search

ExPaNDS-eu / ExPaNDS-experimental-techniques-ontology

EU Photon and Neutron Ontologies (task 3.2)
8 stars 4 forks source link

x-ray absorption spectroscopy is not a subclass of x-ray absorption #118

Closed RKrahl closed 1 month ago

RKrahl commented 4 months ago

One would assume that x-ray absorption spectroscopy should be a subclass of x-ray absorption, but it isn't.

At the moment, we have:

├── x-ray probe
│    ├── x-ray absorption
│    ├── x-ray absorption spectroscopy

I'd rather expect:

├── x-ray probe
│    ├── x-ray absorption
│    │    └── x-ray absorption spectroscopy
spc93 commented 3 months ago

118

Problem: 'x-ray absorption spectroscopy' is not currently a subclass of 'x-ray absorption'

Current definition: subclass of: x-ray probe atomic core excitation absorption spectroscopy

Proposed new definition: subclass of: x-ray absorption atomic core excitation absorption spectroscopy

Since 'x-ray absorption' is subclass of 'x-ray probe' this change should only have the effect of making 'x-ray absorption spectroscopy' a subclass of 'x-ray absorption'

Test results (current version):

Properties of PaNET.PaNET01196 (Label: x-ray absorption spectroscopy) in http://purl.org/pan-science/PaNET/PaNET.owl:

Superclasses (direct and given by equivalent classes):

PaNET.PaNET01054 atomic core excitation PaNET.PaNET01135 absorption spectroscopy PaNET.PaNET01156 x-ray spectroscopy

No. of direct_superclasses of PaNET.PaNET01196: 3

All superclasses:

PaNET.PaNET00001 photon and neutron technique PaNET.PaNET00002 defined by experimental probe PaNET.PaNET00003 defined by experimental physical process PaNET.PaNET00004 defined by functional dependence PaNET.PaNET00100 photon probe PaNET.PaNET00202 absorption technique PaNET.PaNET00206 resonance phenomenon PaNET.PaNET00300 versus energy PaNET.PaNET01012 x-ray probe PaNET.PaNET01053 electronic excitation PaNET.PaNET01054 atomic core excitation PaNET.PaNET01125 spectroscopy PaNET.PaNET01135 absorption spectroscopy PaNET.PaNET01156 x-ray spectroscopy PaNET.PaNET01196 x-ray absorption spectroscopy (Alt. Labels: XAS)

No. of superclasses of PaNET.PaNET01196 (including self): 15

Subclasses (children):

PaNET.PaNET01196 x-ray absorption spectroscopy (Alt. Labels: XAS) PaNET.PaNET01197 x-ray absorption fine structure (Alt. Labels: XAFS) PaNET.PaNET01198 extended x-ray absorption fine structure (Alt. Labels: EXAFS) PaNET.PaNET01199 x-ray absorption near edge structure (Alt. Labels: NEXAFS, XANES) PaNET.PaNET01321 energy dispersive extended x-ray absorption fine structure (Alt. Labels: ED-EXAFS, EDE) PaNET.PaNET01322 microfocus x-ray absorption spectroscopy

No. of subclasses of PaNET.PaNET01196 (including self): 6

Test results (new version):

Properties of PaNET.PaNET01196 (Label: x-ray absorption spectroscopy) in /dls/science/users/spc93/tmp/PaNET.owl:

Superclasses (direct and given by equivalent classes):

PaNET.PaNET01054 atomic core excitation PaNET.PaNET01135 absorption spectroscopy PaNET.PaNET01156 x-ray spectroscopy PaNET.PaNET01227 x-ray absorption

No. of direct_superclasses of PaNET.PaNET01196: 4

All superclasses:

PaNET.PaNET00001 photon and neutron technique PaNET.PaNET00002 defined by experimental probe PaNET.PaNET00003 defined by experimental physical process PaNET.PaNET00004 defined by functional dependence PaNET.PaNET00100 photon probe PaNET.PaNET00202 absorption technique PaNET.PaNET00206 resonance phenomenon PaNET.PaNET00300 versus energy PaNET.PaNET01012 x-ray probe PaNET.PaNET01053 electronic excitation PaNET.PaNET01054 atomic core excitation PaNET.PaNET01125 spectroscopy PaNET.PaNET01135 absorption spectroscopy PaNET.PaNET01156 x-ray spectroscopy PaNET.PaNET01196 x-ray absorption spectroscopy (Alt. Labels: XAS) PaNET.PaNET01227 x-ray absorption

No. of superclasses of PaNET.PaNET01196 (including self): 16

Subclasses (children):

PaNET.PaNET01196 x-ray absorption spectroscopy (Alt. Labels: XAS) PaNET.PaNET01197 x-ray absorption fine structure (Alt. Labels: XAFS) PaNET.PaNET01198 extended x-ray absorption fine structure (Alt. Labels: EXAFS) PaNET.PaNET01199 x-ray absorption near edge structure (Alt. Labels: NEXAFS, XANES) PaNET.PaNET01321 energy dispersive extended x-ray absorption fine structure (Alt. Labels: ED-EXAFS, EDE) PaNET.PaNET01322 microfocus x-ray absorption spectroscopy

No. of subclasses of PaNET.PaNET01196 (including self): 6