[Convention Tags] Entries missing from certain tags/categories

FabricMC / fabric

Essential hooks for modding with Fabric.

Apache License 2.0

2.31k stars 404 forks source link

[Convention Tags] Entries missing from certain tags/categories #3895

Closed Patbox closed 2 months ago

Patbox commented 3 months ago

[ ] Maces are missing from c:tools/melee_weapons
[ ] Flint and steel is missing from c:tools

TelepathicGrunt commented 3 months ago

Flint and steel is a weird one. It's like on border of tool and not. Where would the line be drawn of what is a tool? What about Name Tags or Lead? Would people have any negative experience if flint and steel was in Tools tag when compared to the other items in Tools tag?

apple502j commented 3 months ago

I believe a tool is something with a durability (excluding armor and perhaps weapons).

Patbox commented 3 months ago

Weapons are included in tools tag via inclusion of their tags. But yes, flint and steel is a tool in both looks and usecase, it's just not mining tool. But yeah, you can go with mc wiki definition for that https://minecraft.wiki/w/Tool

TelepathicGrunt commented 3 months ago

Should flint and steel only be in tools or should be there be a subcategory for it? c:tools/firestarter?