FrSkyRC / ETHOS-Feedback-Community

Feedback & suggestions are welcomed here for ETHOS by FrSky
172 stars 82 forks source link

Suite 1.5.5 - New Mac DMG is Corrupt (ZIP is OK) #3923

Closed spoke2570 closed 2 weeks ago

spoke2570 commented 3 weeks ago

The dreaded Error -36....

The Finder can’t complete the operation because some data in “Ethos Suite.app” can’t be read or written. (Error code -36)

Both of the last 2 images work fine, but this one is not so good. Standard drag and drop using the shortcut in the mounted image, and manual drag and drop.

Nicholas-Luoyi commented 3 weeks ago

Sorry. I cannot understand this one

mgsanna commented 3 weeks ago

Same here on MacBook Pro intel, the .dmg is corrupted,

Screenshot 2024-04-26 alle 09 28 13

same error of @spoke2570

But the zipped ethos suite works... installed manually....

Screenshot 2024-04-26 alle 09 33 23
kramgrand commented 3 weeks ago

Hello Just for info, I usually install the latest using the .dmg download option rather than update. I loaded from the .dmg early yesterday morning without any issues. MacBook Air M2 Regards Mark.

LeoCheung123 commented 3 weeks ago

Same problem here. Error -36. MacBook Pro 2023 running Sonoma 14.4.1

It also removes the existing version of Ethos Suite (v.1.5.0 which was functioning fine). Which is a little inconvenient.

kramgrand commented 3 weeks ago

Just for the shear hell of it, I downloaded it again to reinstall over the top of the existing. It's broken...

Screenshot 2024-04-26 at 14 53 00
kramgrand commented 3 weeks ago

Thought you might be interested. I restored my original download of the .dmg via Apple TimeMachine and it worked without error. Could the copy on the server somehow become corrupted?

Screenshot 2024-04-26 at 15 04 25
spoke2570 commented 3 weeks ago

The zipped version works perfect. Restore is working. It takes a while for Suite to recognize the drives after the OS has them, but its working well.

dap35 commented 2 weeks ago

I ran into the same issue with downloading the dmg file and attempting to install. The zip file is fine.

tysonfromcanada commented 2 weeks ago

same here, m2 air

Vermaarp commented 2 weeks ago

same issue in my mac m1

Nicholas-Luoyi commented 2 weeks ago

It may be a package issue. Would you please try the latest one?

spoke2570 commented 2 weeks ago

The new package works. Manual authorization of the app was not necessary. Backup and Restore functions work correctly. Model images seem to resize for the different window sizes better. So far about 10 openings and closings with no weird "quit unexpectedly" warnings after the app has been closed using best practices. -> The install was a little notchy requiring to manually quit Suite, transfer the package to the Apps folder, open the app. (see image)

Screen Shot 2024-04-30 at 6 44 51 AM

-> It took a seriously long time for the package to move the package from the mounted disk image to the app folder. (several minutes)

Conclude: 1.5.6 seems to work correctly, but the best Suite Update experience still was going from 1.5.0 to 1.5.1. The update was announced by the app at open and the update was seamless with no manual operations required except to initiate the update from the alert window within the Suite app.

I would love to see suites basic operation be a marriage of the solid operation that I have seen with Suite 1.5.6, the update speed of most previous versions, and the seamless update operation from the 1.5.0 to 1.5.1 update.

I consider this issue closed, but I will let Nicholas close this thread.

Nicholas-Luoyi commented 2 weeks ago

Thanks for keeping testing and contacting! It seems that everyone has his/her preference. Because for me, I do like the update notification won't disturb me. So I think the best choice is to leave the choice to the user. I will add selection like "auto install / manual install"

spoke2570 commented 2 weeks ago

The pictured result is sort of the worst of both worlds. I pressed the "install update" button and the downloaded image mounted, opened. Suite is still open behind this. So choosing the most obvious path of dropping the app on the provided shortcut results in failure because the Suite is still open. Ya I would close Suite first, but that is not what the screen is implying.

It was nice not to manually approve the app.

I feel like the 3 options should be to download the package or install the package or cancel the operation. That way there is clear expectation of what happens when a user hits the button.