left users without a way to support their previous auth configuration.

To help us make decisions, please comment on this issue to let us know which authentication methods you need to support and any preferences you have for doing this via the Concourse-Up tool. We suspect that Github.com oAuth is going to be a popular method, but we'd like to confirm this.

Many thanks!

Dan

archgrove commented 5 years ago

GitHub Oauth is indeed what we need. No special preferences for configuration, though it would be nice if we didn’t have to continually pass it to the CLI during updates.

ywei2017 commented 5 years ago

How about a plain old LDAP authentication? I think that will have huge applicability in the Enterprise? OAuth is fine, but unfortunately in most places, it is not nearly as ubiquitous and reliable as LDAP.

adamclark-dev commented 5 years ago

@danyoung definitely Github auth. For us we have all our developers, PM's and DM's using Github, so makes perfect sense for us to use Github as our central authentication system for developer related systems.

Thanks again for looking into this

crsimmons commented 5 years ago

@ywei2017 unfortunately LDAP does not appear to be configurable in the 4.0.0 Concourse BOSH release. It is in master though so presumably that will come in a future release. master vs 4.0.0

Once its configurable we can take a look at passing through support to Concourse-up.

danyoung commented 5 years ago

Thanks for the input folks. We have created a new Slack workspace to provide users with a place to ask questions, get support and discuss feature ideas: https://join.slack.com/t/concourse-up/shared_invite/enQtNDI1OTAwODczNDk0LTRkYTk0ZTg4NTliMDkzNWI3NjUwNzU3ZGE1YmQ1ZmQyMjlhMjVjNjI4ODUxMzM5OWJiNjRjYjZkMmI5M2RmNDQ

danyoung commented 5 years ago

For those looking for GitHub oAuth support, this is now in the latest releases. Please check https://github.com/EngineerBetter/concourse-up/releases