search

Esri / file-geodatabase-api

FileGeodatabaseAPI_1.4 (1.4.0.183) The File Geodatabase C++ API for Windows, MacOS and Linux
Apache License 2.0
154 stars 60 forks source link

Polygons with arcs do not have the correct area #4

Open donnyv opened 7 years ago

donnyv commented 7 years ago

Did you guys fix this bug already? https://geonet.esri.com/thread/170662

lshipman commented 7 years ago

The API does not include the tools to make calculations under curves correctly. Possibly at a later release.

donnyv commented 7 years ago

But its almost a year old. How hard can it be to calculate an area of a surface that has curves?

lshipman commented 7 years ago

This issue was added as ENH-000095710 last year. To support this we need to port a geometry library from ArcGIS Desktop. There would be other benefits of this port, like support for more spatial selections (currently we only support envelope intersects), but it's requires a significant resource commitment that we can't make at this time. We would really like to do this, but other commitments make it unlikely.

lshipman commented 7 years ago

Sorry, didn't intend to close the issue. Hit the wrong button.

donnyv commented 6 years ago

Another year has passed and no fix.

donnyv commented 5 years ago

This bug is now 3 years old.

donnyv commented 4 years ago

Oh I missed our yearly post.

Still not fixed!

donnyv commented 3 years ago

Another year and another curvy shape has no area. Still not fixed!

donnyv commented 2 years ago

I missed my yearly anniversary post. Lets hope 2022 brings us a fix for this.

donnyv commented 1 year ago

I'm slacking, missed 2022. 6 YEARS NOW, WOW.

Pat28 commented 1 year ago

🤣