shareNodes not implemented for FQDN nodes

[kreynoldsf5]

Environment

• Application Services Version: 3.19.0 (I can check lower versions)
• BIG-IP Version: BIG-IP 14.1.2.3 Build 0.0.5 Point Release 3

Summary

shareNodes does not apply to fqdn nodes

Steps To Reproduce

Steps to reproduce the behavior:

1. Submit a declaration with the following Pool class:

       "web_pool": {
         "class": "Pool",
         "loadBalancingMode": "round-robin",
         "monitors": [
           "http"
         ],
         "members": [
   
             { 
               "servicePort": 8080,
               "hostname": "f5demoapp.demo.internal",
               "addressDiscovery": "fqdn",
               "autoPopulate": true,
               "shareNodes": true
             }
           ,
             { 
               "servicePort": 8181,
               "hostname": "f5demoapp.demo.internal",
               "addressDiscovery": "fqdn",
               "autoPopulate": true,
               "shareNodes": true
             }
                     ] 
       }

2. Observe the config that gets created on a BIG-IP. The node is in the tenant partition and the ephemeral node is in Common.

3. A subsequent declaration using the same fqdn node will fail.

   "msg": "declaration is invalid. /tenant-app2/app2.demo.internal/web_pool/members: pool member /tenant-app2/app2.demo.internal/web_pool/members/0 fqdn hostname f5demoapp.demo.internal conflicts with bigip fqdn node /tenant-app1/f5demoapp.demo.internal"

Expected Behavior

When "shareNodes": true is used for fqdn nodes, all components of the fqdn node should be placed in /Common. This behavior should be consistent regardless of addressDiscovery.

Actual Behavior

see above.

[dstokesf5]

Thank you for reporting this. I have copied it to our internal product backlog as AUTOTOOL-1556.

[tizianorosato-gr]

we had similar issues with AS 3.23 on BIGIP 14.1.4 but upgrading to AS3 3.26 solved the problem.

[dstokesf5]

@kreynoldsf5 Are you still seeing this issue on AS3 3.26+?

[dstokesf5]

Closing for inactivity. If you are still encountering issue, please reopen this ticket for a file a new one.

[DahlPatric]

Does ShardNode works for FQDN nodes? I do get error as like this "conflicts with bigip fqdn node" { "servicePort": 443, "hostname": "abc.local", "addressDiscovery": "fqdn", "shareNodes": true }