2525C Symbols Reported as not displaying correctly in ArcGIS Runtime

[csmoore]

Customer reports in NIM092427 that some symbols do not display in ArcGIS Runtime 10.1.1. Source of the problem is missing or erroneous symbols in the Style Files (and derived symbol dictionary).

Here are the issues reported with the symbols that do not display:

Number	Issue Reported	Source	Notes	Heirarchy Name	Symbol Id	Name
1	Does not display	Symbol Dictionary	Could Not Repro	WAR.GRDTRK.EQT.GRDVEH.CVLVEH.TRTRLF.SMAL	S_G_EVCTL-*****	SMALL/LIGHT BOX TRAILER
2	Does not display	Symbol Dictionary	Missing	WAR.GRDTRK.UNT.CS.MILINT.SIGINT.ECW.ARMWVH	S_G_UUMSEA*****	ARMORED WHEELED VEHICLE
3	Does not display	Symbol Dictionary	Missing	WAR.GRDTRK.UNT.CSS.ADMIN.MWR	S_G_USAW--*****	MORALE
4	Does not display	Symbol Dictionary	Missing	WAR.GRDTRK.UNT.CSS.ADMIN.MWR.CRP	S_G_USAWT-*****	MWR Theater
5	Does not display	Symbol Dictionary	Missing	WAR.GRDTRK.UNT.CSS.ADMIN.MWR.THT	S_G_USAWC-*****	MWR Corps
6	Does not display	Symbol Dictionary	Could Not Repro	EMS.INCDNT.CVDIS.DISPOP	O_I_R-----*****	CIVIL DISPLACED POPULATION
7	Does not display	Symbol Dictionary	Missing	EMS.INFSTR.TSP.ANCRG	WOS-HPBA--P----	SHIP ANCHORAGE
8	Does not display	Symbol Dictionary	Missing	METOC.AMPHC.STOG.WOSMIC.SUFWET	WAS-GNW-SWP----	SURFACE WET
9	Does not display	Symbol Dictionary	Missing	METOC.AMPHC.STOG.WSMIC.CSNALH	WAS-GSSCH-P----	COMPACT OR WET SNOW
10	Does not display	Symbol Dictionary	Missing	METOC.AMPHC.STOG.WSMIC.CWSNLH	WAS-GSSCL-P----	COMPACT OR WET SNOW
11	Does not display	Symbol Dictionary	Missing	METOC.AMPHC.STOG.WSMIC.LDSALH	WAS-GSSLH-P----	LOOSE DRY SNOW
12	Does not display	Symbol Dictionary	Missing	METOC.AMPHC.WTH.FG.FZSNV	WAS-WSFGFOP----	FOG - FREEZING, SKY NOT VISIBLE
13	Does not display	Symbol Dictionary	Missing	METOC.AMPHC.WTH.FG.FZSV	WAS-WSFGFVP----	FOG - FREEZING, SKY VISIBLE
14	Does not display	Symbol Dictionary	Missing	METOC.AMPHC.WTH.TROPLV	WAS-WST-LVP----	TROPOPAUSE LEVEL
15	Does not display	Symbol Dictionary	Missing	METOC.OCA.HYDGRY.ATN.LITHSE	WOS-HALH--P----	LIGHTHOUSE
16	Does not display	Symbol Dictionary	Missing	METOC.OCA.HYDGRY.ATN.PRH1.PRH2	WOS-HABP--P----	PERCHES/STAKES
17	Does not display	Symbol Dictionary	(“L--” misplaced)	METOC.OCA.HYDGRY.CSTHYD.FSH1.FSH2	WO-DHCF----L---	FORESHORE
18	Does not display	Unknown	May be a bug in Runtime if ID value is repeated/same	METOC.OCA.HYDGRY.CSTHYD.FSH1.FSH3	WO-DHCF-----A--	FORESHORE
19	Does not display	Symbol Dictionary	Missing	METOC.OCA.HYDGRY.DANHAZ.FLGRD1.FLGRD2	WOS-HHDF--P----	FOUL GROUND
20	Does not display	Symbol Dictionary	Missing	METOC.OCA.HYDGRY.DANHAZ.REEF	WOS-HHDR---L---	REEF Line
21	Does not display	Symbol Dictionary	Missing	METOC.OCA.HYDGRY.PRTHBR.FAC.LNDRNG	WOS-HPM-R-P----	LANDING RING
22	Does not display	Symbol Dictionary	“L--” misplaced	METOC.OCA.HYDGRY.PRTHBR.FAC.OSLF2	WO-DHPMO---L---	OFFSHORE Line
23	Does not display	Unknown	May be a bug in Runtime if ID value is repeated/same	METOC.OCA.HYDGRY.PRTHBR.FAC.OSLF3	WO-DHPMO----A--	OFFSHORE
24	Does not display	Symbol Dictionary	Missing	METOC.OCA.HYDGRY.PRTHBR.PRT.ANCRG1	WOS-HPBA--P----	ANCHORAGE
25	Does not display	Symbol Dictionary	Missing	METOC.OCA.HYDGRY.TDECUR.TDEG	WOS-TCCTG-P----	TIDE GAUGE
26	Does not display	Symbol Dictionary	Missing	METOC.OCA.MMD.SUBCBL	WO-DMCA----L---	SUBMARINE CABLE
27	Does not display	Symbol Dictionary	“L--” misplaced		WO-DHPBA---L---	Anchorage Line
28	Does not display with GetSymbolImage	Style File	Bad Symbol (Hostile Only)	WAR.GRDTRK.UNT.CS.CBRN.CML.RECON.WARMVH	SHGPUUACRW-----	Wheeled Armored Vehicle
29	Minor-wavy lines extend just outside frame	Style File	Note: looks fine in style file	WAR.GRDTRK.UNT.CS.MILINT.SIGINT.ECW.JMG	S_G_UUMSEJ-----	Jamming
30	Does not display	Symbol Dictionary	Missing	METOC.OCA.HYDGRY.DANHAZ.REEF	WOS-HHDR--P----	REEF Point
31	Does not display	Symbol Dictionary	Missing	METOC.OCA.HYDGRY.PRTHBR.FAC.OSLF	WO-DHPMO--P----	OFFSHORE Point
32	Does not display	StyleFile	Bad Symbol Rep	METOC.AMPHC.BDAWTH.MVFR	WA-DBAMV--P----	Bounded Area VFR

[csmoore]

Can someone test this and see which of these are still an issue at 10.2

[bmoore1]

(1) SFGPEVCTL-*****, (27) WO-DHPBA---L---,SFGPUUMSEJ----- work for me, but the rest of the images do not show up.

Tested with https://github.com/Esri/military-features-data/tree/master/test/TestExportSymbol

10.2 Runtime & https://github.com/Esri/military-features-data/tree/master/data/mil2525c/dictionary

[eacheson]

re: number 23 in table, using the ExportSymbols.java: ‘Offshore Loading Facility Area’, ID is WO-DHPMO-- :png is output but blank – png file is called ‘WO-DHPMO----A-- presumably for ‘area’ ‘Offshore Loading Facility Line’, ID is WO-DHPMO-- : png is output but blank – png file is called ‘WO-DHPMO----L-- presumably for ‘line’

[csmoore]

As the table indicates "WO-DHPMO----L-- " does have an error (the L is in the wrong column/location), but I am genuinely baffled to explain why the "WO-DHPMO----A-- " doesn't draw/export so this one needs some more investigation.

[eacheson]

I've looked at all the output pngs and there's one more which was just blank: WA-DBAMV----A-- No others that I could see, just the two in my previous comment. When I try to add the corresponding symbol (Bounded Areas - Marginal Visual Flight Rule) to my Java app (via SymbolDictionaryApp.java), it froze my app.

[csmoore]

@conklinbd Updating the Style Files fixed the other issues, but did not fix the issue with the following not displaying/exporting, so an issue will need to be opened in Runtime. There seems to be an issue with the METOC symbols when the start (first 10 chars) of the SymbolId are the same (none of the other Appendices repeat the first 10 chars).

These symbols do not export correctly. To repro, call getSymbolImage with these IDs: WO-DHCF-----A-- WO-DHCF----L---

WOS-HPBA--P---- WOS-HPBA---L--- WOS-HPBA----A--

WO-DHPMO----A-- (Note: exports but incorrectly exports point version - WO-DHPMO--P----) WO-DHPMO---L--- (Note: exports but incorrectly exports point version - WO-DHPMO--P----)

[csmoore]

I have updated the tester to read in and export from the 1st column in a .csv file. To test the fixes to this issue: 1) copy and paste the text below into a .csv and 2) run/use the updated exporter/tester at https://github.com/csmoore/military-features-data/tree/master/test/TestExportSymbolsAll:

SFGPEVCTL-*_,1,Does not display,Symbol Dictionary,Could Not Repro,WAR.GRDTRK.EQT.GRDVEH.CVLVEH.TRTRLF.SMAL,S_GEVCTL-**,SMALL/LIGHT BOX TRAILER SHGPEVCTL-**,1,Does not display,Symbol Dictionary,Could Not Repro,WAR.GRDTRK.EQT.GRDVEH.CVLVEH.TRTRLF.SMAL,S_G_EVCTL-**,SMALL/LIGHT BOX TRAILER SNGPEVCTL-**,1,Does not display,Symbol Dictionary,Could Not Repro,WAR.GRDTRK.EQT.GRDVEH.CVLVEH.TRTRLF.SMAL,S_G_EVCTL-**,SMALL/LIGHT BOX TRAILER SUGPEVCTL-**,1,Does not display,Symbol Dictionary,Could Not Repro,WAR.GRDTRK.EQT.GRDVEH.CVLVEH.TRTRLF.SMAL,S_G_EVCTL-**,SMALL/LIGHT BOX TRAILER SFGPUUMSEA**,2,Does not display,Symbol Dictionary,Missing,WAR.GRDTRK.UNT.CS.MILINT.SIGINT.ECW.ARMWVH,S_G_UUMSEA**,ARMORED WHEELED VEHICLE SFGPUUMSEA**,2,Does not display,Symbol Dictionary,Missing,WAR.GRDTRK.UNT.CS.MILINT.SIGINT.ECW.ARMWVH,S_G_UUMSEA**,ARMORED WHEELED VEHICLE SFGPUUMSEA**,2,Does not display,Symbol Dictionary,Missing,WAR.GRDTRK.UNT.CS.MILINT.SIGINT.ECW.ARMWVH,S_G_UUMSEA**,ARMORED WHEELED VEHICLE SFGPUUMSEA**,2,Does not display,Symbol Dictionary,Missing,WAR.GRDTRK.UNT.CS.MILINT.SIGINT.ECW.ARMWVH,S_G_UUMSEA**,ARMORED WHEELED VEHICLE SFGPUSAW--**,3,Does not display,Symbol Dictionary,Missing,WAR.GRDTRK.UNT.CSS.ADMIN.MWR,S_G_USAW--**,MORALE SHGPUSAW--**,3,Does not display,Symbol Dictionary,Missing,WAR.GRDTRK.UNT.CSS.ADMIN.MWR,S_G_USAW--**,MORALE SNGPUSAW--**,3,Does not display,Symbol Dictionary,Missing,WAR.GRDTRK.UNT.CSS.ADMIN.MWR,S_G_USAW--**,MORALE SUGPUSAW--**,3,Does not display,Symbol Dictionary,Missing,WAR.GRDTRK.UNT.CSS.ADMIN.MWR,S_G_USAW--**,MORALE SFGPUSAWT-**,4,Does not display,Symbol Dictionary,Missing,WAR.GRDTRK.UNT.CSS.ADMIN.MWR.CRP,S_G_USAWT-**,MWR Theater SHGPUSAWT-**,4,Does not display,Symbol Dictionary,Missing,WAR.GRDTRK.UNT.CSS.ADMIN.MWR.CRP,S_G_USAWT-**,MWR Theater SNGPUSAWT-**,4,Does not display,Symbol Dictionary,Missing,WAR.GRDTRK.UNT.CSS.ADMIN.MWR.CRP,S_G_USAWT-**,MWR Theater SUGPUSAWT-**,4,Does not display,Symbol Dictionary,Missing,WAR.GRDTRK.UNT.CSS.ADMIN.MWR.CRP,S_G_USAWT-**,MWR Theater SFGPUSAWC-**,5,Does not display,Symbol Dictionary,Missing,WAR.GRDTRK.UNT.CSS.ADMIN.MWR.THT,S_G_USAWC-**,MWR Corps SHGPUSAWC-**,5,Does not display,Symbol Dictionary,Missing,WAR.GRDTRK.UNT.CSS.ADMIN.MWR.THT,S_G_USAWC-**,MWR Corps SNGPUSAWC-**,5,Does not display,Symbol Dictionary,Missing,WAR.GRDTRK.UNT.CSS.ADMIN.MWR.THT,S_G_USAWC-**,MWR Corps SUGPUSAWC-**,5,Does not display,Symbol Dictionary,Missing,WAR.GRDTRK.UNT.CSS.ADMIN.MWR.THT,S_G_USAWC-**,MWR Corps OFIPR-----**,6,Does not display,Symbol Dictionary,Could Not Repro,EMS.INCDNT.CVDIS.DISPOP,O_I_R----**,CIVIL DISPLACED OHIPR-----**,6,Does not display,Symbol Dictionary,Could Not Repro,EMS.INCDNT.CVDIS.DISPOP,O_I_R----**,CIVIL DISPLACED OUIPR-----**,6,Does not display,Symbol Dictionary,Could Not Repro,EMS.INCDNT.CVDIS.DISPOP,O_I_R----**,CIVIL DISPLACED ONIPR-----**,6,Does not display,Symbol Dictionary,Could Not Repro,EMS.INCDNT.CVDIS.DISPOP,O_I_R----**_,CIVIL DISPLACED WOS-HPBA--P----,7,Does not display,Symbol Dictionary,Missing,EMS.INFSTR.TSP.ANCRG,WOS-HPBA--P----,SHIP ANCHORAGE WAS-GNW-SWP----,8,Does not display,Symbol Dictionary,Missing,METOC.AMPHC.STOG.WOSMIC.SUFWET,WAS-GNW-SWP----,SURFACE WET WAS-GSSCH-P----,9,Does not display,Symbol Dictionary,Missing,METOC.AMPHC.STOG.WSMIC.CSNALH,WAS-GSSCH-P---,COMPACT OR WET SNOW WAS-GSSCL-P----,10,Does not display,Symbol Dictionary,Missing,METOC.AMPHC.STOG.WSMIC.CWSNLH,WAS-GSSCL-P----,COMPACT OR WET SNOW WAS-GSSLH-P----,11,Does not display,Symbol Dictionary,Missing,METOC.AMPHC.STOG.WSMIC.LDSALH,WAS-GSSLH-P----,LOOSE DRY SNOW WAS-WSFGFOP----,12,Does not display,Symbol Dictionary,Missing,METOC.AMPHC.WTH.FG.FZSNV,WAS-WSFGFOP----,"FOG - FREEZING, SKY NOT VISIBLE" WAS-WSFGFVP----,13,Does not display,Symbol Dictionary,Missing,METOC.AMPHC.WTH.FG.FZSV,WAS-WSFGFVP----,"FOG - FREEZING, SKY VISIBLE" WAS-WST-LVP----,14,Does not display,Symbol Dictionary,Missing,METOC.AMPHC.WTH.TROPLV,WAS-WST-LVP----,TROPOPAUSE LEVEL WOS-HALH--P----,15,Does not display,Symbol Dictionary,Missing,METOC.OCA.HYDGRY.ATN.LITHSE,WOS-HALH--P----,LIGHTHOUSE WOS-HABP--P----,16,Does not display,Symbol Dictionary,Missing,METOC.OCA.HYDGRY.ATN.PRH1.PRH2,WOS-HABP--P----,PERCHES/STAKES WO-DHCF----L---,17,Does not display,Symbol Dictionary,(“L--” misplaced),METOC.OCA.HYDGRY.CSTHYD.FSH1.FSH2,WO-DHCF----L---,FORESHORE WO-DHCF-----A--,18,Does not display,Unknown,May be a bug in Runtime if ID value is repeated/same,METOC.OCA.HYDGRY.CSTHYD.FSH1.FSH3,WO-DHCF-----A--,FORESHORE WOS-HHDF--P----,19,Does not display,Symbol Dictionary,Missing,METOC.OCA.HYDGRY.DANHAZ.FLGRD1.FLGRD2,WOS-HHDF--P----,FOUL GROUND WOS-HHDR---L---,20,Does not display,Symbol Dictionary,Missing,METOC.OCA.HYDGRY.DANHAZ.REEF,WOS-HHDR---L---,REEF Line WOS-HPM-R-P----,21,Does not display,Symbol Dictionary,Missing,METOC.OCA.HYDGRY.PRTHBR.FAC.LNDRNG,WOS-HPM-R-P----,LANDING RING WO-DHPMO---L---,22,Does not display,Symbol Dictionary,“L--” misplaced,METOC.OCA.HYDGRY.PRTHBR.FAC.OSLF2,WO-DHPMO---L---,OFFSHORE Line WO-DHPMO---A---,23,Does not display,Unknown,May be a bug in Runtime if ID value is repeated/same,METOC.OCA.HYDGRY.PRTHBR.FAC.OSLF3,WO-DHPMO---A--,OFFSHORE WOS-HPBA--P----,24,Does not display,Symbol Dictionary,Missing,METOC.OCA.HYDGRY.PRTHBR.PRT.ANCRG1,WOS-HPBA--P----,ANCHORAGE WOS-TCCTG-P----,25,Does not display,Symbol Dictionary,Missing,METOC.OCA.HYDGRY.TDECUR.TDEG,WOS-TCCTG-P----,TIDE GAUGE WO-DMCA----L---,26,Does not display,Symbol Dictionary,Missing,METOC.OCA.MMD.SUBCBL,WO-DMCA----L---,SUBMARINE CABLE WO-DHPBA---L---,27,Does not display,Symbol Dictionary,“L--” misplaced,,WO-DHPBA---L---,Anchorage Line SHGPUUACRW-----,28,Does not display with GetSymbolImage,Style File,Bad Symbol (Hostile Only),WAR.GRDTRK.UNT.CS.CBRN.CML.RECON.WARMVH,SHGPUUACRW -----, SFGPUUMSEJ-----,29,Symbol Lines,Style File,Minor-wavy lines extend just outside frame,WAR.GRDTRK.UNT.CS.MILINT.SIGINT.ECW.JMG,S_G_UUMSEJ-----,Note: look fine in style file SHGPUUMSEJ-----,29,Symbol Lines,Style File,Minor-wavy lines extend just outside frame,WAR.GRDTRK.UNT.CS.MILINT.SIGINT.ECW.JMG,S_G_UUMSEJ-----,Note: look fine in style file SUGPUUMSEJ-----,29,Symbol Lines,Style File,Minor-wavy lines extend just outside frame,WAR.GRDTRK.UNT.CS.MILINT.SIGINT.ECW.JMG,S_G_UUMSEJ-----,Note: look fine in style file SNGPUUMSEJ-----,29,Symbol Lines,Style File,Minor-wavy lines extend just outside frame,WAR.GRDTRK.UNT.CS.MILINT.SIGINT.ECW.JMG,S_G*UUMSEJ-----,Note: look fine in style file WOS-HHDR--P----,30,Does not display,Symbol Dictionary,Missing,METOC.OCA.HYDGRY.DANHAZ.REEF,WOS-HHDR--P----,REEF Point WO-DHPMO--P----,31,Does not display,Symbol Dictionary,Missing,METOC.OCA.HYDGRY.PRTHBR.FAC.OSLF,WO-DHPMO--P----,OFFSHORE Point WA-DBAMV--P----,32,Does not display,StyleFile,Bad Symbol Rep,METOC.AMPHC.BDAWTH.MVFR,WA-DBAMV--P----,Bounded Area VFR

[dfoll]

Noticed that WOS-HPBA--P---- WO-DHCF-----A-- and WO-DHCF----L--- do not display... .png displays as solid black box

[dfoll]

tested these, defect #14 was opened for remaining defects found

[dfoll]

test data https://github.com/Esri/military-features-data/blob/master/test/TestReproData/Mil2525CErrorsPre10.2.2.csv

runtime 10.2.2 build 509