EnvironmentOntology / envo

A community-driven ontology for the representation of environments
http://www.environmentontology.org
Creative Commons Zero v1.0 Universal
132 stars 52 forks source link

Bulk request for weather related "terms" #950

Open easr opened 4 years ago

easr commented 4 years ago

Hi Pier,

as discussed in our call, please find below the list of "terms" that will be great to have them in ENVO. As agreed, there will be a clear separation of the phenomena from the calculation/predictions, thus many of the "terms" below will end up reduced to one single term.

AverageCloudCover AverageDewpoint AverageRH AverageSurfaceTemperature AverageTemperature AvgLongwave(UpFlux) AvgNet(In-Out) AvgPollution/Haze AvgPressure AvgShortwave(DownFlux) AvgWindSpeed DateTime Daylight Elevation Evapotranspiration GeoHash Grid IceAccumulation Latitude LeafWetness LeafWetnessIndex LiquidAccumulation Longitude MaxCloudCover MaxDewpoint MaxLongwave(UpFlux) MaxNet(In-Out) MaxPollution/Haze MaxPressure MaxRH MaxShortwave(DownFlux) MaxSurfaceTemperature MaxTemperature MaxWindSpeed MinCloudCover MinDewpoint MinLongwave(UpFlux) MinPollution/Haze MinPressure MinRH MinShortwave(DownFlux) MinSurfaceTemperature MinTemperature MinWindSpeed Moisture% PoreWaterPressure PrecipAccumulation PrecipAccumulationforPeriod PrecipAccumulationnormalized PrecipDuration PrecipitationRate SnowAccumulation SnowDensity SnowDepth SurfaceAvgWindSpeed SurfaceGust SurfaceMaxWindSpeed SurfaceMinWindSpeed Temperature WindDirection

thanks a lot in advance! Erick

celineaubert commented 4 years ago

Hi Pier Luigi, we would like to jump on this conversation to asked for the weather related terms needed in AgrO:

CO2 concentration in the atmosphere Day length from twilight to twilight Photosynthetically active radiation (PAR) Photosynthetic photon flux density (PPFD) Solar radiation Runoff quantity daily Relative humidity, minimum daily Relative humidity, maximum daily Relative humidity at maximum temperature

Let us know if you need more precision. Thanks!

@marieALaporte

pbuttigieg commented 4 years ago

Hi @easr

🚧 Work in progress 🚧 Should wrap up tomorrow.

As discussed, ENVO will represent the real world phenomena that these labels are about, but won't include representations of mathematical operations or other abstractions. Those should be handled in another ontology or light-weight vocab/thesaurus. Ontologies like IAO or STATO may be of interest there.

At any rate, the aboutness links to ENVO classes can go quite a way to semantically enhance these concepts and link them to other resources (which may have separate mathematical conventions).

In scope

Term ENVO Class Comments
AverageCloudCover cloud cover
AverageDewpoint dew point
AverageRH humidity Consider using this PATO term - relative humidity is more a derived quantity than a metaphysical one.
AverageTemperature temperature of what? temperature is a PATO term, but ENVO can link it to an environmental entity (e.g. the atmosphere)
AvgLongwave(UpFlux) outgoing longwave radiation Confirm this is what is meant here
AvgPollution/Haze haze A class for "air pollution" could be created, if haze isn't sufficient
AvgPressure pressure of air assuming air pressure
AvgShortwave(DownFlux) shortwave radiation Can't guess the way "flux" is meant here.
AverageSurfaceTemperature temperature Surface of what? If we have better definition, then we can specialise this
AvgWindSpeed atmospheric wind speed The averaging is external
Elevation elevation a PATO term, ENVO can specialise this by linking it to an environmental entity. Better to post-compose though.
Evapotranspiration evapotranspiration
IceAccumulation ice accumulation process this is a process, we can also reference the actual ice mass if that's what's needed.
LiquidAccumulation liquid accumulation process as with the ice accumulation term, this is assumed to be the process rather than the accumulation of liquid itself.
MaxCloudCover cloud cover
MaxDewpoint dew point
MaxLongwave(UpFlux) outgoing longwave radiation Confirm this is what is meant here
MaxPollution/Haze haze
MaxPressure pressure of air assuming air pressure
MaxRH humidity Consider using this PATO term - relative humidity is more a derived quantity than a metaphysical one.
MaxShortwave(DownFlux) shortwave radiation Can't guess the way "flux" is meant here.
MaxSurfaceTemperature temperature Currently just the PATO temperature term; we can specialise it if we know what the surface is
MaxTemperature temperature of what? see above
MaxWindSpeed atmospheric wind speed
MinCloudCover cloud cover
MinDewpoint dew point
MinLongwave(UpFlux) outgoing longwave radiation Confirm this is what is meant here
MinPollution/Haze haze see above
MinPressure pressure of air assuming air pressure
MinRH humidity Consider using this PATO term - relative humidity is more a derived quantity than a metaphysical one.
MinShortwave(DownFlux) shortwave radiation Can't guess the way "flux" is meant here.
MinSurfaceTemperature temperature surface of what? See above.
MinTemperature temperature
MinWindSpeed atmospheric wind speed
PrecipAccumulation hydrological precipitation process we could specialise this more, to reference the process of accumulation
PrecipAccumulationforPeriod hydrological precipitation process we could specialise this more, but would need more information
PrecipAccumulationnormalized hydrological precipitation process This could be matched to an accumulation of precipitation class, but the rest would be left to the calculation semantics/vocab
PrecipDuration hydrological precipitation process we could specialise this more, to reference a durational quality of the process of accumulation
PrecipitationRate hydrological precipitation process We could have the rate quality asserted here, but this may be more useful if the system handles all the other calculated quantities internally.
SnowAccumulation snow accumulation process Assuming the process, but the mass can be created too
SnowDensity mass density of snow
SnowDepth depth of snow
SurfaceAvgWindSpeed atmospheric wind speed This can be specialised to "surface wind speed", but I'd need to know the surface of what. Also, better to post compose this.
SurfaceGust wind gust This can be further specialised to "surface gust", but more information on what is meant by surface is needed.
SurfaceMaxWindSpeed atmospheric wind speed This can be specialised to "surface wind speed", but I'd need to know the surface of what. Also, better to post compose this.
SurfaceMinWindSpeed atmospheric wind speed This can be specialised to "surface wind speed", but I'd need to know the surface of what. Also, better to post compose this.
Temperature temperature a PATO term, ENVO can specialise that to temperature of some environmental entity, but this is better post-composed
WindDirection atmospheric wind direction

Open questions / out of scope

Term Comments
PoreWaterPressure Sediment? Aquifers? Needs more information. Water pressure is available, however.
AvgNet(In-Out) Unclear
DateTime OWL Time may work
Daylight I can imagine ENVO creating a term like this, but I have the feeling this is far more operationally defined.
GeoHash GIS abstraction
Grid GIS abstraction
Latitude GIS abstraction
Longitude GIS abstraction
MaxNet(In-Out) unclear
LeafWetness Can be post-composed from PO:leaf and PATO:wetness. ENVO could pre-compose, but not sure if this is mission creep
LeafWetnessIndex this is a derived quantity from LeafWetness
Moisture% Unclear what this is referring to
pbuttigieg commented 4 years ago

@celineaubert @marieALaporte

Request ENVO Term Comments
CO2 concentration in the atmosphere concentration of carbon dioxide in an atmosphere
Day length from twilight to twilight What's the operational definition here? I can imagine this being a bit tricky to get right.
Photosynthetically active radiation (PAR) photosynthetically active radiation Represented as a process
Photosynthetic photon flux density (PPFD) This is an odd construction - what is a photosynthetic photon? I'm working on semantics of primary production and the definitional space there is quite a mess.
Solar radiation Solar radiation Created as an instance of stellar radiation with Sol (linked to Wikidata) as a participant.
Runoff quantity daily I'll need a definition to work with, finding quite a lot of variation.
Relative humidity, minimum daily See how RH is handled in response to @easr 's request. As a calculated abstraction, the only part that would be represented in ENVO would be the humidity of X, reusing PATO humidity.
Relative humidity, maximum daily See how RH is handled in response to @easr 's request.
Relative humidity at maximum temperature See how RH is handled in response to @easr 's request.
pbuttigieg commented 4 years ago

@easr any other last minute needs / tweaks before we release?

@celineaubert any feedback we can fold in to this release?

celineaubert commented 4 years ago
Hi @pbuttigieg, we have added our comments in the table. Let us know if you need further details. Request ENVO Term Comments
CO2 concentration in the atmosphere concentration of carbon dioxide in an atmosphere
Daylength from sunrise to sunset What's the operational definition here? I can imagine this being a bit tricky to get right. --> I changed twilight to twilight to sunrise to sunset. Twilight to twilight is used by ICASA. Synonym: Photoperiod
Photosynthetically active radiation (PAR) photosynthetically active radiation Represented as a process
Photosynthetic photon flux density (PPFD) This is an odd construction - what is a photosynthetic photon? I'm working on semantics of primary production and the definitional space there is quite a mess. --> Definition recommended by the Committee on Crop Terminology: Photosynthetic photon flux density (PPFD): the number of photons in the 400- to 700-nm waveband incident per unit time on a unit surface. Suggested units: μmol cm−2 s−1.(https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/immunology-and-microbiology/photosynthetic-photon-flux-density)
Solar radiation Solar radiation Created as an instance of stellar radiation with Sol (linked to Wikidata) as a participant.
Runoff volume I'll need a definition to work with, finding quite a lot of variation.-->Part of the precipitation, snow melt, or irrigation water that appears in uncontrolled (not regulated by a dam upstream) surface streams, rivers, drains or sewers.(https://www.usgs.gov/special-topic/water-science-school/science/runoff-surface-and-overland-water-runoff?qt-science_center_objects=0#qt-science_center_objects)
Relative humidity, minimum daily See how RH is handled in response to @easr 's request. As a calculated abstraction, the only part that would be represented in ENVO would be the humidity of X, reusing PATO humidity.
Relative humidity, maximum daily See how RH is handled in response to @easr 's request.
Relative humidity at maximum temperature See how RH is handled in response to @easr 's request.
easr commented 4 years ago

@pbuttigieg : are the ones 'In Scope' already in ENVO? Perhaps in a draft version?

easr commented 4 years ago

@pbuttigieg : I requested to my colleagues more info about the terms in the table 'open questions /out of scope'. I hope to get more news next week.

pbuttigieg commented 4 years ago

Thanks @easr

The ones above are in the editors' version, here

pbuttigieg commented 4 years ago

@easr - just a note that many of these are now live following our last release