search

Esri / coordinate-conversion-addin-dotnet

Addin for ArcMap and Pro for convenient coordinate conversion in Desktop.
Apache License 2.0
45 stars 20 forks source link

Points [graphics] in the map display cannot be selected #608

Closed dfoll closed 5 years ago

dfoll commented 5 years ago

Current behavior

When points [graphics] are in the map display, either from the Map Point Tool, or an imported CSV, those points cannot be selected with the Select Point tool.

Expected behavior

When points [graphics] are in the map display, either from the Map Point Tool, or an imported CSV, those points can be selected using the Select Point tool. When they are selected using the Select Point tool, the graphic should highlight with the typical green halo, and the coordinate should be highlighted in the list.

Found on ArcGIS Pro 2.3 and 2.4 build 19590 CC build 94 This was also observed with ArcMap 10.3.1 CC build 94

Did not observe on ArcMap with the released version of MT (227) but did observe on ArcGIS Pro even with the released version of Military Tools

dfoll commented 5 years ago

This issue was was found while testing issue #586

dfoll commented 5 years ago

@saip we would like to discuss if there will be time to bring in this one and #600 for this release.

@lfunkhouser fyi

dfoll commented 5 years ago

Tested build 125 which was built from this branch with @ljuru . Selecting points in the map is working as expected. Once a point is highlighted in the map though, it cannot be clicked again in the map to unselect it (does not unselect in the map or list). I would expect that both selecting/unselecting points is part of the way this would operate. @saip are you able to deliver that as part of this issue, or is that a larger effort?

UPDATE: 11June2019

Tested with build 127 today which was created from this branch for PR #612. Behavior is still as described in the original portion of this comment.

  1. Create some points in the map.
  2. Click a coordinate (in the LIst) the corresponding point/graphic gets a green highlight
  3. Click a point/graphic (in the map) the corresponding coordinate is highlighted.

this is correct so far

  1. Click a coordinate in the List.
  2. Click a different coordinate in the List.

Note that the selection switches from one coordinate to the next, unless you have Ctrl or Shift depressed

The same interaction in the map behaves differently

  1. Click a point/graphic in the map
  2. Click a different point/graphic in the map Note that the second point to be clicked is added to the set of selected points, instead of that being the new selection

@saip is it a large effort to make the selection behavior in the List and the selection behavior from the map behave the same? (Behavior of the list is correct and the typical PC beahvior is what many users are used to) Can we do that for this release, or is that a new issue that we should write up and deal with in a future release?

UPDATE2: 11June2019

@saip pointed out that I actually logged an issue asking for this with issue #534 but that was unassigned from @CTLocalGovTeam (I do not remember why). Because of work done in #584 this will be a larger effort. @lfunkhouser I suggest we move forward and call this (608) issue done for now, and add #534 into a future release.

dfoll commented 5 years ago
lfunkhouser commented 5 years ago

Tested on MT dev 307 and CC dev 139 Verified on solutionsdev website