search

FrSkyRC / ETHOS-Feedback-Community

Feedback & suggestions are welcomed here for ETHOS by FrSky
190 stars 85 forks source link

X12S Add Sbus in and Sbus out on Module bay for Student Trainer Wireless Link #2339

Closed yak-54 closed 1 year ago

yak-54 commented 1 year ago

X12S add Sbus in and Sbus out on module bay for wireless trainer System Add support for Access or D16 V2

OpenTX_Manual_Deutsch_1-99 (1)-combined_Page_112_Image_0001

mawzthefinn commented 1 year ago

This is functionally a duplicate of #784.

Closing off in favour of that one. SBus on the DSC sockets, Module bay and S.Port jack would all be useful additions.

yak-54 commented 1 year ago

i dont won't it on dsc plug just on the module bay pins in the module bay some time my students have there own Taranis X9D Plus then i use the cable ? Sbus in and out in the module bay i have 3 TX modules that use sbus with Ardupilot as i would say there would thousands out there in the same bout that cant use them i cant see what the issues is the same radio runs sbus in and out in module bay pins on edgdtx and opentx and fros

yak-54 commented 1 year ago

and i have some with JR radios and spectrum i still help out that i use the cable for

yak-54 commented 1 year ago

This is functionally a duplicate of #784.

Closing off in favour of that one. SBus on the DSC sockets, Module bay and S.Port jack would all be useful additions.

don't think its better i would say its isolates more of the older frsky radio

yak-54 commented 1 year ago

In use the DCS plug with an sbus to Cppm now works fine with the master on ethos with all the older Accst systems with the XM receiver but now they are getting newer X20 and X18 and i don't wish use the cable as it gets in the road 20210204_173745

mawzthefinn commented 1 year ago

Be aware there’s fundamentally 2 different requests here.

  1. Accept SBus input for trainer
  2. Accept trainer input on the module bay

The first must happen before any variant of these requests will occur. Right now SBus is not supported as trainer input anywhere. Once SBus trainer support is there it’s just a matter of designating which potential inputs are enabled for it.

Note that full MPM Telemetry support would functionally solve this as well (as MPM modules can function as FrSky ACCST receivers) so long as their telemetry is supported for Trainer input

As an FYI - the Linker modules only work on a couple older radios anyways (X9D+, X12S and maybe the original QX7), the ACCESS radios don’t support them IIRC, even on OpenTX.