FossifyOrg / General-Discussion

A place for discussing all apps in general plus anything else you want to say.
https://www.fossify.org
65 stars 3 forks source link

Apps cannot communicate "internal memory" contacts with other Fossify apps. #215

Closed that1cutie closed 2 days ago

that1cutie commented 3 weeks ago

Checklist

Affected Android/Custom ROM version

Android 13

Affected device model

Moto 5g 2023 Stylus

How did you install the apps?

F-Droid / IzzyOnDroid

Which apps are affected?

Contacts, Phone

Steps to reproduce the bug

Go to Fossiffy Contacts. Go to settings. Set contact storage to internal (not shared with other apps). Exit Fossify Contacts. Open Fossify Phone. No Contacts available. (This is not the case for Messenger or any other Fossify application I tried, the rest work great.)

Expected behavior

Setting Contacts to internal storage should allow the Fossify Phone application to read the Fossify Contacts storage.

Actual behavior

Setting contact storage location to internal memory (not shared with other apps) in "Contacts" makes it so that the "Phone" application cannot read contacts. So if I am not logged into Google on my phone, I cannot use the phone application to call anyone from my contacts. This kind of defeats the point of having internal storage, or even making a FOSS replacement for the Google Contacts application altogether. (Yes I know how dumb this might sound if you didn't use SimpleMobileTools internal contact storage, please read the next field.)

Screenshots/Screen recordings

No screenies necessary. Problem clearly described.

Additional information

The SimpleMobileTools version was in fact able to communicate internally stored contacts with their "Dialer" application, which is what your "Phone" application is based upon. SimpleMobileTools applications had the full ability to communicate with one-another even when set to internal storage. It is my strong hope that this issue be fixed soon. I am excited to jump ship to Fossify that I may see new updates to the security and practicality of my device. Thank you very much for all your hard work.

Aga-C commented 3 weeks ago

Go to settings. Set contact storage to internal (not shared with other apps).

There's no such thing in settings. Do you mean setting contact storage while editing a contact?

Also, in Fossify Phone, can you check if in the filter options you have enabled Phone storage (not visible by other apps)?

that1cutie commented 2 days ago

Thank you, sorry for creating a whole topic about it. It just works now. I didn't even have to change that setting. :')