Erkan-Yilmaz / Gridcoin-tasks

tasks, wishes, ideas, ... for the Gridcoin project

26 stars 1 forks source link

$50 or $100 bounty -> developping PoSv3 #43

Open Erkan-Yilmaz opened 7 years ago

Erkan-Yilmaz commented 7 years ago

technical details: here

quoting bounty from @frank0051 from there: " Given this, if it helps at all, I am going to vote yes on this item but I'm also willing to donate $50 or $100 to the development of this. While it's not much, maybe if other people are willing to do so it could be a bigger incentive. "

keep in mind:

there's a related poll still ongoing, see here

Erkan-Yilmaz commented 7 years ago

Vortac: "but can we really implement PoSv3 on a bounty? What if someone offers even a larger bounty tomorrow for reverting back to PoSv2? The vote has just begun on this, shouldn't we at least wait until the vote is over?" (forum)

cc @Vortac2

grctest commented 7 years ago

Regarding the poll, I agree that creating the poll was a premature knee-jerk. https://github.com/gridcoin/Gridcoin-Research/issues/106#issuecomment-273724480

Technical polls should last at least two months in order to drive attention to a topic.

A better poll would ask if they had read the github issue and huppdiwupp's proposals (as a pre-req checklist), then ask if they are content with the current pos:dpor balance or if they would prefer one of huppdiwupp's proposals as well as include 'posv3' features as options (fixed rewards, no offline interest gained).

We should also look into creating the survey using surveymonkey, it might get more info across than the wallet (though it wouldn't have mandate due to no balance/mag weight).

barton2526 commented 7 years ago

Seeing as I have just begun running the 7 day logging experiment, I see no point in getting ahead of ourselves with PoSv3. Let us get all the facts before we start jumping to development.

frank0051 commented 7 years ago

@barton2526 : I would like to see 30 days of history if at all possible - that would also help inform https://github.com/Erkan-Yilmaz/Gridcoin-tasks/issues/23

Thoughts?

barton2526 commented 7 years ago

@frank0051 Past 7 days I cannot guarantee full node stability (i.e. no downtime). To be fair, even 7 days is pushing it. If my internet or power goes out for even 1 second I lose all data with my current setup. Let's get the 7 day numbers and then work on a better solution.

Erkan-Yilmaz commented 7 years ago

2 new polls related to this topic:

Are you concerned regarding low network stake weight participation? (vote until March 13)
Should the DPOR:POS mechanism be rebalanced? (vote until June 11)

pwnorbitals commented 7 years ago

Updates ?

tomasbrod commented 7 years ago

The polls were misleading, even the results were not clear. I think there should be a series of very specific polls, like:

Should interest rate be reduced to xx%?
Should PoS interest be replaced by fixed block rewards?

All of them should have link to clear description of the topic, what the options mean and what are the expected effects, pros and cons of them. So voters can actually know what they are voting for.

45

Erkan-Yilmaz commented 7 years ago