GPAv1 feedback
GPAv1 expresses concerns around the usage of the Persistence property and indicates that the definition of Persistence seems like an overlap with the definition of Liveness.
Reply
The “Correctness Analysis of IBFT” and “IBFT 2.0 Gray Paper” papers use a definition of Robustness for a distributed ledger which is in alignment with the literature in this area. Specifically, the Robustness, Persistence and Liveness properties as stated in the “Correctness Analysis of IBFT” and “IBFT 2.0 Gray Paper” have been introduced by Garay et al. (2015) (https://eprint.iacr.org/2014/765)
They have also been used in the following academic papers:
GPAv1 feedback GPAv1 expresses concerns around the usage of the Persistence property and indicates that the definition of Persistence seems like an overlap with the definition of Liveness.
Reply The “Correctness Analysis of IBFT” and “IBFT 2.0 Gray Paper” papers use a definition of Robustness for a distributed ledger which is in alignment with the literature in this area. Specifically, the Robustness, Persistence and Liveness properties as stated in the “Correctness Analysis of IBFT” and “IBFT 2.0 Gray Paper” have been introduced by Garay et al. (2015) (https://eprint.iacr.org/2014/765) They have also been used in the following academic papers: