Hoes with Sharpness V does not boost its damage

[KienNgoQwert]

my netherite hoe stayed 4 damage

[Fourmisain]

If you mean the damage value in the tooltip, that's normal vanilla behavior:

The weapon will still deal more damage when attacking. I just one-shot a cow with a sharpness 100 hoe.

[KienNgoQwert]

weird, i tested it against another player and its still 4

[Fourmisain]

How exactly did you test the damage?

Also, what version are you on? Any other mods?

[KienNgoQwert]

1. Ask a guy to take off his armor to test the damage, he said it took 2 hearts (4 damage)
2. 1.21 Quilt (0.26.4 beta-5 i think? its the latest version of quilt)
3. Only performance mods, AAW is installed only server-side tho (if it helps, i have vanilla refresh installed server-side)

[Fourmisain]

Hm... not sure what's happening then. Axes Are Weapons doesn't actually modify Sharpness or the actual damage, it only makes the item enchantable (and changes the durability loss), so you should get the exact same result with a give command like /give @s netherite_hoe[minecraft:enchantments={sharpness:5}] on a vanilla server.

Gonna try if I can reproduce this.

[KienNgoQwert]

if it helps, apparently sharpness 10 does boost damage, but 5 does nada

[Fourmisain]

Hold on! Vanilla hoes only deal 1 damage in vanilla, even Netherite ones.

Sharpness V will increase that damage by 0.5 * level + 0.5 = 3, so we're up to 4. In other words, everything is working as expected!

[Fourmisain]

I should say: The "All Tools Are Weapons" options are mainly meant to be used in conjunction with other mods that change combat mechanics of those tools. It's basically just one piece of the puzzle.

[KienNgoQwert]

oh thank you i misread the stats

[Fourmisain]

P.S. I think in 1.21 it is also possible to change the damage of hoes via a datapack (e.g. by modifying the item's damage component) if you so wish.

k, gonna see this issue as resolved!