search

Flow-Launcher / Flow.Launcher

:mag: Quick file search & app launcher for Windows with community-made plugins
https://flowlauncher.com
MIT License
8.14k stars 317 forks source link

Discussion: Removal of result highlighting #68

Closed jjw24 closed 4 years ago

jjw24 commented 4 years ago

Just wanting to get some thoughts on whether we should remove result highlighting.

It was introduced as a way of combating the messy search results back then in Wox, but over the many iterations this has been improved to the point I dont think it's a necessity any more, and results now is clear enough. Any missed results would be more or less edge cases which we should just take as opportunity to further improve search experience.

Thoughts? @Flow-Launcher/team + anyone else

jjw24 commented 4 years ago

Also want to add- removal of search precision option in Settings tab. Regular is a good standard and 'Low' + 'None' is not utilised much.

Anyone out there still use the other two options?

JohnTheGr8 commented 4 years ago

Just wanting to get some thoughts on whether we should remove result highlighting.

It was introduced as a way of combating the messy search results back then in Wox, but over the many iterations this has been improved to the point I dont think it's a necessity any more, and results now is clear enough. Any missed results would be more or less edge cases which we should just take as opportunity to further improve search experience.

Thoughts? @Flow-Launcher/team + anyone else

Does highlighting cause any problems other than the icon flickering issue (which is probably fixable)? Whatever performance/complexity overhead it adds is probably negligible.

I agree with what you said, it's not really a necessity any more... the core plugins could do without highlighting. But, at the same time, I think it's a nice to have, and that there could be potential use-cases for it from 3rd-party plugins that we haven't considered.

I'd vote to keep it.

pc223 commented 4 years ago

I think the whole point of highlighting is for helping user to understand why Wox return those results. Maybe we can expand from that idea, let highlighting is a feature for debugging or advanced user mode. And add more features (even simple as log more detail info) to help user understand the search algorithm (why this item have lower point than that item etc ...)

For my personal usage, I have to do this to debug the "grading algorithm" and observe the performance of plugins :D

image

Also want to add- removal of search precision option in Settings tab. Regular is a good standard and 'Low' + 'None' is not utilised much. Anyone out there still use the other two options?

I have to hardcode my algorithm in Wox to make it work like I want :smile: so I'm not using these options.

I think people like the certainty when use launcher like Wox, it feels really different from, say, Google Search, like, we rarely want to see the results, we glance the results, and glance wants low cognitive energy => certainty is needed (But this maybe depends on plugins, so I don't know...Maybe different algorithm for different plugin?... :thinking:)

kalaschnik commented 4 years ago

Just to be clear we are talking about this: image

jjw24 commented 4 years ago

Just to be clear we are talking about this: image

Hey sorry if i am not clear. I am referring to the highlighting of characters in results from the query search, in the screenshot, it is the bolding of 'Code' in results such as "Visual Studio Code" and "Codec Config 3: Codec Config"

kalaschnik commented 4 years ago

Ah I see. I actually like that feature. Just to verify how my query was matched...

jjw24 commented 4 years ago

Result highlighting will be kept as per your feedback. I may add an option to toggle it on/off as a personal preference.