FingerLakesRunnersClub / Leaderboards

Leaderboards for the FLRC Challenge and Trail Circuit
https://fingerlakesrunners.org
GNU General Public License v3.0
0 stars 0 forks source link

How to handle avg age grade for small 1-29 team #119

Closed SteveDesmond-ca closed 2 years ago

SteveDesmond-ca commented 2 years ago

I noticed the 1-29 team is rather small this year, which may give an unintended advantage with the "average age grade" team score calculation.

Options, in probably order of fairness:

SteveDesmond-ca commented 2 years ago

Just checked to see that this is still an issue as we're meeting the end, but the only course that's really affected is Treman since that's the only one where 1-29 isn't in last for age grade anyway.

I think the best solution (other than just ignoring it😅) may actually be to fill in the missing age grades with 0's, so e.g. for the mile, they'd have the 7 fastest age grades that were actually run, and then add 3 0's to make 10 records.

We're doing something similar elsewhere in some scoring algorithm, but can't remember exactly where. Thoughts @adamengst?

adamengst commented 2 years ago

Given that it's clearly not going to affect anything, I'm cool with just leaving it be. But I tend to agree with you that filling in the missing records with 0's is the best option, since that's the negative that should cause the team to encourage more completions. Thanks for staying on top of this!

SteveDesmond-ca commented 2 years ago

Implemented in 6806539 -- no visible change as team 1-29 already dropped to last on Treman