search

FeenixServerProject / Archangel_2.4.3_Bugtracker

This is the official Issue tracker for the Archangel 2.4.3 realm https://www.wow-one.com
78 stars 74 forks source link

[Warrior] [Piercing howl]+[Demoralizing shout] #3625

Open teddys opened 9 years ago

teddys commented 9 years ago

How to reproduce: You need 2 clients, on one create an orc warrior .levelup 70 .learn 25203 (demoralizing shout) .mod hp 1000000000 spec into piercing howl (does not matter which talents you choose in order to get piercing howl) .t test On the other one create a human warrior .levelup 70 .learn 71 ( def stance ) .learn 23920(spell reflection) .mod hp 1000000000 .t test

Start attacking eachother with the warriors, then once you have enough rage, use spell reflection on the human one, switch over to orc warrior --> use piercing howl/demoralizing shout and notice it gets reflected.

Current situation : Piercing howl + demo shout can be spell reflected and resisted even though warrior is hit capped. Expected : Piercing howl + demoralizing shout can not be spell reflected and can not be resisted if warrior is hit capped and target does not have any movement imparing effect resist chance ( piercing howl ) same goes for demoralizing shout and aoe resist effects.

braide commented 9 years ago

should mention that Intimidating Shout also should be affected by hit, and not resist (only by talents) if you're hit capped. Seems like the debuffs of shouts are physical but the actual shout is a spell (that is before it is applied to a target), this also means that targets resists a lot of shouts (maybe not if you're spell hit capped) when they should not resist at all.

ghost commented 9 years ago

i think all shouts count as spells. I only find some proof form 3.2.

(wowhead)[http://www.wowhead.com/forums&topic=121472/what-affects-taunt-miss#p1421562]

  • Do Demo Shout and Challenging Shout use spell hit too?
  • yes, they run off spell hit too

(gamefaqs)[http://www.gamefaqs.com/boards/534914-world-of-warcraft/50973988/559978139]

...Taunt and Demoralizing Shout apparently use the 16% Spell Hit cap...

braide commented 9 years ago

That is wotlk patches, but ye seems unclear. According to wowhead http://www.wowhead.com/spell=1160/demoralizing-shout demo shout cannot miss. There are no changes apperent in the changelogs about that either. The "cannot miss" flag is not on other shouts.

teddys commented 9 years ago

http://www.twitch.tv/teddysxyz/v/16603716 18 30 - 18 50 shouts are definetly not supposed to be reflected by warriors spell reflection :D