ExPaNDS-eu / ExPaNDS-experimental-techniques-ontology

EU Photon and Neutron Ontologies (task 3.2)
8 stars 3 forks source link

Shouldn't neutron single crystal diffraction be a subclass of neutron diffraction? #112

Open RKrahl opened 3 months ago

RKrahl commented 3 months ago

neutron diffraction and neutron single crystal diffraction are both direct subclasses of neutron probe, which seems to be odd. I'd rather suggest that neutron single crystal diffraction should be a subclass of neutron diffraction. Or even more generally: I'd suggest any technique that is both a subclass of neutron probe and of diffraction should be a subclass of neutron diffraction.

spc93 commented 1 week ago

112

Problem: 'neutron single crystal diffraction' is not currently a subclass of 'neutron diffraction'

Current definition: subclass of: single crystal diffraction
neutron probe

Proposed new definition: subclass of: single crystal diffraction
neutron diffraction

Since 'neutron diffraction' is subclass of 'neutron probe' this change should only have the effect of making 'neutron single crystal diffraction' a subclass of 'neutron diffraction'.

Test results (current version):

Properties of PaNET.PaNET01236 (Label: neutron single crystal diffraction) in http://purl.org/pan-science/PaNET/PaNET.owl:

Superclasses (direct and given by equivalent classes):

PaNET.PaNET00101 neutron probe PaNET.PaNET01029 single crystal diffraction

No. of direct_superclasses of PaNET.PaNET01236: 2


All superclasses:

PaNET.PaNET00001 photon and neutron technique PaNET.PaNET00002 defined by experimental probe PaNET.PaNET00003 defined by experimental physical process PaNET.PaNET00101 neutron probe PaNET.PaNET00200 scattering technique PaNET.PaNET01020 elastic scattering PaNET.PaNET01022 diffraction PaNET.PaNET01026 atomic scale diffraction PaNET.PaNET01027 atomic scale diffraction 3D volume PaNET.PaNET01028 atomic scale diffraction 3D volume 3D periodic PaNET.PaNET01029 single crystal diffraction PaNET.PaNET01236 neutron single crystal diffraction obo.CHMO_0000182
wiki.Q133900

No. of superclasses of PaNET.PaNET01236 (including self): 14


Subclasses (children):

PaNET.PaNET01236 neutron single crystal diffraction PaNET.PaNET01237 thermal neutron single crystal diffraction

No. of subclasses of PaNET.PaNET01236 (including self): 2


Test results (new version):

Properties of PaNET.PaNET01236 (Label: neutron single crystal diffraction) in /dls/science/users/spc93/tmp/PaNET.owl:

Superclasses (direct and given by equivalent classes):

PaNET.PaNET01029 single crystal diffraction PaNET.PaNET01217 neutron diffraction

No. of direct_superclasses of PaNET.PaNET01236: 2


All superclasses:

PaNET.PaNET00001 photon and neutron technique PaNET.PaNET00002 defined by experimental probe PaNET.PaNET00003 defined by experimental physical process PaNET.PaNET00101 neutron probe PaNET.PaNET00200 scattering technique PaNET.PaNET01020 elastic scattering PaNET.PaNET01022 diffraction PaNET.PaNET01026 atomic scale diffraction PaNET.PaNET01027 atomic scale diffraction 3D volume PaNET.PaNET01028 atomic scale diffraction 3D volume 3D periodic PaNET.PaNET01029 single crystal diffraction PaNET.PaNET01217 neutron diffraction PaNET.PaNET01236 neutron single crystal diffraction obo.CHMO_0000182
wiki.Q133900

No. of superclasses of PaNET.PaNET01236 (including self): 15


Subclasses (children):

PaNET.PaNET01236 neutron single crystal diffraction PaNET.PaNET01237 thermal neutron single crystal diffraction

No. of subclasses of PaNET.PaNET01236 (including self): 2