search

FlowCrypt / flowcrypt-browser

FlowCrypt Browser extension for Chrome and Firefox
https://flowcrypt.com
Other
373 stars 46 forks source link

Firefox tab container breaks message decrypt #3838

Open shenada opened 3 years ago

shenada commented 3 years ago

Description:

Firefox tab container breaks message decrypt but works with new tab open as 'No Container'.

Test Environment:

Arch x86_64 Windows 10 / Linux Firefox 87-90

How to reproduce issue:

  1. install Mozilla official extension Firefox Multi-Account Containers.
  2. install FlowCrypt Firefox extension.
  3. Login to Gmail in any tab container then 'Secure Compose' a new test encrypted mail to self.
  4. open the test mail

Expected result:

Decrypted mail message shows.

Actual result:

'Could not load message due to network error. retry' shows and 'retry' never works.

tomholub commented 3 years ago

Thank you for the report - indeed the extension is not compatible with Firefox Containers or Google Tab Groups at the moment.

tomholub commented 3 years ago

We'd like to eventually make it compatible, but it's not on current roadmap so I'm unable to say if/when this could be done. One workaround would be to use a separate Firefox profile that does not use containers, to run FlowCrypt. That will automatically "containerize" it from other usage without affecting function.

Superpigdots commented 2 years ago

@shenada yeah, I had told the developers about this too like I told you on the Google Containers github page. I think that they really don't care about this issue. It has gone unfixed for the better part of a year now and seems like it would be a priority considering that most PGP users would probably be using Firefox and Containers. It is a real shame as it essentially breaks 50% of the functionality of this PGP solution for me.

@tomholub with all due respect for you trying to at least propose an alternate solution, having a whole separate Firefox account just to work around this issue is beyond practical since Firefox is not designed for multiple accounts to be logged in at once and logging in/out of different Firefox accounts EVERY time I want to check Gmail is a total pain.

tomholub commented 2 years ago

I understand the inconvenience and sympathize with it. I'll be happy to review merge PR that fixes it if you can a competent and willing person to implement it. Please understand that we are providing a software solution for free, and have limited resources to address user requests, especially the more complicated ones coming from a minority of users on a minority platform.